Abstract
Ontological security theory (OST) provides a unique account of how state Self-identity is formed and reformed in international relations. OST postulates that state Self-identity is usefully understood by inquiring into the foundation of a state's sense of Self: its autobiographical narrative. We seek to amend this line of argument by further suggesting that the autobiographical narratives of states are ‘gendered’. Feminist theorizing about the relationship between gender and power implies that the dominant autobiographical narrative of state Self-identity is ‘gendered’ masculine. The power of this masculinized autobiographical narrative flows from an ‘internal othering’ process of counter ‘feminine’ autobiographical narratives that exist alongside the masculinized autobiographical narrative. Our goal is to suggest that opportunities do arise for counter ‘feminine’ narratives to challenge the dominant autobiographical narrative due to their interdependence and we explicate two practices by which masculinized narratives can be engaged, challenged and disrupted.
Notes
1
For a non-OST rendering of this idea, see Ringmar (Citation1996, 66–92).
2
Laing used the term ‘ontology’ in his words ‘because it appears to be the best adverbial or adjectival derivative of “being”’ (1969, 40). Catarina Kinnvall defines ontological security as ‘a security of being, a sense of confidence and trust that the world is what it appears to be’ (Kinnvall Citation2004, 746). See also McSweeney (Citation1999).
3
Mitzen's (Citation2006) work on OST is well-known, but it focuses less upon the autobiographical narrative endemic to ontological security-seeking.
8
‘Power’ here is considered to be multifaceted, drawing from material relations (for example within capitalist production), but also can be found in the norms and values of society which are internalized by actors and through their ‘actions’ become reproduced. For some reviews of ‘power’ as a concept see Lukes (Citation2005 [1974]) and for a description of the ‘productive’ aspects of ‘power’ see Foucault (Citation1977, 3–33, 135–169).
9
These potentially include: Marxian feminism (Hartsock Citation1983); Liberal feminism (Okin Citation1989); as well as post-structural feminism (Weedon Citation1987) to name a few. Therefore, we need to be careful in ascribing certain ‘concepts’ or ‘arguments’ to feminism as a broad theoretical tradition given its plurality of foci. Nevertheless, it seems that there is a broad agreement within feminist theory about the construction of ‘gender’. The subsequent analysis which links ‘gender’ to ‘power’ might not be generalizable across feminist theory, but is nevertheless included as a way to show how differences in ‘gender’ can result in marginalization and domination.
10
It should also be noted that feminists have critiqued what it means to be ‘female’ by suggesting that the term itself represents a western conception of ‘woman’, which excludes or marginalizes non-western conceptions of ‘female’. See Mohanty (Citation1991).
11
It is important to note that OST seems to equate moral action with rational action. Therefore, feminists could suggest that this reifies the state and further entrenches ‘masculinized’ conceptions of the state. Yet, this would be problematic for two reasons. First, OST (like feminism) argues that a state's sense of self is constructed. Therefore, there is nothing ‘natural’ to the autobiographical narrative that constitutes a state's sense of self. Secondly, OST's conception of rationality is not necessarily equal to the ‘rational actor model’ where agents are disembodied rational utility-maximizers. Indeed, OST suggests that to be rational also includes being moral: to have an understanding of one's needs as a ‘self’ and to act in ways which meet those existential needs. The ‘self’ here is not abstracted nor is it individuated: instead, it is embedded in a narrative-structure of meaning.
12
The work of some feminist authors indicates that the subjugated ‘other’ is not necessarily always gendered ‘feminine’ as differences within the social category of ‘masculinity’ can result in the denigration and marginalization of certain forms of ‘masculinity’ as well (Young Citation2003, 3–4).
13
This is an important difference between the mothers groups in Nicaragua, who while protesting the Somoza government, still largely supported the Sandinistas once they were in power, and those mother groups in Argentina and Chile, who mobilized against a military government throughout their protest (see Ruddick Citation1989).
14
In this regard, see the exchange between US night-time talk show host David Letterman and his guest, neoconservative cable host Bill O'Reilly, on the 3 January 2006 episode of Late Night with David Letterman, where the topic of Sheehan's protest developed into a debate over the meaning of the Iraq War. Letterman at one time asked O'Reilly: ‘So, why are we there in the first place?’ before concluding: ‘I'm very concerned about people like yourself who don't have nothing but endless sympathy for a woman like Cindy Sheehan, honest to Christ’. The exchange illustrates both the political cover that comes from being a grieving mother, as well as the debate over the meaning of a foreign policy action. Transcript at < http://mediamatters.org/items/200601060009>, accessed 14 May 2009
15
For instance, Sheehan was asked in late 2006 the following question by one cable news anchor: ‘Why go stand side-by-side by Hugo Chavez in Venezuela? Why do that? I mean, it sounds like—would you rather live under Hugo Chavez than George Bush?’ Norah O'Donnell, ‘Hardball’, 5 July 2006, available at < http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/13735484/>, accessed 14 May 2009
16
Polling from the period of Sheehan's protest indicated a large drop in support for the Iraq War, although we must also note that other events which may explain this drop, such as the bungled US response to Hurricane Katrina, occurred during the same time, see < http://pollingreport.com/iraq2.htm>, accessed 14 May 2009
17
For example, Hutchings (Citation2000, 124–126) indicates that to assume ‘women’ are always ‘for’ peace is a mistake; indeed, the use of violence, while context-dependent, is not ‘ruled out’ a priori, and to assume this is to reinforce a gendered assumption that ‘women’ in general and ‘feminists’ in particular are always committed to non-violence and therefore, by extension are ‘passive’.
18
Of course, some might argue there is no contradiction here: sometimes violence or force is needed to allow for the ‘freeing’ of oppressed peoples. Yet, it is important note that the use of force (and the chance of killing those who are supposed to be ‘freed’) can be contradictory. Moreover, the assumption that force can be used for freedom presupposes a ‘gendered’ understanding of the means by which certain ends can be attained.
19
One interesting question becomes the mechanisms of dissent. While not developed here, it might be possible that certain technologies (the internet, instant messaging, texting, blogging) could provide the mechanisms for alternative narratives to develop. As new technologies arise, it will be theoretically important to try to understand how marginalized groups can create alternative sources of information, and try to disrupt the dominant autobiographical narrative.
Ringmar
,
Erik
.
1996
.
Identity, interest and action: a cultural explanation of Sweden's intervention in the Thirty Years War
,
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Kinnvall
,
Catarina
.
2004
.
Globalization and religion nationalism: self, identity and the search for ontological security
.
Political Psychology
,
25
(
4
)
:
741
–
767
.
McSweeney
,
Bill
.
1999
.
Security, identity and interests: a sociology of international relations
,
Cambridge, United Kingdom
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Mitzen
,
Jennifer
.
2006
.
Ontological security in world politics: state identity and the security dilemma
.
European Journal of International Relations
,
12
(
3
)
:
341
–
370
.
Hall
,
Rodney B
.
2001
.
Applying the ‘Self/Other’ nexus in International Relations
.
International Studies Review
,
3
(
1
)
:
101
–
111
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1979
.
Women in Western political thought
,
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1989
.
Justice, gender and the family
,
New York
:
Basic Books
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1998
.
“
Gender, the public, and the private
”
. In
Feminism and Politics
,
Edited by:
Phillips
,
Anne
.
116
–
141
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Elshtain
,
Jean Bethke
.
1981
.
Public man/private woman: women in social and political thought
,
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
.
Pateman
,
Carole
.
1988
.
The sexual contract
,
Stanford
:
Stanford University Press
.
Kymlicka
,
Will
.
2002
.
“
Feminism
”
. In
Contemporary political philosophy
,
Edited by:
Kymlicka
,
Will
.
377
–
430
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Allison
,
Miranda
.
2007
.
Wartime sexual violence: women's human rights and questions of masculinity
.
Review of International Studies
,
33
:
75
–
90
.
Ashworth
,
Georgina
.
1999
.
“
The silencing of women
”
. In
Human rights in global politics
,
Edited by:
Dunne
,
Tim
and
Wheeler
,
Nicholas J
.
259
–
276
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Barbara
,
Ehrenreich
and
Russell Hochschild
,
Arlie
, eds.
2002
.
Global woman
,
New York
:
Metropolitan Books
.
Enloe
,
Cynthia
.
2000
.
Maneuvers: the international politics of militarizing women's lives
,
Berkeley and Los Angeles
:
University of California Press
.
Enloe
,
Cynthia
.
2003
.
Creeping militarization
.
International Feminist Journal of Politics
,
5
(
3
)
:
463
–
464
.
Enloe
,
Cynthia
.
2007
.
Globalization and militarism: feminists make the link
,
New York
:
Rowman and Littlefield
.
Hutchings
,
Kimberly
.
2000
.
Towards a feminist international ethics
.
Review of International Studies
,
26
:
111
–
130
.
Locher
,
Birgit
and
Prügel
,
Elisabeth
.
2001
.
“
Feminism: constructivism's other pedigree
”
. In
Constructing International Relations: the next generation
,
Edited by:
Fierke
,
Karin
and
Jøgensen
,
Knud Erik
.
76
–
92
.
New York
:
ME Sharpe
.
Mohanty
,
Chandra Talpade
.
1991
.
“
Under Western eyes: feminist scholarship and colonial discourses
”
. In
Third World women and the politics of feminism
,
Edited by:
Mohanty
,
Chandra Talpade
,
Russo
,
Ann
and
Torres
,
Lourdes
.
51
–
80
.
Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
.
Ong
,
Aihwa
.
1994
.
“
Colonialism and modernity: feminist re-presentations of women in non-Western societies
”
. In
Theorizing feminism: parallel trends in the Humanities and Social Sciences
,
Edited by:
Hermann
,
Anne C
and
Stewart
,
Abigail J
.
372
–
381
.
Boulder
:
Westview Press
.
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
1992a
.
“
Introduction
”
. In
Gendered states: feminist (re)visions of International Relations theory
,
Edited by:
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
31
–
64
.
Boulder
:
Lynne Rienner Publishers
.
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
1992b
.
“
Security and sovereign states: what is at stake in taking Feminism seriously?
”
. In
Gendered states: feminist (re)visions of International Relations theory
,
Edited by:
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
1
–
30
.
Boulder
:
Lynne Rienner Publishers
.
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
1992c
.
Transgressing boundaries: theories of knowledge, gender and International Relations
.
Millennium: Journal of International Studies
,
21
(
2
)
:
183
–
206
.
Peterson
,
V Spike
.
1994
.
Social hierarchies as systems of power
.
PS: Political Science and Politics
,
27
(
4
)
:
719
–
720
.
Elshtain
,
Jean Bethke
.
1981
.
Public man/private woman: women in social and political thought
,
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
.
Peterson
,
V Spike
and
True
,
Jacqui
.
1998
.
“
New times” and new conversations
”
. In
The ‘man’ question in International Relations
,
Edited by:
True
,
Jacqui
.
14
–
27
.
Boulder
:
West View Press
.
Ruddick
,
Sara
.
2001
.
“
Notes towards a feminist peace politics
”
. In
Theorizing feminism: parallel trends in the humanities and social sciences
,
Edited by:
Herrmann
,
Anne C
and
Stewart
,
Abigail J
.
196
–
214
.
Boulder
:
Westview Press
.
Sjoberg
,
Laura
.
2006
.
Gendered realities of the immunity principle: why gender analysis needs feminism
.
International Studies Quarterly
,
50
:
889
–
910
.
Sylvester
,
Christine
.
1994
.
Feminist theory and international relations in a postmodern era
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Tickner
,
J Ann
.
1992
.
Gender in International Relations
,
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Tickner
,
J Ann
.
1995
.
“
Hans Morgenthau's principles of political realism: a reformulation
”
. In
International theory: critical investigations
,
Edited by:
Derian
,
James Der
.
53
–
71
.
New York
:
New York University Press
.
Tickner
,
J Ann
.
1996
.
Gendering world politics
,
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Tickner
,
J Ann
.
1997
.
“
Identity in international relations theory: feminist perspectives
”
. In
The return of culture and identity in IR theory
,
Edited by:
Lapid
,
Josef
and
Kratochwil
,
Fredrich
.
147
–
163
.
London
:
Lynne Rienner Publishers
.
Tickner
,
J Ann
.
2005
.
What is your research program? Some feminist answers to international relations methodological questions
.
International Studies Quarterly
,
49
(
1
)
:
21
Whitworth
,
Sandra
.
1994
.
Feminism and international relations
,
New York
:
St Martin's
.
Zalewski
,
Marysia
.
2006
.
“
Distracted reflections on the production, narration, and refusal of feminist knowledge in international relations
”
. In
Feminist methodologies for International Relations
,
Edited by:
Ackerly
,
Brooke A
,
Stern
,
Maria
and
True
,
Jacqui
.
42
–
61
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Bailely
,
Cathryn
.
1997
.
Making waves and drawing lines: the politics of defining the vicissitudes of feminism
.
Hypatia
,
12
(
3
)
:
1
–
7
.
Baumgardner
,
Jennifer
and
Richards
,
Amy
.
2000
.
Manifesta: young women, feminism and the future
,
New York: Farrar
:
Straus and Grioux
.
Buchan
,
Morag
.
1999
.
Women in Plato's political theory
,
New York
:
Routledge
.
Butler
,
Judith
.
1988
.
Performative acts and gender constitution: an essay in phenomenology and feminist theory
.
Theatre
,
49
(
1
)
:
519
–
531
.
Butler
,
Judith
.
1999
.
Gender trouble: feminism and the subversion of identity
,
New York
:
Routledge
.
Butler
,
Judith
.
2003
.
“
Contingent foundations: feminism and the question of “postmodernism”
. In
Contemporary political thought: a reader and guide
,
Edited by:
Finlayson
,
Alan
.
344
–
350
.
New York
:
New York University Press
.
Connell
,
RW
.
1987
.
Gender and power
,
Stanford, California
:
Stanford University Press
.
Daly
,
Mary
.
1978
.
Gyn/ecology: the metaethics of radical feminism
,
Boston
:
Beacon
.
De Beauvoir
,
Simone
.
1989 [1952]
.
The second sex
,
New York
:
Vintage Books
.
Dworkin
,
Andrea
.
1987
.
Intercourse
,
New York
:
Free Press
.
Elshtain
,
Jean Bethke
.
1981
.
Public man/private woman: women in social and political thought
,
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
.
Frye
,
Marilyn
.
1983
.
Politics and reality
,
Los Angeles
:
The Crossing Press
.
Hartsock
,
Nancy CM
.
1983
.
Money, sex and power: toward a feminist historical materialism
,
New York
:
Longman
.
Kymlicka
,
Will
.
2002
.
“
Feminism
”
. In
Contemporary political philosophy
,
Edited by:
Kymlicka
,
Will
.
377
–
430
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Mill
,
John Stuart
.
1997 [1869]
.
The subjection of women
,
New York
:
Dover Publications
.
Millet
,
Kate
.
1970
.
Sexual politics
,
New York
:
Ballantine Books
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1979
.
Women in Western political thought
,
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1989
.
Justice, gender and the family
,
New York
:
Basic Books
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1998
.
“
Gender, the public, and the private
”
. In
Feminism and Politics
,
Edited by:
Phillips
,
Anne
.
116
–
141
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Pateman
,
Carole
.
1988
.
The sexual contract
,
Stanford
:
Stanford University Press
.
Phillips
,
Anne
.
1993
.
Democracy and difference
,
University Park
:
Pennsylvania State University Press
.
Rich
,
Adrienne
.
1986
.
Of woman born
,
New York
:
WW Norton & Company
.
Rosen
,
Ruth
.
2000
.
The world split open
,
New York
:
Routledge
.
Scott
,
Joan Wallach
.
1999
.
Gender and the politics of history
,
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Tong
,
Rosemarie
.
1989
.
Feminist thought: a comprehensive introduction
,
Boulder
:
Westview Press
.
Weedon
,
Chris
.
1987
.
Feminist practice and poststructuralist theory
,
New York
:
Blackwell
.
Weeks
,
Kathi
.
1998
.
Constituting feminist subjects
,
Ithaca
:
Cornell University Press
.
Wittig
,
Monique
.
2003
.
“
One is not born a woman
”
. In
Feminist theory reader: local and global perspectives
,
Edited by:
McCann
,
Carole R
and
Kim
,
Seung-Kyung
.
249
–
254
.
New York
:
Routledge
.
Young
,
Iris Marion
.
1990
.
“
Polity and group difference: a critique of the ideal of universal citizenship
”
. In
Feminism and political theory
,
Edited by:
Sunstein
,
Cass R
.
117
–
142
.
Chicago
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Lukes
,
Steven
.
2005 [1974]
.
Power: a radical view
,
New York
:
Palgrave
.
Foucault
,
Michel
.
1977
.
Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison
,
New York
:
Vintage Books
.
Hartsock
,
Nancy CM
.
1983
.
Money, sex and power: toward a feminist historical materialism
,
New York
:
Longman
.
Okin
,
Susan Moller
.
1989
.
Justice, gender and the family
,
New York
:
Basic Books
.
Weedon
,
Chris
.
1987
.
Feminist practice and poststructuralist theory
,
New York
:
Blackwell
.
Mohanty
,
Chandra Talpade
.
1991
.
“
Under Western eyes: feminist scholarship and colonial discourses
”
. In
Third World women and the politics of feminism
,
Edited by:
Mohanty
,
Chandra Talpade
,
Russo
,
Ann
and
Torres
,
Lourdes
.
51
–
80
.
Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
.
Young
,
Iris Marion
.
2003
.
The logic of masculinist protection: reflections on the current security state
.
Signs
,
29
(
1
)
:
1
–
25
.
Ruddick
,
Sara
.
1989
.
Maternal thinking: toward a politics of peace
,
Boston
:
Beacon Press
.
Hutchings
,
Kimberly
.
2000
.
Towards a feminist international ethics
.
Review of International Studies
,
26
:
111
–
130
.