Non-target effects of kaolin and coppers applied on olive trees for the predatory lacewing Chrysoperla carnea

Abstract

Kaolin clays and copper salts might be considered as alternative chemical control products for controlling olive pests in the contexts of both organic farming and integrated pest management programmes. Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) (Neur. Chrysopidae) represents one of the most significant generalist predators of olive grove pests. In this study, we evaluated the side effects of these compounds on the predatory lacewing. First, kaolin and two copper salts (copper oxychloride and Bordeaux mixture) were tested on C. carnea eggs to determine their effects on egg viability and larval hatching suppression by topical application. Second, L₃ larvae were exposed to the pesticide residues on treated olive tree leaves. Third, a series of three residual tests in adults were sequentially performed as follows: residues on glass surfaces, on olive tree leaves and on small olive trees. Finally, kaolin- and water-treated eggs of Ephestia kuehniella Zeller (Lep. Pyralidae) were offered to L₃ larvae in both dual- and no-choice tests. C. carnea egg hatching was reduced by the kaolin treatment compared to the control treatment. Residual treatments were harmless to larvae and adults, without any deleterious effects on reproduction. L₃ larvae consistently preferred to feed on water-treated E. kuehniella eggs compared to kaolin-treated eggs. The larvae from the no-choice test that had fed ad libitum until pupation on kaolin-treated E. kuehniella eggs, pupated and emerged as healthy adults in reduced proportions compared with those that fed on water-treated eggs. In conclusion, our data suggest that both kaolin and copper products appeared to be largely harmless or only slightly harmful to the predator.

Keywords:

• ecotoxicology
• IPM
• IOBC
• lacewing
• lethal and sublethal effects
• organic farming

Acknowledgements

Paloma Bengochea acknowledges Technical University of Madrid for a pre-doctoral grant.

Funding

This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation project [AGL 2007-66130-C03-02] to P. Medina.

Additional information

Funding

Funding: This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation project [AGL 2007-66130-C03-02] to P. Medina.