The role of Vartan Bhanji in implementing HRM practices in Pakistan

Abstract

The local adaptation of Western HR concepts in more traditional societies is an important topic for international HRM research and practice. We analyze the role of Vartan Bhanji, a traditional notion constituting and governing local social networks, when implementing such concepts in the Pakistani context. Based on a detailed case study of a privatized hospital, our analysis shows that Vartan Bhanji is both supporting and limiting Western HRM practices, in particular recruitment and selection, appraisal, compensation and promotion. The study reduces the knowledge gap for Pakistan, a country underrepresented in the international HRM discourse; illustrates the role of traditional social networks in companies using Western HRM concepts and supports calls for contextualizing HRM practices and research.

Keywords::

• comparative HRM
• contextualized HRM
• HRM practices
• Pakistan
• Vartan Bhanji

Notes

^1. In this paper, we use ‘Western' as an umbrella term covering HRM concepts coming from industrialized countries, in particular the USA and Europe.