Abstract
This paper examines the implementation and operation of a simple method of inventory valuation: the retail price inventory method. Previous research has examined the method's widespread adoption by US department stores during the 1920s. In particular, attention has focused on the disciplinary properties of the method and the creation of visibilities which recast power relations within the store. This paper attempts to extend existing scholarly enquiry by crossing the Atlantic to follow the practical adoption of the method by an Irish department store in the 1930s. The case reveals the extent of employee resistance to the method's adoption, culminating in a physical attack on the accountant employed with its execution. More importantly however, implemented incorrectly, the method failed to deliver the promised surveillance role, but instead yielded an unanticipated consequence. It revealed the gross profitability of the retail component of store trade and hence supported a managerial initiative to expand this side of business activities to the eventual detriment of the former resistant departmental buyers. The paper therefore acknowledges the broader role of a seemingly neutral accounting technique and reinforces the importance of recognising the organisational context of accounting practice.
Notes
3. The use of weather reports to explain trading performance was a common procedure. For example, the sales records of one US department store in 1902 contain a weather diary alongside the daily sales results. Source: C. F. Hovey Collection, Mss 776, H846, V5, Historical Collections, Baker Library, Harvard Business School.
4. Our previous research on the retail price inventory method included a consultation of the archival records of the London stores Harrods and Selfridges, both of which used the method.
5. The minutes of meetings of the Controllers Congress are held at the Baker Library, Harvard University.
7. Other new techniques included consumer credit controls (Jeacle and Walsh Citation2002) and departmental overhead allocation (Jeacle Citation2003).
Chaney
,
D.
1983
.
The department store as a cultural form
.
Theory, Culture and Society
,
1
(
3
)
:
22
–
31
.
Featherstone
,
M.
1991
.
Consumer culture and postmodermism
,
London
:
Sage
.
Ferguson
,
H.
1992
.
“
Watching the world go round: atrium culture and the psychology of shopping
”
. In
Lifestyle shopping: the subject of consumption
,
Edited by:
Shields
,
R.
21
–
39
.
London and New York
:
Routledge
.
Finkelstein
,
J.
1991
.
The fashioned self
,
Cambridge
:
Polity Press
.
Glennie
,
P.
1995
.
“
Consumption within historical studies
”
. In
Acknowledging Consumption
,
Edited by:
Miller
,
D.
164
–
203
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Laermans
,
R.
1993
.
Learning to consume: early department stores and the shaping of the modern consumer culture (1860–1914)
.
Theory, Culture and Society
,
10
(
4
)
:
79
–
102
.
McCracken
,
G.
1988
.
Culture and consumption: new approaches to the symbolic character of consumer goods and activities
,
Bloomington and Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
.
Nava
,
M.
1995
.
“
Modernity's disavowel: women, the city and the department store
”
. In
Modern times: reflections on a century of English modernity
,
Edited by:
Nava
,
M.
and
O'Shea
,
A.
38
–
76
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Appel
,
J. H.
1930
.
The business biography of John Wanamaker: founder and builder
,
New York
:
Macmillan
.
Hower
,
R. M.
1943
.
History of Macy's of New York 1858–1919: Chapters in the Evolution of the Department Store
,
Cambridge, MA
:
Harvard University Press
.
Klassen
,
H. C.
1992
.
T. C. Power and Bro.: the rise of a small western department store 1870–1902
.
Business History Review
,
66
(
4
)
:
671
–
722
.
Leach
,
W.
1984
.
“
Transformations in a culture of consumption: women and department stores, 1890–1925
”
. In
Land of desire: merchants, power, and the rise of a new American culture
,
New York
:
Pantheon Books
.
Mahoney
,
T.
1955
.
The great merchants: the stories of twenty famous retail operations and the people who made them great
,
New York
:
Harper and Brothers
.
Resseguie
,
H.
1964
.
A.T. Stewart's marble palace: the cradle of the department store
.
New York Historical Society Quarterly
,
48
(
2
)
:
130
–
62
.
Twyman
,
R. W.
1954
.
History of Marshall Field and Co
,
1852
–
1906
.
Philadelphia, PA
:
University of Pennsylvania Press
.
Adburgham
,
A.
1964
.
Shops and shopping 1800–1914: where, and in what manner the well-dressed Englishwoman bought her clothes
,
London
:
Allen and Unwin
.
Alexander
,
D.
1970
.
Retailing in England during the Industrial Revolution
,
London
:
The Athlone Press, University of London
.
Corina
,
M.
1978
.
Fine silks and oak counters: Debenhams 1778–1978
,
London
:
Hutchinson Benham
.
Crossick
,
G.
and
Jaumain
,
S.
1999
.
Cathedrals of consumption: the European department store 1850–1939
,
Edited by:
Crossick
,
G.
and
Jaumain
,
S.
Aldershot
:
Ashgate
.
Davis
,
D.
1966
.
A history of shopping
,
London
:
Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
Fraser
,
W. H.
1981
.
The coming of the mass market
,
1850
–
1914
.
London
:
Macmillan
.
Jefferys
,
J.
1954
.
Retail trading in Britain 1850–1950
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Miller
,
M.
1989
.
The bon marché
,
New Jersey
:
Princeton University Press
.
Moss
,
M.
and
Turton
,
A.
1989
.
A legend of retailing: House of Fraser
,
London
:
Wiedenfield and Nicholson
.
Rappaport
,
E.
1993
.
The west end and women's pleasure: gender and commercial culture in London, 1860–1914
,
New Brunswick
:
Rutgers The State University of New Jersey
.
PhD thesis
Williams
,
R.
1982
.
Dream worlds, mass consumption in late nineteenth-century France
,
Berkeley, CA
:
University of California Press
.
Zola
,
E.
1992
.
The ladies’ paradise
,
Berkeley, CA
:
University of California Press
.
Jeacle
,
I.
and
Walsh
,
E.
2002
.
From moral evaluation to rationalization: accounting and the shifting technologies of credit
.
Accounting Organizations and Society
,
27
(
8
)
:
737
–
61
.
Jeacle
,
I.
2003
.
Accounting and the construction of the standard body
.
Accounting Organizations and Society
,
28
(
4
)
:
357
–
77
.