0
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Article

Roles of gender in addressing structural inequality: assessment of Borana women’s endogenous institutional agents of gender amelioration in peace, conflict, and post-conflict settings

ORCID Icon, ORCID Icon, ORCID Icon & ORCID Icon
Received 27 Mar 2024, Accepted 16 Jul 2024, Published online: 30 Jul 2024
 

ABSTRACT

The portrayal of women in traditional societies as victims of conflicts and gender inequalities often overlooks their roles as agents of change. This article examined the roles of Borana women in addressing structural inequality during peace, conflict, and post-conflict settings using endogenous institutions. The study utilized an ethnographic research design and a qualitative research approach. Both primary and secondary data were collected for the study. Key informant interviews and focus group discussions were used to collect primary data, while secondary data were obtained from relevant materials through desk review. The primary data were transcribed, translated, and analyzed using thematic analysis. The findings of the study reveal that Borana women play crucial roles in fighting structural inequality through endogenous institutions in preserving peace, protecting the vulnerables, challenging male dominance, maintaining community life and upholding women’s customary laws. The study also revealed the challenges women face in addressing structural inequality. These findings contribute to feminist theories by emphasizing women’s active and diverse roles in combating structural inequality. Consequently, assertive policy options that safeguard women’s customary rights and endogenous peacemaking practices are needed. Furthermore, the study calls for policy interventions and support systems that empower women and enhance their participation in decision-making processes.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1. Moser and Clark, Citation2001. Perpetrators, or; Kaufman and Williams, Victims Women and war.

2. Oluwaniyi. “Women’s roles and positions,” 541–460; and Utas, Victimcy, Girl Friending, Soldiering, 403–430; Davies and True. women, peace and security

3. Fejokwu, Female combatants in Africa; and Oluwaniyi, Women’s roles and positions in African wars.

4. Debsu, “Gender and culture,” 20–36; Karam, “Women in War and Peace-building,” 2–25; and Thure, Women in

Inter-Community Peace and Reconciliation

5. Guzzi, Gendered Structural Inequalities; Moise and Hankerson, 1061–1062.

6. Krinsky, Politics of Protest, 487

7. Legesse, Gada.

8. Legesse, Gada; Ta’a, The Gadaa system, 81–97; Legesse, Oromo democracy

9. Abdurahman, Gada system and the Oromo’s; Debisa, Building peace by peaceful approach.

10. Ta’a, The Gadaa system, 81–97

11. See VII above; Debisa, Building peace by peaceful approach.

12. Abdurahman, Gada system and the Oromo’s.

13. Ta’a, The Gadaa system, 81–97; Legesse, Gada

14. Legesse, Oromo democracy.

15. Ibid.

16. Jorgo, Conquest and change in Boorana traditional polity, 30–67

17. Legesse, Oromo Democracy.

18. Legesse, Gada; Legesse, The Oromo Democracy.

19. Chala, Blessing the Route, 153–166; Conquest and change in Boorana traditional polity

20. 20 Legesse, Gada; Jorgo, Conquest and change in Boorana traditional polity, 30–67

21. Ta’a. The Gadaa system, 81–97

22. Legesse, Oromo Democracy.

23. Ta’a, Gadaa system, 81–97

24. Imana, Muka-Laafaa: Image of Oromo Women under the Gadaa System, 69–84.

25. Meyer, The Evolution of Modern Stratification Systems, 1116–1125.; Elias and Paradies, costs of institutional racism

26. Caprioli and Boyer, Gender, violence, and international crisis.

27. Weeden and Grusky, Three worlds of inequality, 1723–1785

28. Ramtohul, Women, Gender, and Politics, 41–66; Lupu& Pontusson,316–336

29. Weeden and Grusky, Three worlds of inequality, 1723–1785

30. Weeden & Grusky, Three worlds of inequality, 1723–1785

31. Weeden and Grusky, Three worlds of inequality, 1723–1785

32. Yang and Sun, Structural gender inequality and mental health, 31–43

33. Schultz and Mullings, Gender, Race, Class, and Health; Shepherd, Gender, violence and security

34. Regan and Paskeviciute, Women’s access to politics and peaceful states, 287–302

35. Lorber, Gender inequality.

36. Caprioli, Primed for violence, 161–178

37. Armah et al., Dimensions of structural inequalities, 456–470

38. Armah et al., Dimensions of structural inequalities, 456–470

39. Ramtohul, Women, Gender, and Politics.

40. Armah et al., Dimensions of structural, 456–470

41. Sharpe, Linkages between economic growth and inequality.

42. Wamala and Lynch, Gender and social inequities in health.

43. Schultz and Mullings, Gender, Race, Class, and Health; Shepherd, Gender, violence and security

44. Caprioli and Boyer, Gender, violence, and international crisis; Regan and Paskeviciute, Women’s access, to politics and peaceful states, 287–302

45. Saferworld, Gender and conflict analysis.

46. Paffenholz, Unpacking the local turn in peacebuilding, 41–58

47. Reda, Dynamics in pastoral resource management, 31–43

48. Shepherd, Gender, violence and security

49. Wahyudan, Odera and Mulusa, Dismantling patriarchal structures, 16–29

50. Moise & Hankerson, Addressing Structural Racism and Inequities,1061–1062.

51. Dressel, Minkler & Yen, Gender, race, class, and aging, 467–480

52. Gittell et al., Women creating social capital.

53. Gittell et al., Women creating social capital.

54. Grown et al., Taking action

55. Fenetahun and Fentahun, Socio-economic profile of arid, 113–122.

56. Utas, Victimcy, Girl Friending, Soldiering, 403–430; Davies and True, women, peace and security

57. Hodgson, once intrepid warriors; Flintan, Gender and pastoralism.

58. Onyima, Women in pastoral societies.

59. Flintan, Women’s Empowerment in Pastoral Societies

60. Hugo, Conflict resolution among pastoral communities, 458 and conflict resolution.

61. Issifu, Local peace committees in Africa.

62. Tafere, Peace-making from within, 57–78

63. Ingiriis, changing transformation of gender.

64. Krätli and Swift, Understanding pastoral poverty.

65. Debsu, Gender and culture; Kumsa, Siiqqee institution, 115–145

66. Guyo, Colonial and post-colonial changes 1–19; Ta’a, Gadaa system and some of its institutions; Legesse, Oromo democracy

67. Guyo, Colonial and post-colonial changes, 1–19

68. Key informant: Mr. Bonaya Dida, Addis Ababa, March 5, 2022.

69. Interview, Mrs. Dabo Yadani, Gomole, March 8, 2022.

70. Interview, Wamu Boru, Arero, August 15, 2022.

71. Mr. Hussien Galacha, Arero, 2022.

72. Wako, Contesting Marginality in Jest, 91–118

73. Interview, Nuno Borbor, Arero, March 16, 2022.

74. Interview, Guyo Boru, Mega, March 26, 2022.

75. Interview, Guyo Boru, Mega, March 26, 2022.

76. Galgalo Tadhole, Yabello, March 4, 2022.

77. Guyo, Colonial and post-colonial changes, 1–19; Waqo, Contesting Marginality in Jest, 91–118

78. Guyo, Colonial and post-colonial changes, 1–19; Waqo, Contesting Marginality in Jest, 91–118

79. Interview, Mrs. Ayisha Golicha, Moyale, March 21.

80. Interview, Mrs. Almaz Liban, Arero, August 13, 2022.

81. Interviews, Mr. Galgalo Tadhole and Wariyo Dima, Yabello, March, 2022.

82. Interview, Nuno Borbor and Borbor Bule, Yabello, March 11, 2022.

83. Interview, Mengistu Eticha, Yabello, March 06, 2022.

84. Wariyo Dima, and Wariyo Argessa, Yabello, March 8, 2022.

85. Interview, Abdisa Mulugeta, Wamu Boru, Momina Jarso, Arero, August 12, 2022.

86. Anbacha and Kjosavik, Borana women’s Indigenous social network-marro; Schloeder et al., Women as Partners, 58–62

87. Anbacha and Kjosavik, dynamics of Gender Relations under Recurrent Drought.

88. Anbacha and Kjosavik, Borana women’s Indigenous social network-marro.

89. Jatani Dida and Nuno Borbor, Yabello, 10 Ma.

90. Kura Jarso, Arero, 16 August, 2022rch, 2022.

91. Ezer, Forging a path for women’s rights 65–75

92. Williams, Democracy, Gender Equality, and Customary Law, 65–85

93. Ezer, Forging a path for women’s rights 65–75

94. Ezer, Forging a path for women’s rights.

95. Apple, Education and power.

96. Elemo, Traditional Institutions among the Borana Oromo.

97. Imana, Muka-Laafaa: Image of Oromo Women under the Gadaa System, 69–84

98. Imana, Muka-Laafaa: The Image of Oromo Women under the Gadaa System, 69–84; Baxter, Borana Age-sets and Generation-sets, 151–182

99. Interview, Jatani Dida, Bakke (Yabello), March 17, 2022.

100. Interview, Mrs. Ayisha Golicha, Moyale, March 21, 2022 and Mrs. Hacha Hasano, Gomole, 8 March, 2022.

101. Interview, Mrs. Almaz Liban, Arero, July 13, 2022.

102. Interview, Mr. Wariyo Argessa and Mr. Mengistu Eticha, Yabello, March 14, 2022.

103. Adii Duuloo Willee, a female warrior from the Konitu clan of Borana Oromo, was a celebrated fighter who played a crucial role in the victory over Arsi clan. Riding into battle on horseback, she expertly wielded her spear to vanquish her foes. Her unmatched bravery and reputation as a formidable warrior were widely recognized. Adii Duuloo Willee was held in such high esteem that no man dared to challenge her in combat. In recognition of her bravery, the Borana community composed and performed songs honoring her heroism.

104. Interview, Kabale Halake, Yabello, March 5, 2022.

105. Interview, Kanu Jilo, Dhas, August 27, 2022.

106. Interview, Haca Hasano, March, 2022.

107. ‘Lichoo’ is a ceremonial whip carried by married men and leaders in Borana culture. Made from the thick hide of a rhinoceros, giraffe, or bull, lichoo symbolizes leadership. The elected Gadaa or Qaalluu councils carry lichoo, and a person who carries it is considered a ‘hayyuu’, or leader. These councils are responsible for making decisions on political, economic, social, and religious matters. A person carrying lichoo is respected as a wise individual and recognized as a member of these esteemed councils. It is from this context that the name lichoo is bestowed upon the councils.

108. Pineview, Mrs. Momina Jarso and Mrs. Tiji Aydii, Arero, 28 August, 2022.

109. Debsu, Gender and culture in southern Ethiopia, 15–36.

110. Anderlini, Women building peace; Stephen, Women and social movements.

111. Interview, Mrs. Momina Jarso and Mrs. Tiji Aydii, Arero, 28 August, 2022.

112. Interview, Mr. Guyo Duba, Mega, 24 August, 2022 and Bonaya Dida, March 5, 2022.

113. Interview, Mr. Guyo Duba, Mega, August 24, 2022.

114. Anbacha and Kjosavik, Borana women’s Indigenous social network, 1–12; Anbacha and Kjosavik, dynamics of Gender, 435–447 Relations

115. Interview, Mrs. Dimbilal Abera and Mr. Mangistu Eticha, Yabello, March 12, 2022.

116. Arostegui, Gender, Conflict, and Peace-building.

117. Willett, Introduction: Security Council Resolution, 142–158; Spiegel et al., Peace studies for sustainable development in Africa

118. Interview, Mr. Golicha Dhegicha, Yabello, March 11, 2022.

119. Interview, Mrs. Dahi Boru, Arero Mata gafarsa, July 26, 2022.

120. Interview, Beletech Bahiru, Gomole, March 22, 2022.

121. Interview, Mrs. Dimbilal Abera, March 12, 2022.

122. Gizelis, Women Creating Social Capital and Social Change, 33–34

123. Interview, Galgalo Doyo, Mega, August 11, 2022.

124. Interview, Mrs. Lasi Jaldessa, Moyale, March 12, 2022.

125. Interview, Mrs. Kabale Halake, March 8, 2022.

126. Debsu, Gender and culture in southern Ethiopia, 15–36.

127. Assefa and Pankhurst, Women, Peace and Conflict in Africa.; Flintan, Women’s Empowerment in Pastoral Societies

128. Kristjanson et al., Livestock and Women’s Livelihoods

129. Interview, Mr. Wariyoo Diimaa, Mr. Galgalo Tadhole, and Mr. Wariyoo Argessa, Yabello, March 18, 2022.

130. Interview, Mr. Mengistu Eticha, Yabello, March 12, 2022.

131. Grown et al., Taking action.

132. Boserup, Women’s role in economic development; Amine and Staub, Women entrepreneurs in sub- Saharan Africa.

133. interview, Mrs. Ayisha Golicha, Moyale, 21 March, 2022, Mr. Galgalo Tadhole, Yabello, 4 March, 2022, Mr. Kanu Jilo, Dhas, August 27, 2022.

134. Informants: Mrs. Ayisha Golicha, Moyale, 21 March, 2022, Mr. Galgalo Tadhole, Yabello, 4 March, 2022, Mr. Kanu Jilo, Dhas, August 27, 2022.

135. Legesse, Gada: three approaches to the study of African society; Guyo, Colonial and post-colonial Changes, 1–19

136. Garikipati, impact of lending to women on household, 2620–2642; Chant, Women, girls, and world Poverty, 1–24; Hill, Development as Empowerment, 117–135

137. Hill, Development as Empowerment, 117–135

138. Anbacha and Kjosavik, The dynamics of Gender Relations under Recurrent Drought 435–447; Reda, Dynamics in pastoral resource management, 31–43; Feyissa, Conflicts among Pastoralists in the Borana Area of Southern Ethiopia

139. Acemoglu et al., Women, war, and wages, 499–541

140. Manchanda, Women, war, and Peace in South Asia.

Additional information

Funding

The work was supported by the Haramaya University International Peace Research Association Foundation.

Notes on contributors

Tesfaye Gudeta Gerba

Tesfaye Gudeta Gerba is a senior lecturer in the College of Social Sciences and Humanities at Haramaya University, Haramaya, Ethiopia. He is also a PhD candidate in Peace and Development Studies at Haramaya University, Haramaya, Ethiopia. His research interest includes Gender studies, ethnopolitics, Sociolinguistics, Semantics, Ethnic conflicts, gender and peacebuilding, Gadaa system, Conflict transformation, and anthropology.

Gutema Imana Keno

Gutema Imana is an associate professor of Sociology in the Department of Sociology, Haramaya University. His research interest is in development sociology, Peacebuilding, peacebuilding and Conflict Transformation.

Mulu Berhanu Hundera

Mulu B. Hundera is an assistant professor of Management and Development at the Department of Gender and Development Studies at Haramaya University, Haramaya, Ethiopia. Her research interest is Gender, Female Entrepreneurship and Family dynamics, Diversity and Social Inclusion, and Female leadership.

Fekadu Adugna Tufa

Fekadu Adugna is an associate professor of Social Anthropology in the Department of Social Anthropology, at Addis Ababa University. His research interest is on social ethnicity, conflict, development, and ethno-social problems.

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
USD 53.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
USD 289.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable

Related Research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.