Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.
Notes
1. The target content is the content of the case that matters for philosophical purposes, the superficial content the content that doesn’t.
2. Springle also puzzles over the notion of a proper domain. I define it on p. 112: ‘let’s call “the proper domain” of a judgment the circumstances in which it is reliable … The proper domain of a judgment (e.g. ascription of knowledge or responsibility) varies with the expertise of the person judging, when the subject matter of the judgment allows for expertise.’