ABSTRACT
Most economists examining the question of ‘pollution havens’ have concluded that the level of environmental regulation and activism in different states is not generally a significant determinant of international patterns of trade and foreign direct investment. This paper argues on the basis of extensive primary research that with respect to Japan's foreign direct investment during the 1970s, at any rate, this conclusion needs to be rethought. In the early 1970s, Japanese actors were remarkably forthright in ascribing their investment decisions to a desire to move polluting industry overseas. These statements allow us to examine ‘pollution export’ as a state strategy, a project advocated by industry organizations, and a response of individual firms to high levels of protest and regulation. The paper also traces the development of the Japanese debate over pollution export through the 1970s.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Research for this paper was supported financially by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the Institute for the Study of World Politics, Cornell University's East Asia, Southeast Asia, and International Political Economy programs, and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. The author would like to acknowledge his gratitude to Jennifer Clapp, Eric Helleiner, Peter Katzenstein, Suehiro Akira, and three anonymous reviewers for RIPE for their suggestions, to Arakawa Shunji for giving him access to his collection of back numbers of Kōgai o Nogasu Na!, and to Robin Webster and Yoshino Isao for their research assistance. All errors are the author's own.
Notes
3. Especially the Asahan aluminum smelter in Sumatra, Kawasaki Steel's sintering plant in Mindanao, and Mitsubishi's Asian Rare Earth plant in Malaysia.
9. Interview, Arakawa Shunji, Tokyo, 7 November 2000.
10. One exception is the January 1971 suggestion by Tanaka Nobuji, Vice-Director of the Japan Industrial Siting Center, that sending polluting industry to Asia would only exacerbate anti-Japanese sentiment (CitationTanaka, 1971: 1).
Cameron
,
O.
1996
.
“
‘Japan and Southeast Asia's Environment’
”
. In
Environmental Change in South-East Asia: People Politics and Sustainable Development
,
Edited by:
Parnwell
,
M. J. G.
and
Bryant
,
R. L.
67
–
93
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Dauvergne
,
P.
1997
.
Shadows in the Forest: Japan and the Politics of Timber in Southeast Asia
,
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Parker
,
P.
1998
.
‘An Environmental Measure of Japan's Economic Development: The Ecological Footprint’
.
Geographische Zeitschrift
,
86
(
2
)
:
106
–
19
.
Itō
,
T.
2004
.
ChikyūÛ o Korosu Na! Kankyō Hakai Taikoku: Nippon
,
Tokyo
:
Fubaisha
.
Hall
,
D.
2006
.
“
‘Regional Shrimp, Global Trees, Chinese Vegetables: The Environment in Japan–Asia Relations’
”
. In
Beyond Japan: East Asian Regionalism
,
Edited by:
Katzenstein
,
P. J.
and
Shiraishi
,
T.
188
–
210
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Ozawa
,
T.
1979
.
Multinationalism Japanese Style: The Political Economy of Outward Dependency
,
Princeton, NJ
:
Princeton University Press
.
Nishikawa
,
J.
1978
.
“
‘“Resource Constraints”: A Problem of the Japanese Economy’
”
. In
Growth and Resources Problems Related to Japan
,
Edited by:
Tsuru
,
S.
297
–
313
.
Tokyo
:
Asahi Evening News
.
Proceedings of Session VI of the Fifth Congress of the International Economic Association
Arase
,
D.
1995
.
Buying Power: The Political Economy of Japan's Foreign Aid
,
Boulder, CO
:
Lynne Rienner
.
Hatch
,
W.
and
Yamamura
,
K.
1996
.
Asia in Japan's Embrace: Building a Regional Production Alliance
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Doner
,
R. F.
1997
.
“
‘Japan in East Asia’
”
. In
Network Power: Japan and Asia
,
Edited by:
Katzenstein
,
P. J.
and
Shiraishi
,
T.
197
–
233
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Pempel
,
T. J.
1997
.
“
‘Transpacific Torii’
”
. In
Network Power: Japan and Asia
,
Edited by:
Katzenstein
,
P. J.
and
Shiraishi
,
T.
47
–
82
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Korhonen
,
P.
1998
.
Japan and Asia Pacific Integration: Pacific Romances 1968–1996
,
London
:
Routledge
.
Solis
,
M.
2004
.
Banking on Multinationals: Public Credit and the Export of Japanese Sunset Industries
,
Stanford, CA
:
Stanford University Press
.
Nectoux
,
F.
and
Kuroda
,
Y.
1990
.
Timber from the South Seas: An Analysis of Japan's Tropical Timber Trade and Its Environmental Impact
,
Gland,
, Switzerland
:
WWF International
.
Kawahara
,
J.
1995
.
‘Ajia ni Okeru Kankyō Mondai to Nihon Kigyō’
.
Aichi Daigaku Kokusai Mondai KenkyūÛjo Kiyō
,
102
:
115
–
55
.
Kawana
,
H.
1996
.
Dokyumento: Nihon no Kōgai. Dai 13-Kan: Ajia no Kankyō Hakai to Nihon
,
Tokyo
:
Midorikaze Shuppan
.
Itō
,
T.
2004
.
ChikyūÛ o Korosu Na! Kankyō Hakai Taikoku: Nippon
,
Tokyo
:
Fubaisha
.
Leonard
,
H. J.
1988
.
Pollution and the Struggle for the World Product: Multinational Corporations Environment and International Comparative Advantage
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Brunnermeier
,
S. B.
and
Levinson
,
A.
2004
.
‘Examining the Evidence on Environmental Regulations and Industry Location’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
13
(
1
)
:
6
–
41
.
Porter
,
G.
1999
.
‘Trade Competition and Pollution Standards: “Race to the Bottom” or “Stuck at the Bottom”?’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
8
(
2
)
:
133
–
51
.
Hall
,
D.
2002b
.
‘Environmental Change, Protest, and Havens of Environmental Degradation: Evidence from Japan–Southeast Asia Relations’
.
Global Environmental Politics
,
2
(
2
)
:
20
–
8
.
Leonard
,
H. J.
1988
.
Pollution and the Struggle for the World Product: Multinational Corporations Environment and International Comparative Advantage
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Molina
,
D.
1993
.
‘A Comment on whether Maquiladoras are in Mexico for Low Wages or to Avoid Pollution Abatement Costs’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
2
(
1
)
:
221
–
41
.
Pargal
,
S.
and
Mani
,
M.
2000
.
‘Citizen Activism, Environmental Regulation, and the Location of Industrial Plants: Evidence from India’
.
Economic Development and Cultural Change
,
48
(
4
)
:
829
–
46
.
Dean
,
J. M.
,
Lovely
,
M. E.
and
Wang
,
H.
2005
.
‘Are Foreign Investors Attracted to Weak Environmental Regulations? Evaluating the Evidence from China’
World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3505
Low
,
P.
and
Yeats
,
A.
1992
.
“
‘Do “Dirty” Industries Migrate?’
”
. In
International Trade and the Environment
,
Edited by:
Low
,
P.
89
–
120
.
Washington, DC
:
World Bank
.
Birdsall
,
N.
and
Wheeler
,
D.
1993
.
‘Trade Policy and Industrial Pollution in Latin America: Where Are the Pollution Havens?’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
2
(
1
)
:
137
–
49
.
Letchumanan
,
R.
1998
.
Trade, Environment and Competitiveness: Testing the ‘Pollution-Haven’ Hypothesis from the Technology Perspective
,
Tokyo
:
United Nations University/Institute of Advanced Studies
.
Mani
,
M.
and
Wheeler
,
D.
1998
.
‘In Search of Pollution Havens? Dirty Industry in the World Economy, 1960 to 1995’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
7
(
3
)
:
215
–
47
.
Neumayer
,
E.
2000
.
‘Trade and the Environment: A Critical Assessment and Some Suggestions for Reconciliation’
.
Journal of Environment and Development
,
9
(
2
)
:
138
–
59
.
Tanaka
,
N.
1971
.
‘Kōgai Sangyō Ricchi e no Shisei’
.
Kōgyō Ricchi
,
:
1
January