The development of informal governance in post-apartheid
South Africa: Criminal gangs as neo-medieval agents

Abstract

Employing international relations theory's concept of the new medievalism, this article applies a model of informal governance to the study of post-apartheid South Africa, arguing that what appear to be ungoverned spaces, criminality or corruption may in fact represent the development of informal governance. Employing a political-economy approach, it analyses the rise and decline of the modern state by reference to the relative efficiency of actors in the formal and informal systems. After an initial upsurge of neo-medievalism following the end of apartheid, the South African state has enjoyed recent success reasserting its sovereignty, although this may yet prove temporary.

Keywords:

• Africa
• South Africa
• sovereignty
• informal governance
• neo-medievalism
• criminal gangs
• political economy

Acknowledgements

The author would like to acknowledge the support of SAIIA, the Centre for International Governance Innovation and the Global Consortium on Security Transformation, as well as the contributions made by David Hornsby, Richard Moncrieff and colleagues at SAIIA, who provided useful input and feedback to seminar presentations of this article during his tenure as a Visiting Bradlow Fellow.

Notes

1. Bull H, ‘Beyond the states system?’ in The Anarchical Society: A Study of Order in World Politics. London: Macmillan, 1977.

2. Friedrichs J, ‘The meaning of new medievalism’, European Journal of International Relations, 7.4, 2001, pp. 475–501.

3. Wolfers A, Discord and Collaboration: Essays on International Politics. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1962.

4. Cooper R, ‘The New Liberal Imperialism’, The Observer (London), 7 April 2002; Ruggie JG, ‘Territoriality and beyond: Problematizing modernity in international relations’, International Organization, 46, 1993); Akihiko T, The New Middle Ages: The World System in the 21st Century, Tokyo: International House of Japan, 2002; cf. Hurrell A, ‘The regional dimension of international relations theory’, in Farrell M (ed.) Global Politics of Regionalism, London: Pluto Press, 2005.

5. See e.g. Friedrichs J, ‘The meaning of new medievalism’, European Journal of International Relations, 7.4, 2001, pp. 475–501. Aalberts TE, ‘The future of sovereignty in multilevel governance Europe — a constructivist reading’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 42.1, March 2004, pp. 23–46; Zielonka J, ‘How new enlarged borders will reshape the European Union’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 39.3, 2001, pp. 507–36; Trainor B, ‘The origin and end of modernity’, Journal of Applied Philosophy, 15.2, 1998, pp. 133–44; Walby S, ‘The new regulatory state: The social powers of the European Union’, British Journal of Sociology, 50.1, 1999, pp. 118–40.

6. Newhouse J, ‘Europe's rising regionalism’, Foreign Affairs, 76.1, 1997, pp. 67–84.

7. See, for example, Helman GB and SR Ratner, ‘Saving failed states’, Foreign Policy, 89, 1992, pp. 3–20; Rotberg RI, ‘Failed states in a world of terror’, Foreign Affairs, 81.4, 2002, pp. 1–13, pp. 1–13, and ‘Failed states, collapsed states, weak states: Causes and indicators’, in Rotberg RI (ed.) State Failure and State Weakness in a Time of Terror, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 2003; Krasner SD and C Pascual, ‘Addressing state failure’, Foreign Affairs, 84.4, 2005, pp. 153–63; Eizenstat SE, JE Porter and JM Weinstein, ‘Rebuilding weak states’, Foreign Affairs, 84.1, 2005, pp. 134–146.

8. Jackson RH and CG Rosberg, ‘Why Africa's weak states persist: The empirical and juridical in statehood’, World Politics, 35.1, 1982, pp. 1–24.

9. Herbst JI, States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2000.

10. Boone V, Political topographies of the African State, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003; cf. Adebajo A, The Curse of Berlin: Africa after the Cold War, New York: Columbia University Press, 2010.

11. Wolch J, ‘The shadow state: Transformations in the voluntary sector’, in Wolch J and M Dear (eds) The Power of Geography, Boston, MA: Unwin Hymnan, 1989, p. 201; see also Wolch J, The Shadow State: Government and the Voluntary Sector in Transition, New York: The Foundation Center, 1990; and ‘Decentering America's nonprofit sector: Reflection on Salomon's crises analysis’, Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 10.1, 1999, pp. 25–35.

12. A detailed development of this theory can be found in Rapley J, ‘Informal governance and the state’ (forthcoming).

13. See Torgler B and F Schneider, ‘The impact of tax morale and institutional quality on the shadow economy’, Journal of Economic Psychology, 30.2, 2009, pp. 228–45; cf. Johnson S, D Kaufmann and A Shleifer, ‘The unofficial economy in transition’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2, 1997, 185–6.

14. South African Institute of Race Relations, Race Relations Survey 1992/93, Johannesburg: SAIRR, 1993, p. 381.

15. South African Institute of Race Relations, Race Relations Survey 1994/9, Johannesburg: SAIRR, 1995, p. 236.

16. Deininger K and Squire L, ‘A new data set for measuring income inequality’, The World Bank Economic Review, 10.3, September 1996, pp. 565–91.

17. Welsh D, The Rise and Fall of Apartheid, Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball, 2009, pp. 242–4.

18. South African Institute of Race Relations, Race Relations Survey 1992/93, Johannesburg: SAIRR, 1993, p. 280.

19. Shaw M, Marching to a Different Tune: Political Change and Police Transformation in South Africa and Northern Ireland, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2001, p. 34.

20. Leibbrandt M et al., Trends in South African Income Distribution and Poverty since the Fall of Apartheid, Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers no. 101, Paris: OECD, 2010.

21. In 1994, despite the fact that most inter-personal crime took place in townships or rural areas, three-quarters of the country's police stations were in white suburbs and business districts. See Shaw M, Marching to a Different Tune: Political Change and Police Transformation in South Africa and Northern Ireland, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2001, p. 34.

22. Leibbrandt M et al., Trends in South African Income Distribution and Poverty since the Fall of Apartheid, Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers no. 101, Paris: OECD, 2010.

23. Shaw M, Marching to a Different Tune: Political Change and Police Transformation in South Africa and Northern Ireland, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2001, p. 35.

24. In a 2000 survey, over a fifth of South African doctors had left to work abroad. See Clemens MA and Petterssen G, Medical Leave: A New Database of Health Professional Emigration from Africa, Working Paper 95, Washington, DC: Center for Global Development, 2006, Table 1.

25. Cameron R, New Public Sector Management Reforms in the South African Public Service: 1999–2008, Cape Town: Paper Presented to Political Studies Departmental Seminar, 28 April 2009, p. 15.

26. Schiavo-Campo S, G de Tommaso and A Mukherjee, Government Employment and Pay: A Global and Regional Perspective, Policy Research Working Paper 1771, Washington, DC: World Bank, May 1997.

27. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February, 2011.

28. Wannenburg G, Africa's Pablos and Political Entrepreneurs: War, the State and Criminal Networks in West and Southern Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2006, pp. 107–9.

29. The South African Defence Force supplied weapons to neighbouring insurgent forces, homeland defence forces and its own commandos, but in ways that escaped detection, posing a challenge to the regime after 1994 as it sought to mop up this supply of weapons. See Lamb G, ‘Under the Gun’: An Assessment of Firearm Crime and Violence in South Africa, Pretoria: South Africa, Office of the President, March 2008, pp. 15–18.

30. Irish-Qhobosheane J, Gentlemen or Villains, Thugs or Heroes? The Social Economy of Organised Crime in South Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, p. 83.

31. Irish-Qhobosheane J, See No Evil, Hear No Evil: The Social Economy of Organised Crime in Mozambique, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, pp. 35–6.

32. Glaser C, ‘Swines, hazels and the dirty dozen: Masculinity, territoriality and the youth gangs of Soweto, 1960–1976’, Journal of Southern African Studies, 24.4, 1998, pp. 719–36.

33. Glaser C, ‘“We must infiltrate the tsotsis”: School politics and youth gangs in Soweto, 1968–1976’, Journal of Southern African Studies, 24.2, 1998, pp. 301–23.

34. Shaw M, Marching to a Different Tune: Political Change and Police Transformation in South Africa and Northern Ireland, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2001, p. 23; Irish-Qhobosheane J, Gentlemen or Villains, Thugs or Heroes? The Social Economy of Organised Crime in South Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, p. 81.

35. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 136–9.

36. Shaw M, Marching to a Different Tune: Political Change and Police Transformation in South Africa and Northern Ireland, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2001, pp. 30–31, 35; Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 38–42.

37. Ellis S, ‘The new frontiers of crime in South Africa’, in Bayart JF, S Ellis and B Hibou (eds) The Criminalization of the State in Africa, Oxford: James Currey, 1999, p. 52; Truth and Reconciliation Commission, Final Report, 1998 (http://www.justice.gov.za/trc/report/index.htm), volume 2.

38. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 1 March 2011.

39. Powell I, Interview, Group Investigations Editor, Cape Argus, Cape Town, 10 March 2011.

40. Irish-Qhobosheane J, See No Evil, Hear No Evil: The Social Economy of Organised Crime in Mozambique, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, pp. 356.

41. Irish-Qhobosheane J, Gentlemen or Villains, Thugs or Heroes? The Social Economy of Organised Crime in South Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, p. 81.

42. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 140–41.

43. Wannenburg G, Wannenburg G, Africa's Pablos and Political Entrepreneurs: War, the State and Criminal Networks in West and Southern Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2006, p. 25; Irish-Qhobosheane J, Gentlemen or Villains, Thugs or Heroes? The Social Economy of Organised Crime in South Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, p. 87.

44. Wannenburg G, Interview, Sub-Section Head, Commercial and Cyber-Crime, South Africa Police Service, Johannesburg, 1 March 2011.

45. Wannenburg G, Interview, Sub-Section Head, Commercial and Cyber-Crime, South Africa Police Service, Pretoria, 8 March 2011.

46. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February. The 2012 conviction of Sheryl Cwele, ex-wife of a state security minister, on drug-dealing charges does, however, turn one's attention to the vulnerability of the state to criminal penetration.

47. Powell I, Interview, Group Investigations Editor, Cape Argus, Cape Town, 10 March 2011.

48. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February 2011.

49. Efrat A, ‘Toward internationally regulated goods: Controlling the trade in small arms and light weapons’, International Organization, 64, 2010, pp. 97–131.

50. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February 2011; Meek S and N Stott, A Guide to the Destruction of Small Arms and Light Weapons The Approach of the South African National Defence Force, Geneva: United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research and Small Arms Survey, 2004. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February 2011.

51. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February 2011.

52. Wannenburg G, Interview, South African Institute of International Affairs, Johannesburg, 22 February 2011.

53. Karp A, Surplus Arms in South America: A Survey, Geneva: Small Arms Survey, 2009, p. 17.

54. Kirsten A et al., Islands of Safety in a Sea of Guns: Gun-free Zones in South Africa's Fothane, Diepkloof, and Khayelitsha, Working Paper no. 3, Geneva: Small Arms Survey, 2006, p. 19.

55. Lambrechts D, ‘The impact of organised crime on the state: The battle for social control — a study of organised criminal groups and local governance on the Cape Flats, Cape Town, South Africa’, Journal of Southern African Studies, (forthcoming in the Journal of Southern African Studies, Vol 38, December 2012.).

56. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 229–30.

57. Saunders S, Estimates of the Informal Economy in South Africa, DCom diss., Faculty of Economic and Financial Sciences, University of Johannesburg, 2005; Schneider F, Size and Measurement of the Informal Economy in 110 Countries around the World, Canberra: Presentation to workshop of Australian National Tax Centre, Australian National University, 17 July 2002.

58. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, p. 229.

59. Irish-Qhobosheane J, Gentlemen or Villains, Thugs or Heroes? The Social Economy of Organised Crime in South Africa, Johannesburg: South African Institute of International Affairs, 2007, pp. 61–3.

60. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 198–200.

61. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006., pp. 194–195.

62. Moeletsi M, Interview, Lonehill, South Africa, 8 March 2011.

63. Leibbrandt M et al., ‘Trends in South African Income Distribution and Poverty since the Fall of Apartheid’, Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers no. 101, Paris: OECD, 2010.

64. Mahlangu M, Interview, Pretoria, 8 March, 2011.

65. Mahlangu M, Interview, Pretoria, 8 March, 2011.

66. Kersting N, ‘Voting behaviour in the 2009 South African election’, Africa Spectrum, 44.2, 2009, pp. 125–33.

67. Standing A, Organised Crime: A Study from the Cape Flats, Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 2006, pp. 18–20.

68. See, for instance, the post in the Nkomazi Ratepayers Association for 20 May 2010: http://www.nrpas.co.za/News/tabid/902/AID/116/Ratepayers-Newsletter-No-37-May-14th-2010.aspx (accessed 10 October 2012).

69. Dessy S and S Pallage, ‘Taxes, inequality and the size of the informal sector’, Journal of Development Economics, 70.1, 2003, pp. 225–33; Barkley Rosser J Jr, MV Rosser and E Ahmed, ‘Income inequality and the informal economy in transition economies’, Journal of Comparative Economics, 28.1, 2000, pp. 156–71; Bloomquist KM, ‘Tax evasion’, Income Inequality and Opportunity Costs of Compliance, Paper Presented at the 96th Annual Conference of the National Tax Association, Chicago, IL, November 2003; Chong A and Gradtsein M, ‘Inequality and informality’, Journal of Public Economics, 91, 2007, pp. 159–79.

70. World Bank, World Development Indicators.

71. Mbeki M, ‘Only a matter of time before the hand grenade explodes’, Business Day (Johannesburg), 10 February 2011.