ABSTRACT
This paper adopts the idea that nationally observed commemorative events are pivotal in the enactment of identity. Exemplified by Anzac Day, collective mnemonic narratives are implicated in the process of producing particular conceptions of what is normative and valued within a legal and political community. The notion of collective memory’s contribution to the production of normative and formative frames, and associated senses of belonging and recognition, is brought into conversation with the theorisation of the plurality of law. Interview data from a project examining the experiences of expatriate homosexual Australian men is introduced in order to explore the entanglement of Anzac Day commemoration and law in the elastic quality of normative frames to tolerate difference while also being inherently exclusionary.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank interviewees for their contribution to this work. I would also like to thank OU belonging symposium participants and the two anonymous reviewers for their helpful suggestions.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.
Notes on contributor
Matt Howard is a lecturer in law at the Open University and he holds a PhD in law from the University of Kent. His research interests include interrogating how the concepts of ‘belonging’ and ‘normativity’ are regulated by time and memory.
Notes
1 This follows Levine and Mellema (Citation2001), who argue that experiences of law rely, too, on norms and forces which can be considered extra-legal or quasi-legal. Collective memory is rendered here as an ‘institution’ to convey the regularised and established practice of particular mnemonhistorical narratives as being a key feature of a group identity.
10 Despite the Anzac legend encompassing both Australia and New Zealand, the focus of this paper is solely on Australia; the observance of, and attitudes towards, Anzac Day in each country is tempered by specific social and political conditions, both contemporary and at the time.
12 Broadly within this century and the final quarter of the last century, Australia has enacted a range of legislation, both federally and by state, extending rights and recognition to its LGBT population. Notwithstanding decriminalisation and criminal justice provisions, this legislation has tended to cover family life, concerning succession, adoption, family planning, and marriage & partnership recognition, reaffirming normative and generative relationship logics.
15 Fleur Johns (Citation2013) identifies various taxonomies of non-legal; it is defined as illegal, extra-legal, pre- or post-legal, supra- or infra-legal. Each of these suggest a definite distinction from law. The ‘ostensibly’ non-legal institutions I am referring to in this paper, particularly in relation to mnemonic institutions, can more appropriately be considered quasi-legal to reflect how closely bound up these institutions are in the process of making legal order.
29 This method is based heavily on principles found within the approach taken to interviews in interpretative phenomenological analysis. See eg Smith (Citation2004); Smith, Flowers, & Larkin (Citation2009); Smith & Osborn (Citation2008).
32 Rather than the pursuit of closure of satisfaction of a particular assumption. Smith & Osborn (Citation2008).
39 All interviewees names have been anonymised.
42 He recounts this conversation during the stages after coming out to his parents, and before marriage equality was legislated for in Australia.
43 At 53, John was the oldest participant interviewed, and was in his early 20s in the period when male homosexuality was decriminalised in New South Wales and remained criminalised in Queensland.
44 This sentiment is also touched upon by Shawn, who states that ‘we only got same sex marriage last year, um, well behind the rest of the Western World, shall we say.’
45 Smaal (Citation2015). See also Riseman, Robinson, & Willett (Citation2018) for a collection of stories which confront the official, political, and cultural silencing of the service of LGBT personnel in the Australian Defence Force.
48 Ford (Citation1995), p 95. See Smaal & Willett (Citation2015) and Riseman (Citation2018) who suggest similar policies existed in WWII and the post-Vietnam era policy, respectively.
55 Two participants in particular, Zackary and Shawn, mention growing up with only The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert as a reference for how homosexuals were characterised.
56 This is an insight shared by Clark, who suggests that ‘cutting each other, making those terrible, terrible remarks [ . . . ] was my upbringing on my father’s side.’
62 Bridges (Citation2014). Tristan Bridges is, here, writing in the context of heterosexual men problematically co-opting ‘gay aesthetics’ as a means of dissociating themselves from the masculine stereotype. However, the notion of reliance on aesthetics ‘to identify the seeds of belonging’ (p 66) productively ties appearance, the satisfaction of social patterns and norms, and belonging together.
72 See, for instance, Aaron’s comments in relation to this:
they’ve had to do it slowly, because if they’d just gone, bang, there were gays, there would have been an absolute uproar and people, you know, and people would have been like, no, there were no gays, no, no, none, no, no, no, none.
85 Puar (Citation2007). See also Schotten (Citation2016) for an indication of how Puar’s thesis in relation to US sexual exceptionalism can be globalised.
Kay Levine and Virginia Mellema (2001) ‘Strategizing the Street: How Law Matters in the Lives of Women in the Street-Level Drug Economy’, 26(1) Law & Social Inquiry 169. doi: 10.1111/j.1747-4469.2001.tb00175.x Emmanuel Melissaris (2009) Ubiquitous Law: Legal Theory and the Space of Legal Pluralism, Routledge. Margaret Davies (2017) Law Unlimited: Materialism, Pluralism, and Legal Theory, Routledge. Andreas Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos (2015) Spatial Justice: Body, Lawscape, Atmosphere, Routledge. Jan Assmann (2011) Cultural Memory and Early Civilization: Writing, Remembrance, and Political Imagination, Cambridge University Press. Hans Lindahl (2010) ‘A-legality: Postnationalism and the Question of Legal Boundaries’, 73(1) The Modern Law Review 30. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2230.2009.00783.x Marc Hertogh (2018) Nobody’s Law: Legal Consciousness and Legal Alienation in Everyday Life, Palgrave Macmillan. Roberto Esposito (2013) Terms of the Political: Community, Immunity, Biopolitics, trans. Rhiannon Welch, Fordham University Press. Tony Blackshaw (2010) Key Concepts in Community Studies, SAGE. Nina Philadelphoff-Puren and Peter Rush (2003) ‘Fatal (F)laws: Law, Literature and Writing’ 14 Law and Critique 191. doi: 10.1023/A:1024799619365 Joy Damousi and Marilyn Lake (eds) (1995) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Patricia Ewick and Susan Silbey (1998) The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life, University of Chicago Press. Marian Valverde (2012) Everyday Law on the Street: City Governance in an Age of Diversity, University of Chicago Press. Fleur Johns (2013) Non-legality in International Law, Cambridge University Press. Margaret Davies (2017) Law Unlimited: Materialism, Pluralism, and Legal Theory, Routledge. Margaret Davies (2005) ‘The Ethos of Pluralism’ 27(1) Sydney Law Review 87. Lisa Duggan (2003) The Twilight of Equality: Neoliberalism, Cultural Politics, and the Attack on Democracy, Beacon Press. Francesca Romana Ammaturo (2014) ‘The Right to a Privilege? Homonormativity and the Recognition of Same-Sex Couples in Europe’ 23(2) Social & Legal Studies 175. doi: 10.1177/0964663914521651 Hans Lindahl (2013) Fault Lines of Globalization: Legal Order and the Politics of A-legality, Oxford University Press. Hans Lindahl (2013) Fault Lines of Globalization: Legal Order and the Politics of A-legality, Oxford University Press. Dave Cowan and Helen Carr (2016) ‘What’s the Use of a Hashtag? A Case Study’ 43(3) Journal of Law and Society 416. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-6478.2016.00761.x Webb Keane (2005) ‘Signs are not the Garb of Meaning: on the Social Analysis of Material Things’ in D Miller (ed) Materiality, Duke University Press. Joanne Conaghan (2013) ‘Feminism, Law, and Materialism: Reclaiming the “Tainted Realm”’ in M Davies and V Munro (eds) The Ashgate Research Companion to Feminist Legal Theory, Routledge. Andreas Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos (2015) Spatial Justice: Body, Lawscape, Atmosphere, Routledge. Devyani Prabhat (2018) Britishness, Belonging and Citizenship: Experiencing Nationality Law, Policy Press. Marc Hertogh (2018) Nobody’s Law: Legal Consciousness and Legal Alienation in Everyday Life, Palgrave Macmillan. Susanne Karstedt (ed) (2009) Legal Institutions and Collective Memories, Hart. Uladzislau Belavusau and Aleksandra Gliszczyńska-Grabias (eds) (2017) Law and Memory: Towards Legal Governance of History, Cambridge University Press. Emilios Christodolidis and Scott Veitch (2009) ‘Reflections on Law and Memory’ in S Karstedt (ed) Legal Institutions and Collective Memories, Hart. Stiina Löytömäki (2012) ‘Law and Memory: the Politics of Victimhood’, 21(1) Griffith Law Review 1. doi: 10.1080/10383441.2012.10854730 Jonathan Smith (2004) ‘Reflecting on the Development of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis and its Contribution to Qualitative Research in Psychology’ 1(1) Qualitative Research in Psychology 39. Jonathan Smith, et al (2009) Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis: Theory, Method and Research, SAGE. Jonathan Smith and Mike Osborn (2008) ‘Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis’ in J Smith (ed) Qualitative Psychology: A Practical Guide to Methods, 2nd edn, SAGE. Ruaidhri Mulveen and Julie Hepworth (2006) ‘An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of Participation in a Pro-anorexia Internet Site and Its Relationship with Disordered Eating’ 11(2) Journal of Health Psychology 283. doi: 10.1177/1359105306061187 Kathryn Munroe, et al (2016) ‘The Experiences of African Immigrant Mothers Living in the United Kingdom with a Child Diagnosed with an Autism Spectrum Disorder: an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis’ 31(6) Disability & Society 798. doi: 10.1080/09687599.2016.1200015 Jonathan Smith (2004) ‘Reflecting on the Development of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis and its Contribution to Qualitative Research in Psychology’ 1(1) Qualitative Research in Psychology 39. Jonathan Smith and Mike Osborn (2008) ‘Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis’ in J Smith (ed) Qualitative Psychology: A Practical Guide to Methods, 2nd edn, SAGE. Bob Carter and Alison Sealey (2007) ‘Languages, Nations and Identities’ 2(2) Methodological Innovation Online 20. doi: 10.4256/mio.2007.0009 Jeffrey Olick and Joyce Robbins (1998) ‘Social Memory Studies: From “Collective Memory” to the Historical Sociology of Mnemonic Practices’ 24(1) Annual Review of Sociology 105. doi: 10.1146/annurev.soc.24.1.105 Jan Assmann (2011) Cultural Memory and Early Civilization: Writing, Remembrance, and Political Imagination, Cambridge University Press. Monika Reif-Hülser (2012) ‘South African Transition in the Literary Imagination: Nadine Gordimer, J.M. Coetzee, Malika Lueen Ndlovu’ in A Assmann & L Shortt (eds) Memory and Political Change, Palgrave Macmillan. Anja Schwarz (2012) ‘“That’s Not a Story I Could Tell.” Commemorating the Other Side of the Colonial Frontier in Australian Literature and Reconciliation’ in A Assmann & L Shortt (eds) Memory and Political Change, Palgrave Macmillan. Jo McCormack (2011) ‘Social Memories in (Post)Colonial France: Remembering the Franco-Algerian War’ 44(4) Journal of Social History 1129. doi: 10.1353/jsh.2011.0048 Aleida Assmann and Linda Shortt (eds) (2012) Memory and Political Change, Palgrave Macmillan. Aileen Moreton-Robinson (2015) The White Possessive: Property, Power, and Indigenous Sovereignty, University of Minnesota Press. Enika Abazi and Albert Doja (2018) ‘Time and Narrative: Temporality, Memory, and Instant History of Balkan Wars’ 27(2) Time & Society 239. doi: 10.1177/0961463X16678249 Marilyn Lake (2010) ‘Introduction: What Have You Done for Your Country?’ in M Lake & H Reynolds (eds) What’s Wrong with ANZAC?: The Militarisation of Australian History, University of New South Wales Press. Paul Daley (2018) On Patriotism, Melbourne University Press. Ben Wadham (2013) ‘Brotherhood: Homosociality, Totality and Military Subjectivity’, 28(76) Australian Feminist Studies 212. doi: 10.1080/08164649.2013.792440 Devyani Prabhat (2018) Britishness, Belonging and Citizenship: Experiencing Nationality Law, Policy Press. Claire Sutherland (2017) Reimagining the Nation: Togetherness, Belonging and Mobility, Bristol University Press. Yorick Smaal (2015) Sex, Soldiers and the South Pacific, 1939–45: Queer Identities in Australia in the Second World War, Palgrave Macmillan. Noah Riseman, et al (2018) Serving in Silence? Australian LGBT Servicemen and Women, NewSouth Publishing. Anne-Marie Condé, (2007) ‘War History on Scraps of Paper: Exhibitions of Documents at the Australian War Memorial, 1922–1954’ 14 Public History Review 25. doi: 10.5130/phrj.v14i0.301 Marilyn Lake and Joy Damousi (1995) ‘Introduction: Welfare, History and Gender’ in J Damousi & M Lake (eds) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Ruth Ford (1995) ‘Lesbians and Loose Women: Female Sexuality and the Women’s Services during World War II’ in J Damousi and M Lake (eds) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Yorick Smaal and Graham Willett (2015) ‘Eliminate the “Females”: The New Guinea Affair and Medical Approaches to Homosexuality in the Australian Army in the Second World War’, in C Twomey and E Koh (eds) The Pacific War: Aftermaths, Remembrance, and Culture, Routledge. Noah Riseman (2018) ‘Activism and Australia’s Ban on Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Military Service in the 1970s–80s’, 33(95) Australian Feminist Studies 147. doi: 10.1080/08164649.2018.1498728 Noah Riseman (2018) ‘Activism and Australia’s Ban on Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Military Service in the 1970s–80s’, 33(95) Australian Feminist Studies 147. doi: 10.1080/08164649.2018.1498728 Yorick Smaal and Graham Willett (2015) ‘Eliminate the “Females”: The New Guinea Affair and Medical Approaches to Homosexuality in the Australian Army in the Second World War’, in C Twomey and E Koh (eds) The Pacific War: Aftermaths, Remembrance, and Culture, Routledge. Judith Butler (2009) Frames of War: When is Life Grievable?, Verso Books. Mike Ojakangas (2003) ‘Carl Schmitt’s Real Enemy: the Citizen of the Non-exclusive Democratic Community?’ 8(4) The European Legacy 411. doi: 10.1080/1084877032000138567 Noah Riseman (2017) ‘“Just Another Start to the Denigration of Anzac Day”: Evolving Commemorations of LGBTI Military Service’, 48(1) Australian Historical Studies 35. doi: 10.1080/1031461X.2016.1251476 Fiona Nicoll (2001) From Diggers to Drag Queens: Configurations of Australian National Identity, Pluto Press. Nina Philadelphoff-Puren and Peter Rush (2003) ‘Fatal (F)laws: Law, Literature and Writing’ 14 Law and Critique 191. doi: 10.1023/A:1024799619365 Raewyn Connell and James Messerschmidt (2005) ‘Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept’ 19(6) Gender & Society 829. doi: 10.1177/0891243205278639 Joy Damousi and Marilyn Lake (eds) (1995) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Alistair Thomson (1989) ‘Steadfast until Death? CEW Bean and the Representation of Australian Military Manhood’ 23(93) Australian Historical Studies 462. doi: 10.1080/10314618908595824 Marilyn Lake (1992) ‘Mission Impossible: How Men Gave Birth to the Australian Nation: Gender, Nationalism and Other Seminal Acts’, 4(3) Gender and History 305. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-0424.1992.tb00152.x Noah Riseman (2018) ‘Activism and Australia’s Ban on Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Military Service in the 1970s–80s’, 33(95) Australian Feminist Studies 147. doi: 10.1080/08164649.2018.1498728 Carmel Shute (1995) ‘Heroines and Heroes: Sexual Mythology in Australia 1914–18’ in J Damousi & M Lake (eds) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Garry Wotherspoon (1995) ‘Comrades-in-arms: World War II and Male Homosexuality in Australia’ in J Damousi & M Lake (eds) Gender and War, Cambridge University Press. Vanessa May (2011) ‘Self, Belonging and Social Change’ 45(3) Sociology 363. doi: 10.1177/0038038511399624 Tristan Bridges (2014) ‘A Very “Gay” Straight? Hybrid Masculinities, Sexual Aesthetics, and the Changing Relationship between Masculinity and Homophobia’ 28(1) Gender & Society 58. doi: 10.1177/0891243213503901 Emily Kazyak (2012) ‘Midwest or Lesbian? Gender, Rurality, and Sexuality’, 26(6) Gender & Society 825. doi: 10.1177/0891243212458361 Jonathan Bollen, et al (2008) Men at Play: Masculinities in Australian Theatre since the 1950s, Rodopi. J Edward Sumerau (2012), ‘“That’s What a Man Is Supposed to Do”: Compensatory Manhood Acts in an LGBT Christian Church’ 26(3) Gender & Society 461. doi: 10.1177/0891243212439748 João Manuel de Oliveira, Carlos Gonçalves Costa, and Conceição Nogueira (2013), ‘The Workings of Homonormativity: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Queer Discourses on Discrimination and Public Displays of Affections in Portugal’, 60 Journal of Homosexuality 1475. doi: 10.1080/00918369.2013.819221 Lisa Duggan (2002) ‘The New Homonormativity: The Sexual Politics of Neoliberalism’, in R Castronovo and D Nelson (eds) Materializing Democracy, Duke University Press. Lisa Duggan (2002) ‘The New Homonormativity: The Sexual Politics of Neoliberalism’, in R Castronovo and D Nelson (eds) Materializing Democracy, Duke University Press. Francesca Romana Ammaturo (2014) ‘The Right to a Privilege? Homonormativity and the Recognition of Same-Sex Couples in Europe’ 23(2) Social & Legal Studies 175. doi: 10.1177/0964663914521651 Julie Podmore (2013) ‘Critical Commentary: Sexualities Landscapes Beyond Homonormativity’, 49 Geoforum 263. doi: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2013.03.014 Lisa Duggan (2002) ‘The New Homonormativity: The Sexual Politics of Neoliberalism’, in R Castronovo and D Nelson (eds) Materializing Democracy, Duke University Press. Stephanie Taylor and Margaret Wetherell (1999) ‘A Suitable Time and Place’ 8(1) Time & Society 39. doi: 10.1177/0961463X99008001003 Damien Riggs and Clemence Due (2013). ‘Moving Beyond Homonormativity in Teacher Training: Experiences from South Australia’, 13(S1) Sex Education 99. doi: 10.1080/14681811.2012.760447 Damien Riggs and Clemence Due (2013). ‘Moving Beyond Homonormativity in Teacher Training: Experiences from South Australia’, 13(S1) Sex Education 99. doi: 10.1080/14681811.2012.760447 Francesca Romana Ammaturo (2014) ‘The Right to a Privilege? Homonormativity and the Recognition of Same-Sex Couples in Europe’ 23(2) Social & Legal Studies 175. doi: 10.1177/0964663914521651 Thibaut Raboin (2017) ‘Exhortations of Happiness: Liberalism and Nationalism in the Discourses on LGBTI Asylum Rights in the UK’, 20(5–6) Sexualities 663. doi: 10.1177/1363460716645802 Michael Nebeling Petersen and Lene Myong (2015) ‘(Un)liveabilities: Homonationalism and Transnational Adoption’, 18(3) Sexualities 329. doi: 10.1177/1363460714544809 Lain Mathers, JE Sumerau, & Ryan Cragun (2018) ‘The Limits of Homonormativity: Constructions of Bisexual and Transgender People in the Post-gay Era’, 61(6) Sociological Perspectives 934. doi: 10.1177/0731121417753370 João Manuel de Oliveira, Carlos Gonçalves Costa, and Conceição Nogueira (2013), ‘The Workings of Homonormativity: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Queer Discourses on Discrimination and Public Displays of Affections in Portugal’, 60 Journal of Homosexuality 1475. doi: 10.1080/00918369.2013.819221 Lisa Duggan (2002) ‘The New Homonormativity: The Sexual Politics of Neoliberalism’, in R Castronovo and D Nelson (eds) Materializing Democracy, Duke University Press. Margaret Davies (2005) ‘The Ethos of Pluralism’ 27(1) Sydney Law Review 87. Ann-Dorte Christensen (2009) ‘Belonging and Unbelonging from an Intersectional Perspective’ 13(1) Gender, Technology and Development 21. doi: 10.1177/097185240901300102 Jasbir Puar (2013) ‘Homonationalism as Assemblage: Viral Travels, Affective Sexualities’, 4(2) Jindal Global Law Review 23. Jasbir Puar (2007) Terrorist Assemblages: Homonationalism in Queer Times, Duke University Press. C Heike Schotten (2016) ‘Homonationalism: From Critique to Diagnosis, or, We Are All Homonational Now’, 18(3) International Feminist Journal of Politics 361. doi: 10.1080/14616742.2015.1103061 Vanja Hamzić (2017) ‘Alegality: Outside and Beyond the Legal Logic of Late Capitalism’ in H Brabazon (ed) Neoliberal Legality: Understanding the Role of Law in the Neoliberal Project, Routledge.