Residents’ Experiences of Negative Emotions toward Patients: Challenges to their Identities

Abstract

PhenomenonMedical learners are more likely than practicing physicians to experience negative emotions toward some patients whom they find challenging, and medical students experience such emotions related to their identity as learners. Little is known about experiences of residents, who are further along in their physician identity formation and have greater autonomy and competence. We explored and characterized how residents understand their experiences of the phenomenon of feeling negative emotions toward patients in relation to their identities as residents. Approach: In 2018, 305 final-year obstetrics and gynecology residents were invited to participate in interviews, which we conducted until reaching theoretical sufficiency. In semi-structured interviews conducted by phone, we probed interactions when residents felt negative emotions toward patients, including reasons for their feelings related to their professional identities, strategies, and curricular desires. The authors coded data and identified patterns using thematic analysis. Findings: Nineteen residents were interviewed by phone. Residents experienced negative emotions toward patients because of challenges to their identities as: physicians – wanting respect and specific unexpected patient behaviors; learners – desiring complete autonomy and experiencing challenges with attending physicians; teachers – wanting to be a role model and protect junior learners; and workers – trying to complete tasks. Among the strategies used to manage feelings toward patients, they struggled with “venting”, or complaining about patients, which was not always helpful and residents recognized as perceived negatively by students. They desired curricular support for these interactions such as debriefs and other supported reflection, faculty modeling, and communication skills training. Insights: Like medical students and physicians in practice, residents experience negative emotions toward patients, often because of and made more difficult by their identities as physicians, learners, teachers, and workers. Educators should support residents’ reflections about these interactions, model compassionate behavior when feeling challenged by patients, and address unhealthy coping strategies.

Keywords:

• reflection
• emotion
• difficult patient interactions

Funding

The author(s) reported there is no funding associated with the work featured in this article.