Culture matters: Chinese mental health professionals’ fear of losing face in routine outcome monitoring

Abstract

Objective:

The culturally salient fear of losing face might influence Chinese therapists’ attitudes toward and use of routine outcome monitoring (ROM). We tested a model wherein self-face concern is associated with ROM use by way of attitudes toward ROM, and whether this process is weakened when therapists report high counseling self-efficacy and perspective-taking.

Method:

A national sample of Chinese mental health professionals (N = 371) completed questionnaires on their fear of losing face, attitudes toward ROM, ROM use, counseling self-efficacy, and perspective-taking.

Results:

Regression-based analyses showed that fear of losing face was linked to greater negative attitudes toward ROM and lower ROM use. Greater negative attitudes mediated the relationship between fear of losing face and ROM use. However, neither counseling self-efficacy nor perspective-taking mitigated the relationship between self-face concern and ROM use; instead, they exacerbated this relationship through different paths. In the mediated pathway, counseling self-efficacy in coping with clients with difficult problems interacted with self-face concern to predict negative attitudes toward ROM. Perspective-taking served as a moderator that exacerbated the direct relationship between self-face concern and ROM use.

Conclusions:

Findings suggest the importance of considering culturally salient factors in implementing ROM in China and other non-Western contexts.

Keywords:

• routine outcome monitoring
• fear of losing face
• ROM implementation
• self-efficacy
• perspective-taking
• culture

Acknowledgements

We would like to extend our gratitude to Dr. Qingqi Liu for his assistance in the data analysis of this manuscript.

Disclosure Statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).