Do Spiritual Struggles Predict Poorer Physical/Mental Health Among Jews?

Abstract

Although spirituality and religion are generally associated with higher levels of physical and mental well-being, spiritual struggles, which involve tension in regard to spiritual issues, have been identified as a risk factor for poorer physical and mental health, especially among individuals with greater levels of personal religiousness. However, studies in this area have utilized predominantly Christian samples and the importance of spiritual struggles to Jews is not known. We proposed and tested two competing models in an adult Jewish community sample: (a) the Universal Effects model in which spiritual struggles were proposed to be associated with decreased levels of physical/mental health, and more problematic for more religious Jews, and (b) the Differential Effects model in which spiritual struggles were proposed to be generally unrelated to the physical/mental health of Jews, and even less impactful on religious Jews. We found some support for both models. Spiritual struggles were modestly associated with lower levels of physical/mental health in the sample as a whole, even after controlling for demographic covariates. However, at the highest levels of spiritual struggle, Orthodox Jews exhibited an increase in physical and mental health whereas non-Orthodox Jews' health continued to decrease.

Notes

David H. Rosmarin is now a clinical fellow in the Department of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.

^aThese norms for the SF-36 are based on a randomized sample of the population of Britain conducted by the Office for National Statistics in 1992 (Bowling, Bond, Jenkinson, & Lamping, 1999).

*p < .05.

**p < .01.

*p < .05.

**p < .01.

***p < .001.