Abstract
This essay explores the use of the mother tongue on the part of poor, primarily black women who were welfare recipient-activists in the late 1960s. In contrast to the “feminine style” described by Campbell as “inductive, even circuitous” and “somewhat tentative” in tone (Campbell, Citation1986, p. 440), the mother tongue is direct, unequivocal, and at times irreverent or indecorous for the given speaking situation. Recipient-activists used the mother tongue to refute prevailing stereotypes such as the “welfare chiseler” and the “welfare queen.” The study complicates notions of the feminine style by calling attention to the influence of race and class on rhetorical intervention in public policy debates.
Notes
Quoted in May, 1965, p. 13.
Social Security and Welfare Proposals, 1969, p. 1013.
Jeppesen (2009) and Katz (Citation1989) represent two of the very few studies on poor people's rhetorics.
In 2008, the National Communication Association's annual conference theme was “The Engaged Discipline.”
In the 2010 case, Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, the Supreme Court decided in favor of unlimited corporate expenditure to support independent political organizations.
See Foss and Griffin's (Citation1995) advocacy of “invitational” rhetoric. Also noteworthy, an Institute for Civil Discourse has been formed at the University of Arizona to promote a “research and policy regarding civil discourse consistent with First Amendment principles” (para. 1).
Johnnie Tillmon founded ANC Mothers Anonymous located in Watts, California, in the early 1960s. She later went on to become the first chair of the National Welfare Rights Organization (see White, Citation1999, pp. 223–226).
The place of housework within a capitalist system—and whether or not it constituted productive or unproductive labor—was debated by women in the Communist Party, among other places. In her book, In Woman's Defense, Mary Inman argued in contrast with other female CPers that housework was productive labor deserving of pay (see Weigand, Citation2001).
The Welfare Fighter, during its run from 1969–1972, regularly featured articles on the successes of both local WROs and the national organization, including stories of important legal victories won at the federal level.
For recent scholarship on the disciplining effects of calls for civility, see Dow (Citation1995), Fulkerson (Citation1996). Lozano-Reich and Cloud (Citation2009), Pollock, Artz, Frey, Pearce, and Murphy (1996), and Tonn (Citation2005). Note that discussions over the limitations of traditional means of communication for disempowered groups have been present among communication scholars since the 1960s (Andrews, Citation1969; Barnlund & Haiman, Citation1960; Griffin, Citation1964; Haiman, Citation1967; Scott & Smith, Citation1969; Simons, Citation1972).
Given space limitations, the issue of standpoint was not introduced in the present study. For a start, see Alcoff (Citation2006), Hartsock (Citation1983), and Lukacs (Citation1968). Work among standpoint theorists has been diverse with studies focusing on the impact of standpoint on reception (Droogsma, Citation2007; Harris & Donmoyer, Citation2000; Kinefuchi & Orbe, Citation2008) and production (Ellingson, Citation2000) of cultural texts; while others have grappled with the “commonality-diversity” problematic—recognizing differences among women even as they speak of a common women's experience (K. E. Bell, Orbe, Drummond, & Camara, Citation2000; Dougherty & Krone, Citation2000; Hallstein, Citation2000, p. 3; Harding, Citation1991; Wood, Citation1992). Black feminists have challenged tendencies toward reducing the female experience to a white experience highlighting black women's unique position as “outsider-within” (Collins, Citation1986, Citation1991; hooks, Citation1984, Citation1989; Moraga & Anzaldua, Citation1983).
Katz
,
M.
(
1989
).
The undeserving poor: From the war on poverty to the war on welfare
.
New York
,
NY
:
Random House
.
Foss
,
S. K.
, &
Griffin
,
C. L.
(
1995
).
Beyond persuasion: A proposal for an invitational rhetoric
.
Communication Monographs
,
62
,
2
–
18
.
White
,
D. G.
(
1999
).
Too heavy a load: Black women in defense of themselves, 1894–1994
.
New York
,
NY
:
W. W. Norton & Company
.
Weigand
,
K.
(
2001
).
Red feminism: American Communism and the making of women's liberation
.
Baltimore
,
MD
:
Johns Hopkins University Press
.
Dow
,
B. J.
(
1995
).
Feminism, difference(s), and rhetorical studies
.
Communication Studies
,
46
,
106
–
117
.
Fulkerson
,
R.
(
1996
).
Transcending our conception of argument in light of feminist critiques
.
Argumentation and Advocacy
,
32
,
199
–
218
.
Lozano-Reich
,
N. M.
, &
Cloud
,
D. L.
(
2009
).
The uncivil tongue: Invitational rhetoric and the problem of inequality
.
Western Journal of Communication
,
73
,
220
–
226
.
Tonn
,
M. B.
(
2005
).
Taking conversation, dialogue and therapy public
.
Rhetoric & Public Affairs
,
8
,
405
–
430
.
Andrews
,
J. R.
(
1969
).
Confrontation at Columbia: A case study in coercive rhetoric
.
Quarterly Journal of Speech
,
55
,
9
–
16
.
Barnlund
,
D. C.
, &
Haiman
,
F. S.
(
1960
).
The dynamics of discussion
.
Boston
,
MA
:
Houghton Mifflin
.
Griffin
,
L.
(
1964
).
The rhetorical structure of the “New Left” movement: Part I
.
Quarterly Journal of Speech
,
50
,
113
–
135
.
Haiman
,
F. S.
(
1967
).
The rhetoric of the streets: Some legal and ethical considerations
.
Quarterly Journal of Speech
,
53
,
99
–
114
.
Scott
,
R. L.
, &
Smith
,
D. K.
(
1969
).
The rhetoric of confrontation
.
Quarterly Journal of Speech
,
55
,
1
–
8
.
Simons
,
H.
(
1972
).
Persuasion in social conflicts: A critique of prevailing conceptions and a framework for future research
.
Speech Monographs
,
39
,
227
–
247
.
Alcoff
,
L. M.
(
2006
).
Visible identities: Race, gender, and the self
.
New York
,
NY
:
Oxford University Press
.
Hartsock
,
N.
(
1983
).
Money, sex, and power: Toward a feminist historical materialism
.
New York
,
NY
:
Longman
.
Lukacs
,
G.
(
1968
).
History and class consciousness: Studies in Marxist dialectics
.
Cambridge
,
MA
:
The MIT Press
.
Droogsma
,
R. A.
(
2007
).
Redefining Hijab: American Muslim women's standpoints on veiling
.
Journal of Applied Communication Research
,
35
,
294
–
319
.
Harris
,
T. M.
, &
Donmoyer
,
D.
(
2000
).
Is art imitating life?: Communication gender and racial identity in Imitation of Life
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
23
,
91
–
110
.
Kinefuchi
,
E.
, &
Orbe
,
M. P.
(
2008
).
Situating oneself in a racialized world: Understanding student reactions to Crash through standpoint theory and context-positionality frames
.
Journal of International and Intercultural Communication
,
1
,
70
–
90
.
Ellingson
,
L. L.
(
2000
).
Style, substance, and standpoint: A feminist critique of Bernie Siegel's rhetoric of self-healing
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
23
,
63
–
90
.
Bell
,
K. E.
,
Orbe
,
M. P.
,
Drummond
,
D. K.
, &
Camara
,
S. K.
(
2000
).
Accepting the challenge of centralizing without essentializing: Black feminist through an African American woman's communicative experiences
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
23
,
41
–
62
.
Dougherty
,
D. S.
, &
Krone
,
K. J.
(
2000
).
Overcoming the dichotomy: Cultivating standpoints in organizations through research
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
23
,
16
–
40
.
Hallstein
,
D. L. O.
(
2000
).
Where standpoint stands now: An introduction and commentary
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
23
,
1
–
15
.
Harding
,
S.
(
1991
).
Whose science? Whose knowledge? Thinking from women's lives
.
Ithaca
,
NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Wood
,
J. T.
(
1992
).
Gender and moral voice: Moving from women's nature to standpoint epistemology
.
Women's Studies in Communication
,
15
,
1
–
24
.
Collins
,
P. H.
(
1986
).
Learning from the outsider-within: The sociological significance of black feminist thought
.
Social Problems
,
33
,
S14
–
S32
.
Collins
,
P. H.
(
1991
).
Black feminist thought: Knowledge, consciousness, and the politics of empowerment
.
New York
,
NY
:
Routledge
.
Hooks
,
B.
(
1984
).
Feminist theory from margin to center
.
Boston
,
MA
:
South End Press
.
Hooks
,
B.
(
1989
).
Talking back: Thinking feminist, thinking black
.
Boston
,
MA
:
South End Press
.
Moraga
,
C.
, &
Anzaldua
,
G.
(Eds.). (
1983
).
This bridge called my back: Writings by radical women of color
.
Watertown
,
MA
:
Persephone Press
. Additional information
Notes on contributors
Mary E. Triece
Mary E. Triece is a Professor at the School of Communication, University of Akron.