Would 3D Digital Participatory Planning Improve Social Sustainability in Smart Cities? An Empirical Evaluation Study in Less-Advantaged Areas

ABSTRACT

This study evaluates the impact of using three-dimensional digital participatory planning (3DDPP) on planning practices. This method was tested within the framework of a redevelopment project in one of the less-advantaged neighborhoods in the Dutch city of Schiedam. An interactive 3DDPP tool was employed by a group of residents who co-designed public spaces in the neighborhood. Residents were given the opportunity to visualize online the project area in 3D format, suggest their ideas, comment on the design proposal, produce interactive graphical designs online, and interact with each other. The impact of this process was tested according to five criteria (efficiency, feasibility, attractiveness, interaction, and satisfaction) developed via free-listing and pile-sorting methods in collaboration with nine experts. A qualitatively driven (QUAL) mixed method was used to analyze the data collected from a sample of 62 subjects, which included professionals and citizens. The results showed that the use of 3DDPP tools can potentially enhance community engagement in decision-making. This article concludes by emphasizing that socioeconomic, political, and demographic challenges, which might decrease the residents’ willingness to be actively engaged in collaborative decision-making, might not solely be solved via technologies.

KEYWORDS:

• E-participation
• co-creation
• participatory planning assessment
• community engagement
• smart cities
• Europe

Disclosure Statement

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Additional information

Funding

Research fund was provided by Schiedam Municipality, Netherlands and is hereby gratefully acknowledged. Schiedam Municipality is not involved in the study design, the collection, analysis resources, in the writing of the article, nor the decision to submit the article for publication.

Notes on contributors

Islam Bouzguenda

Islam Bouzguenda is an architect/planner who holds a Ph.D. in Environmental Analysis and Regional Planning from the Universitat de Girona.

Nadia Fava

Nadia Fava is an architect at the IUAV University of Venice and holds a PhD from the Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya.

Chaham Alalouch

Chaham Alalouch is an assistant professor in architectural engineering at Sultan Qaboos University, Oman.