The Application of Cash-Flow-at-Risk to Risk Management in a Deregulated Electricity Market

ABSTRACT

The current level of deregulation in electricity markets is continuing to expand. Although each of these markets has individual operational and financial structures, one common characteristic is volatility. This volatility is significant and time-varying, and the persistence of this volatility makes the management of financial risk a priority among market participants.

This article considers two applications of an innovative spot price model to risk management in such a market. The first application is the empirical estimation of risk premia in the market considered here. The results support other approaches, which find the risk premia to be both significant and time-variant. In addition, this work considers the application of a Cash-Flow-at-Risk (CFaR) approach to measuring and comparing financial risk among various portfolio alternatives. These portfolios are considered from the perspective of the electricity producer, and the electricity purchaser. This approach is flexible and practical, allowing the comparison among portfolios and across seasons. The results of this analysis show that derivative instruments are significantly over-priced in this market, and that producers have the opportunity to earn significant profits, above those justified by the inherent risk in the market.

Key Words:

• Cash-Flow-at-Risk
• deregulated electricity markets
• energy price
• volume risk

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Both authors thank the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada for funding; Davison thanks the Mathematics of Information Technology and Complex Systems Network of Centres of Excellence (Canada) for funding.