Consulting With a Surgeon Before Breast Cancer Surgery: Patient Question Asking and Satisfaction

Abstract

Research has found a negative association between patient question asking and aspects of their satisfaction. In the context of surgical oncology, the aim of this exploratory study was to test the association between patient question asking and 3 indices of their satisfaction. Participants included 51 women who were newly diagnosed with breast cancer engaged in presurgical consultations with a surgical oncologist from a National Cancer Institute–designated cancer center in the Northeastern United States. Outcomes were patients' postconsultation reports of their satisfaction with the treatment plan, intentions to adhere to the treatment plan, and satisfaction with the surgeon. The main predictor was the frequency of patients' self-initiated questions coded from videotapes of consultations. The frequency of patients' self-initiated questions was negatively associated with their satisfaction with the treatment plan (p = .02), intentions to adhere to the treatment plan (p = .02), and satisfaction with the surgeon (p = .07). Results can be explained in terms of patients' perceptions that the surgeon's information was insufficient or inadequate. Future research needs to identify the specific content of patients' questions and how such content might be associated with satisfaction.

Notes

*Column shows percentage except where noted to show mean and standard deviation (age, preconsultation anxiety, and preconsultation uncertainty).

Note. For preexisting relationship with surgeon, 0 = no prior relationship, 1 = prior relationship.

Note. For educational attainment, 0 = less than B.A., 1 = B.A. and greater.