The development and validation of an alternative assessment to measure changes in understanding of the longleaf pine ecosystem

Abstract

A drawing assessment to gauge changes in fourth grade students’ understanding of the essential components of the longleaf pine ecosystem was developed to support an out-of-school environmental education program. Pre- and post-attendance drawings were scored with a rubric that was determined to have content validity and reliability among users. In the specific context of this intervention, the assessment documented significant growth in the understanding of the essential components, processes, flora and fauna of the ecosystem. This assessment found no significant differential advantage with respect to gender or dominance status of the students and is offered as an alternative to traditional assessments that favor select groups. Extensions of this framework to other ecosystems, and implications for in-service/pre-service educators and science proficiency, are discussed.

Keywords:

• drawings
• instrument
• assessment
• learning
• environment

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to acknowledge the dedication and support of Mr. M.C. Davis and the staff of the E.O. Wilson Biophilia Center.