https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6903-4319
![Sample our Politics & International Relations journals, sign in here to start your FREE access for 14 days]({"type":"image" , "src" : "/sda/5947/TOC-Subject-Sample-2021-Politics-International-Relations.jpg"})
ABSTRACT
The past decade has witnessed worldwide backsliding on democracy, and the COVID-19 pandemic might have exacerbated this trend. This study examined popular confidence in democracy in China, Japan, and South Korea, which represented authoritarian and democratic contexts. The results show that Chinese citizens had a negative perception of the capacity of democracy to control the outbreak of COVID-19 and achieve economic growth, with an unfavourable evaluation of democracy as a better political system than alternatives. Although Japanese and South Korean citizens had more favourable evaluations of democracy than their Chinese counterparts, such positive evaluations were lukewarm in the former two countries. Confidence in the home political system in South Korea did not correlate with confidence in the capability of democracy to address economic challenges, as observed in Japan. The COVID-19 pandemic prompted ordinary people to seek a strong leader, reinforcing Chinese citizens’ beliefs in the superiority of their authoritarian political system. Simultaneously, it weakened South Korean citizens’ confidence in the effectiveness of their home political system. However, it had no discernible impact on Japanese citizens’ belief in the superiority of their political system.
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments and suggestions on earlier drafts of this article. Data analyzed in this article were collected by the joint research project “COVID-19 and Relations between State & Society,” which was co-administered by Taisuke Fujita, Hidehiro Yamamoto, Yida Zhai, and Woontaek Lim. The views expressed herein are the author’s own.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
Notes
1 Chanley, Rudolph, and Rahn, “The Origins and Consequences of Public Trust in Government”; Hetherington, Why Trust Matters.
2 Levitsky and Way, “The New Competitive Authoritarianism”; Nathan, “China’s Challenge”; Perry, “The Illiberal Challenge of Authoritarian China.”
3 Mainwaring and Bizzarro, “The Fates of Third-Wave Democracies”; Wike and Fetterolf, “Liberal Democracy’s Crisis of Confidence.”
4 Bogaards, “De-Democratization in Hungary”; Plattner, “Is Democracy in Decline?” Repucci and Slipowitz, “Democracy in a Year of Crisis.”
5 Chen and Biswas, “Impact of National Culture on the Severity of the COVID-19 Pandemic”; Gelfand, Jackson et al., “The Relationship between Cultural Tightness-Looseness and COVID-19 Cases and Deaths”; Wang et al., “How Culture Orientation Influences the COVID-19 Pandemic.”
6 Chodor and Hameiri, “COVID-19 and the Pathologies of Australia’s Regulatory State.”
7 Han and Zhai, “The Association between Food Insecurity and Social Capital”; Zhai, “The Politics of COVID-19.”
8 Angelis and de Oliveira, “COVID-19 and the ‘State of Exception’.”
9 Zhai, “Pride and Prejudice”; Zhai et al., “Social Dominance Orientation, Right-Wing Authoritarianism, and Political Attitudes.”
10 Klingemann, “Mapping Political Support in the 1990s.”
11 Norris, Critical Citizens.
12 Chang, Chu, and Park, “Authoritarian Nostalgia in East Asia.”
13 Cho, “Citizens’ Support for Democracy”; Lührmann and Lindberg, “A Third Wave of Autocratization is Here”; Szymański, “De-Democratization.”
14 Bogaards, “De-Democratization in Hungary.”
15 Zhai, “Values Change and Support for Democracy in East Asia.”
16 Park, “Quality of Governance and Regime Support”; Park and Shin, “Popular Support for Democracy and Its Institutions in Korea.”
17 Fukuyama, “What is Governance?”
18 Aruguete and McCutcheon, “Who Wishes for a Strong Leader?”; Sprong et al. “‘Our Country Needs a Strong Leader Right Now’.”
19 Selvanathan, Crimston, and Jetten, “How Being Rooted in the Past Can Shape the Future.”
20 Lima et al., “Materialist and Post-Materialist Concerns.”
21 Brooks and Brady, “Income, Economic Voting.”
22 Johnston and Pattie, “Dimensions of Retrospective Voting.”
23 Dickson et al., “Public Goods and Regime Support in Urban China”; Wroe, “Economic Insecurity and Political Trust in the United States”; Zhai, “Looking Forward and Looking Backward.”
24 Bratton and Mattes, “Support for Democracy in Africa”; Zhai, “Quality of Governance and Political Support in China, Japan, and South Korea.”
25 Beetham, The Legitimation of Power.
26 Christensen and Lægreid, “Trust in Government.”
27 Liu, Su, and Wu, “How Modernization Theory Has Stumbled in China”; Wu and Wilkes, “Local-National Political Trust Patterns.”
28 Christmann, “Economic Performance, Quality of Democracy and Satisfaction with Democracy”; Tang, Public Opinion and Political Change in China; Zhai, “Looking Forward and Looking Backward.”
29 Ake, “The Unique Case of African Democracy”; Bratton and Mattes, “Support for Democracy in Africa”
30 Linz and Stepan, Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation, 5; Shin and Wells, “Is Democracy the Only Game in Town?”
31 Dalton, Shin, and Jou, “Understanding Democracy”; Jamal and Tessler, “Attitudes in the Arab World.”
32 Yeung, “Overestimation of the Level of Democracy Among Citizens in Nondemocracies.”
33 Lu and Shi, “The Battle of Ideas and Discourses Before Democratic Transition”; Yeung, “Overestimation of the Level of Democracy Among Citizens in Nondemocracies.”
34 Chu and Huang, “Solving an Asian Puzzle”; Shin, Confucianism and Democratization in East Asia.
35 Sprong et al., “‘Our Country Needs a Strong Leader Right Now’.”
36 Cho, “Citizens’ Support for Democracy.”
37 The V-Dem Institute, Democracy Report 2024, 23.
38 Fackler, “The Silencing of Japan’s Free Press”; Narita, “How Japanese Research Became the Centre of a Conservative Culture War.”
39 Angelis and de Oliveira, “COVID-19 and the ‘State of Exception’.”
40 Lu and Shi, “The Battle of Ideas and Discourses Before Democratic Transition”; Nathan, Chinese Democracy; Zhai, “Popular Perceptions of Democracy in China.”
41 Zhai, “Popular Perceptions of Democracy in China”; Zhai, “Pride and Prejudice.”
42 Shin, Confucianism and Democratization in East Asia; Zhai, “Values Change and Support for Democracy in East Asia.”
43 Zhai, “The Politics of COVID-19.”
44 Shen, “The Dynamic Zero-COVID Approach is the Only Way to Defeat the Virus”; Xinhua News Agency, “Are Chinese People Distinct from the Party?”
45 Machida et al., “Unwillingness to Cooperate with COVID-19 Contact Tracing in Japan”; Park, Choi, and Ko, “Information Technology-Based Tracing Strategy in Response to COVID-19 in South Korea—Privacy Controversies.”
46 Shoji et al., “Prosociality and the Uptake of COVID-19 Contact Tracing Apps.”
47 Chen et al., “A Cross-Country Core Strategy Comparison in China, Japan, Singapore and South Korea.”
48 Kuhlmann et al., “Tracing Divergence in Crisis Governance.”
49 Alfano, Ercolano, and Pinto, “Fighting the COVID Pandemic.”
50 Fukai, Kawata, and Nakabayashi, “Updated Beliefs and Shaken Confidence.”
51 Park, “Authoritarian Rule in South Korea.”
52 Im, “Better Democracy, Better Economic Growth? South Korea.”
53 Chang, Chu, and Park, “Authoritarian Nostalgia in East Asia.”
54 Chu and Huang, “Solving an Asian Puzzle”; Mainwaring and Bizzarro, “The Fates of Third-Wave Democracies.”
55 Ikeda and Kohno, “Japanese Attitudes and Values toward Democracy”; Shin and Wells, “Is Democracy the Only Game in Town?”
56 Bratton and Mattes, “Support for Democracy in Africa”; Huhe and Tang, “Contingent Instrumental and Intrinsic Support.”
57 Zhai, “Quality of Governance and Political Support in China, Japan, and South Korea.”
58 Aruguete and McCutcheon, “Who Wishes for A Strong Leader?”; Sprong et al. “‘Our Country Needs a Strong Leader Right Now’.”
59 Ikeda, Contemporary Japanese Politics and Anxiety Over Governance.
60 Cho, “Citizens’ Support for Democracy.”
61 Johnston and Pattie, “Dimensions of Retrospective Voting”; Wroe, “Economic Insecurity and Political Trust in the United States”; Zhai, “Looking Forward and Looking Backward.”
62 Lewis-Beck, Tang, and Martini, “A Chinese Popularity Function Sources of Government Support”; Ou-Yang and Zhou, “Economic Evaluations and Political Support in Authoritarian Countries”; Zhai, “Looking Forward and Looking Backward.”
Additional information
Funding
Notes on contributors
Yida Zhai
Yida Zhai is an Associate Professor in the School of International and Public Affairs at Shanghai Jiao Tong University. He received his PhD from the University of Tokyo. He studies political psychology, political sociology, and East Asian comparative politics/sociology. His research has appeared in Contemporary Politics, International Political Science Review, and other Chinese and Japanese journals.