Abstract
On the basis of a content analysis of 168 news items dealing with women in the two largest-circulation newspapers in Israel, this article investigates whether there was any change in the news media's representation of women during the Six Day War. The results indicate that while there was little change in women's representation in quantitative terms, that is, their visibility remained low, there were differences in qualitative terms. Whereas women typically appear in the news as victims, this type of representation was rare in the Six Day War, when women were represented in the context of the collective rather than the private sphere. Thus, the image of the “egotistical woman” was replaced by that of the “woman volunteer,” while the wife/mother image appeared in the national context during the war. However, once the war was over, women returned to their private world, and the image of the woman soldier as a sexual object also reappeared. Rather than enabling women to redefine their relations with men, the nation and the state, the war underlined their traditional gender roles.
Acknowledgments
I am very grateful to Dafna Lemish, Anat First, and Hagar Lahav for their help in preparing this article.
Notes
8. CitationFirst, “All Women Should Cry,” 35–61; Lemish, “Exclusion and Marginality,” 42–43.
9. Gallagher, Global Media, 43–47. This was found also in Israel: Lemish, Osim ve-osot, 5.
10. Lemish, “Media Gendering of War and Conflict,” 275.
11. Tidhar and Lemish, “Women in the Intifada,” 116–41.
21. Tydor-Baumel. “‘Hayinu sham’,” 439.
22. Tamar Lubushinski-Katako, “Dmut ha-lohemet ha-yehudiyah be-milhemet ha-olam ha-shniyah: Skirah historit (The image of the Jewish woman fighter during World War II: A historical survey) [January 14, 2004], available at http://www.aka.idf.il/yohalan/main/main.asp?catID = 26223 (accessed 29 December 2008); Tydor-Baumel. “‘Hayinu sham’,” 439.
23. Tamar Lubushinski-Katako, “Dmut ha-lohemet ha-yehudiyah be-milhemet ha-olam ha-shniyah: Skirah historit (The image of the Jewish woman fighter during World War II: A historical survey) [January 14, 2004], available at http://www.aka.idf.il/yohalan/main/main.asp?catID = 26223 (accessed 29 December 2008); Tydor-Baumel. “‘Hayinu sham’,”, 440.
24. CitationJerabi, Ha-mehir ha-kaful, 66–72. However, more combat roles are becoming available to women now. See Sasson-Levy. Zehuyot be-madim, 42–48.
26. Sasson-Levy, Zehuyot be-madim, 43–45.
29. As this study was primarily interested in a qualitative examination, references to men and women were not compared in quantitative terms. As noted above, numerous studies conducted in Israel and elsewhere over the years clearly indicate the quantitative exclusion of women from the news.
31. Gallagher, Global Media, 52.
32. Each reference to a different woman was counted. Multiple references to the same woman were counted only once.
33. CitationThe four figures accounted for 17 of the 22 roles identified.
34. Tydor-Baumel. “‘Hayinu sham’,” 439–41.
35. Ma'ariv, 28 May 1967, 7.
36. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 25 May 1967, 3.
37. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 12 June 1967, 11.
38. Ma'ariv, 30 May 1967, 3.
40. Ma'ariv, 30 May 1967, 3.
41. Ma'ariv, 26 May 1967, 19.
43. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 4 June 1967, 7.
44. Ma'ariv, 31 May 1967, 7.
46. Ma'ariv, 5 June 1967, 15.
47. Ma'ariv, 31 May 1967, 5.
48. Ma'ariv, 2 June 1967, 17.
50. Ma'ariv, 9 June 1967, 14. The lyrics and music were written during the war, and the song was recorded by the Israel Broadcasting Authority after the war; telephone interview with Shulamit Livnat, 29 September 2007. (English translation by Sarah Kitai.)
51. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 11 June 1967, 6.
52. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 1 June 1967, 2.
53. She was often referred to in the press as the “castrating woman” in the context of her relations with Yigal Allon and Dayan. CitationShapira, “Golda,” 62.
54. Almog, Preidah mi-Srulik, 880.
57. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 2 June 1967, 4.
58. Telephone interview with Herzliya Ron, one of the founders of the League of Women Voters, 18 September 2007.
59. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 28 May 1967, 7. Frederika Segal, an architect, bohemian, and celebrity who owned a discotheque in north Tel Aviv, was nicknamed “the queen of Tel-Aviv's night life.” Almog, Preidah mi-Srulik, 886, 1141. It seems that the term “disco-priestess” refers to a woman who spent most of her time at this discotheque.
60. Ma'ariv, 2 June 1967, 16.
61. Almog, Preidah mi-Srulik, 886.
62. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 31 May 1967, 1.
63. Ma'ariv, 30 May 1967, 4.
64. Yedi'ot Aharonot, 13 June 1967, 13.
65. This has been demonstrated by a variety of examples from different parts of the world; Ridd, “Powers of the Powerless,” 1–24.
67. Ridd, “Powers of the Powerless,” 4.
71. Zemer, “Beterem,” 236.
Ridd
,
Rosemary
.
1987
.
“
Powers of the Powerless
”
. In
Women and Political Conflict: Portraits of Struggle in Times of Crisis
,
Edited by:
Ridd
,
Rosemary
and
Callaway
,
Helen
.
1
–
24
.
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Caspi
,
Dan
and
Limor
,
Yehiel
.
1986
.
Ha-metavkhim. Emtza'ei ha-tikshoret be-Yisrael, 1948–1990
,
Tel Aviv
:
Am Oved
.
(The mediators: The mass media in Israel, 1948–1990)
Tuchman
,
Gaye
.
1978
.
“
Introduction: The Symbolic Annihilation of Women by the Mass Media
”
. In
Hearth and Home: Images of Women in the Mass Media
,
Edited by:
Tuchman
,
Gaye
,
Daniels
,
Arlene Kaplan
and
Benet
,
James
.
3
–
38
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Gill
,
Rosalind
.
2007
.
Gender and the Media
,
Cambridge
:
Polity
.
Kama
,
Amit
.
2003
.
“
Kri'ah pe'ilah: Rav-tarbutiyut ve-ilutzei ha-siah ha-hegemoni
”
. In
Tikshoret ke-tarbut (Communication as culture), vol. 2
, Yetzirat mashma'ut ke-mifgash bein tekst levein kor'im (The making of meaning as an encounter between text and reader)
,
Edited by:
Liebes
,
Tamar
,
Kama
,
Amit
and
Talmon
,
Miri
.
95
–
125
.
Tel Aviv
:
The Open University of Israel
.
(Active reading: Multiculturalism and the restrictions of the hegemonic discourse)
Byerly
,
Carolyn M.
and
Ross
,
Karen
.
2006
.
Women and Media: A Critical Introduction
,
Malden
:
Blackwell Publishing
.
Byerly
,
Carolyn M.
and
Ross
,
Karen
.
2006
.
Women and Media: A Critical Introduction
,
Malden
:
Blackwell Publishing
.
First
,
Anat
.
1995
.
All Women Should Cry: Coverage of Women in Foreign News – A Multi-National Study
.
Communications
,
27
(
1
)
:
35
–
61
.
Fogiel-Bijaoui
,
Sylvia
.
1998
.
Nashim ve-ezrahut be-Yisrael
.
Politikah
,
1
:
47
–
71
.
(Women and citizenship in Israel)
Kamir
,
Orit
.
2007
.
Kvod adam ve-Havah: Feminizim yisre'eli, mishpati ve-hevrati
,
Jerusalem
:
Carmel
.
(Israel's dignity-based feminism in law and society)
Herzog
,
Hanna
.
2006
.
“
Migdar
”
. In
I/shivyon (In/Equality)
,
Edited by:
Ram
,
Uri
and
Berkovitch
,
Nitza
.
220
–
27
.
Beer-Sheva
:
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press
.
(Gender)
Safran
,
Hanna
.
2006
.
Lo rotzot lihiyot nehmadot: Ha-ma'avak al zehut ha-behirah le-nashim ve-reshito shel ha-feminizm ha-hadash be-Yisrael
,
Haifa
:
Pardes
.
(Don't wanna be nice girls: The struggle for suffrage and the new feminism in Israel)
Berkovitch
,
Nitza
.
2001
.
“
Ezrahut ve-imahut: Ma'amadan shel nashim be-Yisrael
”
. In
Yisrael: Mi-hevrah meguyeset le-hevrah ezrahit? (Israel: From mobilized to civil society?)
,
Edited by:
Peled
,
Yoav
and
Ophir
,
Adi
.
206
–
43
.
Jerusalem
:
Van Leer Jerusalem Institute and Hakibbutz Hameuchad
.
(Citizenship and motherhood: The status of women in Israel)
Herzog
,
Hanna
.
2008
.
“
Likrat shihrur ha-ishah: Reshito shel ha-gal ha-sheni shel ha-feminizm be-Yisrael, 1977–1968
”
. In
Ha-asor ha-shlishi la-hevrah ha-yisre'elit (The third decade of Israeli society)
,
Edited by:
Tzamaret
,
Zvi
and
Yablonka
,
Hannah
.
419
–
36
.
Jerusalem
:
Idan and Yad Ben-Zvi
.
(Towards women's liberation: The beginning of the second wave of feminism in Israel, 1968–1977)
Herzog
,
Hanna
.
2008
.
“
Likrat shihrur ha-ishah: Reshito shel ha-gal ha-sheni shel ha-feminizm be-Yisrael, 1977–1968
”
. In
Ha-asor ha-shlishi la-hevrah ha-yisre'elit (The third decade of Israeli society)
,
Edited by:
Tzamaret
,
Zvi
and
Yablonka
,
Hannah
.
419
–
36
.
Jerusalem
:
Idan and Yad Ben-Zvi
.
(Towards women's liberation: The beginning of the second wave of feminism in Israel, 1968–1977)
Sasson-Levy
,
Orna
.
2006
.
Zehuyot be-madim: Gavriyut ve-nashiyut ba-tzava ha-yisre'eli
,
Jerusalem
:
The Hebrew University Magnes Press
.
(Identities in uniform: Masculinities and femininities in the Israeli military)
Helman
,
Sarah
.
2006
.
“
Tzva'iyut u-militarizm
”
. In
I/shivyon (In/Equality)
,
Edited by:
Ram
,
Uri
and
Berkovitch
,
Nitza
.
348
–
54
.
Beer-Sheva
:
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press
.
(The army and militarism)
Herzog
,
Hanna
.
1999
.
“
Nashim ba-politikah u-folitikah shel nashim
”
. In
Min, migdar, politikah (Sex, gender, politics)
,
Edited by:
Izraeli
,
Dafna
.
307
–
55
.
Tel Aviv
:
Ramot and Hakibbutz Hameuchad
.
et al.,
Jerabi
,
Iris
.
1996
.
Ha-mehir ha-kaful: Ma'amad ha-ishah ba-hevrah ha-yisre'elit ve-sherut ha-nashim be-tzahal
,
Tel Aviv
:
Tel Aviv University Press
.
(The double cost: Women's status in Israeli society and women's participation in the army)
Buber Agassi
,
Judith
.
1982
.
“
Matzavan shel nashim be-Yisrael
”
. In
Nashim be-milkud: Al matzav ha-ishah ha-yisre'elit (The double bind: Women in Israel)
,
Edited by:
Izraeli
,
Dafna N.
210
–
30
.
Tel Aviv
:
Hakibbutz Hameuchad
.
et al.,
Segev
,
Tom
.
2007
.
1967: Israel, the War, and the Year that Transformed the Middle East. Trans. Jessica Cohen
,
New York
:
Metropolitan Books
.
Bar Zohar
,
Michael
.
1968
.
Ha-hodesh ha-arokh beyoter
,
Tel Aviv
:
Lewin Epstein
.
(The longest month)
Bernstein
,
Deborah S.
2001
.
“
Heker nashim ba-historiografiyah ha-yisre'elit: Nekudot motza, kivunim hadashim ve-tovanot sheba-derekh
”
. In
Ha-ivriyot ha-hadashot: Nashim ba-yishuv uva-tziyonut bi-re'i ha-migdar (The new Jewish women: Jewish women in Palestine and in Zionism from the point of view of gender)
,
Edited by:
Shilo
,
Margalit
,
Kark
,
Ruth
and
Hazan-Rokem
,
Galit
.
7
–
25
.
Jerusalem
:
Yad Ben-Zvi
.
(The study of women in Israeli historiography: Starting points, new directions and emerging insights)
Gallagher
,
Margaret
.
2005
.
Global Media Monitoring Project: Women's Participation in the News
,
Ontario
:
World Association for Christian Communication
.
Lemish
,
Dafna
.
2006
.
Osim ve-osot hadashot be-Yisrael
,
Tel Aviv
:
World Association for Christian Communication
.
(Making news in Israel)
Lemish
,
Dafna
.
2005
.
The Media Gendering of War and Conflict
.
Feminist Media Studies
,
5
(
3
)
:
275
–
78
.
Ariel
,
Mira
.
1988
.
Female and Male Stereotypes in Israeli Literature and Media: Evidence from Introductory Patterns
.
Language and Communication
,
8
(
1
)
:
43
–
68
.
Shachar
,
Orly
.
2005
.
“
The Israeli Womb: Images of Gendered Nationalism in the Israeli Press
”
. In
Women and the Media
,
Edited by:
Carilli
,
Theresa
and
Campbell
,
Jane
.
19
–
34
.
Lanham, MD
:
University Press of America
.
Lemish
,
Dafna
and
Barzel
,
Inbal
.
2000
.
Four Mothers’: The Womb in the Public Sphere
.
European Journal of Communication
,
15
(
2
)
:
147
–
69
.
Herzog
,
Hanna
.
2000
.
“
Yeda, koah u-folitikah feministit
”
. In
Hevrah be-mar'ah:. Le-zikhro shel Yonatan Shapira (Reflection of society: In memory of Yonathan Shapira)
,
Edited by:
Herzog
,
Hannah
.
269
–
93
.
Tel Aviv
:
Ramot
.
(Knowledge, power and feminist politics)
Zanger
,
Anat
.
2003
.
Hole in the Moon or Zionism and the Binding (Ha-Ak'eda) Myth in Israeli Cinema
.
Shofar
,
22
(
1
)
:
95
–
109
.
Shapira
,
Anita
.
2003
.
Golda: nashiyut ve-feminizm
.
Israel
,
:
57
–
68
.
(Golda: Femininity and feminism)
Teveth
,
Shabtai
.
1971
.
Moshe Dayan
,
Tel Aviv
:
Davar
.
Teveth
,
Shabtai
.
1971
.
Moshe Dayan
,
Tel Aviv
:
Davar
.
Chazan
,
Meir
.
2006
.
Me'oravuto shel iton Ha'aretz ba-ma'arekhet ha-politit bi-tkufat ha-hamtanah
.
Israel
,
:
116
–
75
.
(Ha'aretz during the waiting period)
Tidhar
,
E. Chava
and
Lemish
,
Dafna
.
1993
.
“
Women in the Intifada: A Television News Perspective
”
. In
Framing the Intifada: People and Media
,
Edited by:
Cohen
,
Akiba. A.
and
Wolfsfeld
,
Gadi
.
142
–
59
.
Norwood, NJ
:
Ablex
.
Naveh
,
Hannah
.
2001
.
“
Ha-havayah ha-yisre'elit ve-havayatah shel ha-yisre'elit – girsat beit ha-kvarot ha-tzva'i, o: Eifoh Shulah Melet?
”
. In
Ha-tishma koli? Yetzugim shel nashim ba-tarbut ha-yisre'elit (Will you listen to my voice? Representations of women in Israeli culture)
,
Edited by:
Atzmon
,
Yael
.
305
–
25
.
Jerusalem
:
Hakibbutz Hameuchad
.
(The Israeli experience and the Israeli woman's experience – the military cemetery version or: Where is Shulah Melet?)
Limor
,
Yehiel
and
Mann
,
Rafi
.
1997
.
Itona'ut. Isuf meida, ktivah ve-arikhah
,
Tel Aviv
:
The Open University
.
(Journalism: Reporting, writing and editing)
Barzilai
,
Gad
.
1996
.
“
Medinah, hevrah u-vitahon le'umi: Tikshoret hamonim u-milhamot
”
. In
Yisrael likrat shnat 2000: Hevrah, politikah ve-tarbut (Israel toward the year 2000: Society, politics and culture)
,
Edited by:
Lissak
,
Moshe
and
Knei-paz
,
Baruch
.
176
–
95
.
Jerusalem
:
Magnes
.
(State, society, and national security: Mass media and wars)