Are they ready? An investigation of university students’ difficulties in peer assessment from dual perspectives

ABSTRACT

Few studies have explored the difficulties that undergraduates encounter in peer assessment from the dual perspectives of feedback givers and receivers and framed them in terms of specific needs for student feedback literacy development. To address this research gap, this study explored the obstacles that Hong Kong university students experienced during peer assessment in a General Education course based on 51 retrospective journal entries and 21 individual post-journal interviews. The findings reveal that the participants appeared to face more cognitive difficulties when giving feedback to peers and more socio-affective difficulties when receiving peer feedback, which indicates their specific needs for feedback capacities and dispositions. To prepare students cognitively for peer assessment, teachers must build up students’ evaluative judgment and self-regulation capacities. To prepare them socio-affectively for peer assessment, teachers should help students to realise the benefits of giving feedback and their active roles and enhance their resilience and volition.

KEYWORDS:

• Dual perspectives
• obstacles
• peer assessment
• student feedback literacy

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Additional information

Funding

This study was supported by Seed Funding Grant (RG43/2020-2021R) and Research Cluster Fund (No.: RG76/2020-2021R) in the Education University of Hong Kong.