Hiding behind the camera: social learning within the Cooperative Learning Model to engage girls in physical education

Abstract

Research suggests that girls are disengaged in physical education due to the ‘traditional’ way that it is taught, i.e. teacher-centred approaches with a primary focus on motor performance. In contrast, Cooperative Learning, a student-centred pedagogy focusing on learning in multiple domains, has had success in engaging girls in physical education. Furthermore, when cooperative group work has been combined with technology, student engagement with learning is heightened. This article discusses the use of Cooperative Learning and video cameras to bring about a positive change to the learning environment for girls who were identified as being disengaged in physical education. Two classes of adolescent girls were taught an eight-lesson unit of Basketball using Cooperative Learning. Students worked in learning teams, participating in different roles, such as a coach or a camerawoman, to help each other learn and to film video clips of their learning. Data collection included a teacher's reflective journal, post-lesson teacher analysis tool, student interviews and the analysis of learning teams' movies. Inductive analysis and constant comparison was used for data analyses. Findings suggest that the role of the coach and the camerawoman was pivotal to girls' engagement. Some girls only ‘fully’ participated in lessons when learning was within the social and cognitive domains, since they could ‘hide behind the camera’ and were not required to participate physically. We controversially suggest that, in order to engage girls in physical education, we may have to temporarily remove the physical domain of learning (at least for some girls) in order to positively affect their longer term engagement in the subject.

Keywords:

• Information and communication technology
• Engagement
• Participation
• Girls

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the reviewers for their helpful comments on the article and the physical education department at the school for their support with this study. Particularly we would like to thank Professor Jan Wright for her constructive comments and recommendations on the first draft of this article. The authors are responsible for any shortcomings that remain.

Notes

1. An optional part of the national curriculum whereby students are assessed on both theoretical knowledge and physical performance or leadership skills.