4,219
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Historiographical Essay

British Union of Fascists

Pages 1-19 | Published online: 12 May 2015
 

Abstract

The historiography of the rise and fall of Britain's largest, and only significant, fascist party, the British Union of Fascists (BUF), has been lively since its inception. As several leading historians in the field (notably Stanley Payne and Richard Thurlow) remarked, the number of academic works on the topic greatly surpasses its importance. The interest in the movement's history, however, refuses to die down and the number of works detailing various aspects of BUF operations continues to multiply. This study does not aspire to give an exhausting description of all published works on the BUF. Instead, it aims to chart the basic tendencies in historiography pertaining to the BUF and to inform the reader of fundamental, as well as the most recent scholarly work on the topic.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes

 [1] British Union of Fascists changed its name to the British Union of Fascists and National Socialists in 1936 and in 1937 to British Union. I am referring to the movement as BUF in this article in order to avoid confusion.

 [2]CitationPayne, A History of Fascism, 305.

 [3] The Rex party won 21 of 202 deputies (11.4 per cent of the votes) and 12 senators in the 1936 elections. CitationBonney, Confronting the Nazi, 175–176.

 [4] In the 1937 parliamentary elections, the Iron guard came in third, with 15.5 per cent of the votes. CitationPayne, A History of Fascism, 277–289.

 [5]CitationThurlow, Fascism in Modern Britain, 1.

 [6]CitationRees, Fascism in Britain.

 [7] For example CitationRees, ‘Changing Interpretations’, 187–204.

 [8]CitationMcCloud. ‘Oswald Mosley’, 687–697.

 [9]CitationStrachey, The Menace of Fascism.

[10]CitationDutt, Fascism and Social Revolution.

[11]CitationConze and Wilkinson, Why Fascism?.

[12]CitationRudlin, The Growth of Fascism.

[13]CitationGarratt, The Shadow of the Swastika.

[14]CitationBarnes, Half a Life Left.

[15]CitationDrennan, B.U.F.: Oswald Mosley.

[16]CitationChesterton, Oswald Mosley, Portrait.

[17]CitationBaker, Ideology of Obsession, 130.

[18]CitationSkidelsky, Oswald Mosley.

[19]CitationLunn, ‘British Fascism Revisited’, 166–179.

[20]CitationGriffin, The Nature of Fascism.

[21] Ibid., 26.

[22]CitationGriffin, ‘Studying Fascism’, 1–17.

[23]CitationCross, The Fascists in Britain.

[24]CitationBenewick, Political Violence. Revised edition with new introduction was published in 1972. CitationBenewick, The Fascist Movement.

[25]CitationMandle, ‘The Leadership’, 360–383; and CitationMandle, Anti-Semitism.

[26]CitationMosley, My Life.

[27]CitationSkidelsky, Oswald Mosley, 13.

[28] Skidelsky is also the author of John Maynard Keynes biography. See CitationSkidelsky, Keynes: The Return.

[29]CitationTrythall, “Boney” Fuller.

[30]CitationNugent, ‘The Ideas’, 130–162.

[31] Ibid., 158–159; similarly, CitationLewis, Illusions of Grandeur, 262, and other works.

[32]CitationCullen, ‘The Development’, 115–136; CitationThurlow, Fascism in Britain, 114–121; CitationLinehan, British Fascism, 92–93, and other works.

[33]CitationKibblewhite and Rigby, Fascism in Aberdeen.

[34]CitationBrewer, Mosley's Men; CitationBrewer, ‘The British Union of Fascists’, 109–122; CitationFrancis, Miners Against Fascism; and CitationHusbands, ‘East End and Racism’, 3–26.

[35]CitationDurham, ‘Women and the British Union’, 2–18. R.M. Douglas is author of the book on British voluntary women police during the Second World War. In his book, he devotes some attention to Mary Allen, one of the most prominent female members of the BUF. See CitationDouglas, Feminist Freikorps.

[36]CitationLunn and Thurlow, British Fascism: Essays.

[37]CitationGriffiths, Fellow Travellers.

[38]CitationLarsen, Hagtvet and Myklebust, Who Were the Fascists?.

[39]CitationMosley, Rules of the Game; and CitationMosley, Beyond the Pale.

[40]CitationThurlow, Fascism in Modern Britain, 7.

[41] Ibid.

[42]CitationThurlow, ‘Blaming the Blackshirts’, 112–129; CitationThurlow, ‘State Management’, 29–52; CitationThurlow, ‘The Evolution’, 477–498; CitationThurlow, ‘The Guardian’, 241–254; CitationThurlow, ‘The Historiography and Source’, 141–171; CitationThurlow, ‘The Return of Jeremiah’, 100–113, and others.

[43]CitationThurlow, Fascism in Modern Britain, 61.

[44]CitationLewis, Illusions of Grandeur.

[45] In detail see CitationKallis, The Fascism Reader, 103.

[46]CitationMcIntyre, ‘The Aging Narcissistic Leader’, 483–499.

[47]CitationBrewer, ‘Looking Back at Fascism’, 742–760; CitationRawnsley, ‘The Membership’, 150–166; and CitationWebber, ‘Patterns of Membership’, 575–606.

[48]CitationCullen, ‘The Development’, 115–136. Important contribution to the study of the BUF's ideology is also Stuart Rawnsley's unpublished dissertation thesis. CitationRawnsley, ‘Fascism and Fascists’. Also see CitationCullen, ‘Leaders and Martyrs’, 408–430; and CitationSusser, ‘Fascism, Literary Modernism’, 463–486.

[49]CitationHamm, Action Replay; CitationCharnley, Blackshirts and Roses; CitationMosley, A Life of Contrasts; and CitationMosley, Loved Ones. Noteworthy is also Leonard Wise's collection of 12 stories of former Blackshirts. CitationWise, Mosley's Blackshirts. Also see CitationMayall, ‘Rescued from the Shadows’, 19–39.

[50]CitationMoloney, Westminster, Whitehall.

[51]CitationCohen, ‘The Police’, 416–434.

[52]CitationCole, Lord Haw-Haw; and CitationSelwyn, Hitler's Englishman.

[53] Maxwell Knight was the role model for the ‘M’ character in the James Bond books. CitationMasters, The Man Who Was M.

[54] In detail see CitationGoldman, ‘Defence Regulation’, 120–136.

[55] , ‘Henry Williamson’, 123–139, and 289–305; CitationFarson, An Appreciation of Henry Williamson; and CitationSewell, Henry Williamson.

[56]CitationWest, Truth Betrayed.

[57]CitationKushner and Lunn, Traditions of Intolerance; and CitationKushner and Lunn, The Politics of Marginality.

[58]CitationCullen, ‘Four Women for Mosley’, 49–59; CitationDurham, Women and Fascism; CitationDurham, ‘Gender and the British’, 513–529; CitationDurham, ‘Women and the British Union’, 101–110; CitationGottlieb, ‘Women and Fascism’, 31–50; CitationKean, ‘Some Problems of Constructing’, 475–493; and CitationKillin, ‘Women and British Fascism’, 21–23.

[59] For example CitationCook, ‘A Fascist Memory’, 147–162; CitationDouglas, ‘The Swastika and the Shamrock’, 57–75; CitationHaskell, ‘Botticelli, Fascism’, 462–472; CitationCollins, ‘Return to Manhood’, 145–162; CitationCullen, ‘Political Violence’, 245–267; CitationPugh, ‘The British Union’, 529–542; and CitationLinehan, ‘Fascist Perceptions’, 23–30.

[60]CitationHolmes, ‘British Justice at Work’, 150–163; and CitationSimpson, In the Highest Degree.

[61]CitationGrundy, Memoir of a Fascist Childhood; and CitationCharnley, Blackshirts and Roses.

[62]CitationCoupland, ‘The Blackshirted Utopians’, 255–272.

[63]CitationLinehan, ‘East London for Mosley’.

[64]CitationBarrett, ‘Liberal Tolerance’; CitationBarrett, ‘The Threat of the British’, 56–73; CitationCullen, ‘Another Nationalism’, 101–114; CitationCullen, ‘The British Union of Fascists’, 116–123; CitationLinehan, ‘The British Union of Fascists in Hackney’; CitationLoughlin, ‘Northern Island’, 537–552; CitationMaitles, ‘Fascism in the 1930s’, 7–22; CitationMilligan, ‘The British Union’, 1–17; CitationRenton, Red Shirts and Black; and CitationTurner, Fascism and Anti-Fascism.

[65]CitationBaker, Ideology of Obsession.

[66]CitationBeckett, Rebel Who Lost.

[67]CitationDalley, Diana Mosley.

[68]CitationWilliamson, Henry Williamson; and CitationLamplaugh, A Shadowed Man.

[69]CitationCronin, The Failure.

[70]CitationBooker, Blackshirts-on-Sea.

[71]CitationMillican, Mosley's Men in Black.

[72] Marxist historians still deny the existence of the coherent fascist ideology and its revolutionary nature. In accordance with this trend, Dave Renton in 2000 wrote the article in which he claimed that to define fascism primarily as an ideology is the wrong way to understand it. See CitationRenton, ‘UK: Was Fascism an Ideology?’, 72–84. Also see CitationRenton, ‘British Fascism Reconsidered’, 65–78; and CitationRenton, Fascism, Anti-Fascism and Britain.

[73]CitationLinehan, British Fascism.

[74] For example CitationLinehan, ‘A Dangerous Piece of Celluloid?’, 41–54; CitationLinehan, ‘The British Union of Fascists as a Totalitarian’, 397–418; CitationLinehan, ‘Fascist Perceptions’, 23–30; CitationLinehan, ‘On the Side of Christ’, 75–89; CitationLinehan, ‘“On the Side of Christ”: Fascist Clerics’, 287–301; CitationLinehan, ‘The British Union of Fascists in Hackney’, and others.

[75]CitationLinehan, ‘Space Matters’, 1–21.

[76]CitationLinehan and Gottlieb, The Culture of Fascism.

[77]CitationSpurr, ‘Living the Blackshirt Life’, 305–322.

[78]CitationSpurr, ‘“Playing for Fascism”’, 359–376.

[79]CitationRau, ‘The Fascist Body’, 5–35; CitationGottlieb, ‘Body Fascism in Britain’, 111–136; CitationZweiniger-Bargielowska, ‘Building a British Superman’, 596–610; and CitationStone, ‘Race in British Eugenics’, 397–425.

[80]CitationLawrence, ‘Fascist Violence’, 238–267; and CitationTilles, ‘Bullies or Victims?’, 327–346.

[81]CitationGriffiths, ‘A Note on Mosley’, 675–688; and CitationGottlieb, ‘“Motherly Hate”’, 294–320.

[82]CitationCullen, ‘The Fasces and the Saltire’, 306–331; CitationCoupland, ‘The Blackshirts in Northampton’, 71–82; and CitationMaitles, ‘Blackshirts across the Border’, 92–100.

[83] In particular, CitationKushner and Valman, Remembering Cable Street; CitationMoore-Colyer, ‘Towards “Mother Earth”’, 353–371; CitationNewsinger, ‘Blackshirts, Blueshirts’, 825–844; CitationStone, ‘The English Mistery’, 336–358; and CitationFisher and Fisher, ‘Tomorrow We Live’, 71–82.

[84]CitationGottlieb, Feminine Fascism; and CitationGottlieb, ‘Women and British Fascism Revisited’, 108–123.

[85]CitationGottlieb, ‘A Mosleyite Life Stranger’, 70–91; CitationGottlieb, ‘Britain's New Fascist Men’, 83–99; CitationGottlieb, ‘Female Fanatics’, 29–42; CitationGottlieb, ‘Suffragette Experiences’; CitationGottlieb, ‘The Gender of Tolerance’, 129–156; CitationGottlieb, ‘The Marketing of Megalomania’, 35–55; CitationGottlieb, ‘Women and British Fascism Revisited’, 108–123; CitationGottlieb, ‘Women and Fascism’, 31–50; CitationGottlieb, ‘Women Blackshirts’, 26–29, and others.

[86]CitationLove, ‘“What's the Big Idea?”’, 447–468.

[87]CitationDe Courcy, Diana Mosley.

[88]CitationFarndale, Haw-Haw: The Tragedy; CitationKenny, Germany Calling; and CitationMartland, Lord Haw Haw.

[89]CitationDorril, Blackshirt.

[90]CitationMount, ‘Double-Barrelled Dolts’, 14–17. See also P. Coupland, Book Review: Stephen Dorril, Author's blog [online]. Accessed March 19, 2013. http://drpmc.blogspot.co.uk/2008/08/book-review-stephen-dorrils-blackshirt.html

[91] Possible supplement to Dorrils book is Peter Cook's unpublished dissertation. CitationCook, Towards a Greater Britain: Unfortunately, approximately the last 30 years of Mosley's life is missing from the thesis. It shows, however, the possible future trends in the research on Oswald Mosley and the BUF.

[92]CitationPugh, Hurrah for the Blackshirts!.

[93]CitationWorley, Oswald Mosley; CitationWorley, ‘A Call to Action’, 236–255; CitationWorley, ‘What Was the New Party?’, 39–63; and CitationWorley, ‘Why Fascism?’, 68–83. Apart from Worley's work, Steven Woodbridge made some valuable contributions to this topic as well. See CitationWoodbridge, ‘Fraudulent Fascism’, 493–507.

[94] For example CitationHuggins, ‘Racing, Betting, Anti-Semitism’, 1529–1552. See also the biography of Wilfred Risdon: CitationRisdon, Black Shirt.

[95]CitationMacklin, ‘“Onward Blackshirts!”’, 430–457.

[96]CitationTilles, British Fascist Antisemitism.

[97] One of the most recent studies on BUF is CitationYoung, ‘Fascism for the British Audience’, 93–116.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Jakub Drabik

Jakub Drabik completed his PhD in history at the Charles University in Prague. His research focuses on the history of fascism, particularly British and Czech fascism and comparative fascist studies. His dissertation focused on British Union of fascists propaganda, and was published by the Charles University Press in 2014. Correspondence to: Jakub Drabik, Povazska 24, 040 11, Kosice, Slovakia.

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
USD 53.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
USD 273.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable

Related Research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.