Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Jim Goodman for his insightful comments, tireless support and for encouraging me to take a creative approach to this article. To Grace Karskens for her probing suggestions, continuous inspiration, candour and infectious enthusiasm. To Tom Griffiths for writing such an incredible book and for talking candidly about the profound power of the past. To Matthew Barry, James Keating, Sophie Robinson and Lisa Ford for your ongoing encouragement, generosity and rich insights. And last, but not least, to all the historians who continue to write and inspire, who give themselves to their histories completely, and who bring the magic of the past back to our modern world.
Notes
6. This essay uses Jörn Rüsen’s working definition of ‘historical consciousness’ as
‘historical sense-generation’. This making sense of the past … is ‘a mental procedure by which the past is interpreted for the sake of understanding the present and anticipating the future’. Rather than simply defining levels of attainment in historical literacy or understanding … historical consciousness covers ‘every form’ of thinking about the past, from ‘historical studies’ to the ‘use and function of history in private and public life’.
Jörn Rüsen and Anna Clark in Clark (
Citation2014, 88, 89).
16. See for example, Dening (Citation1997, 419–429, Citation2004), Clendinnen (Citation1998, Citation2002, 157–174, Citation2005), Sachs (Citation2013), and Lanz (Citation2015, 314).
24.
The expression ‘black armband view of history’ has been used to describe a brand of Australian history which its critics argue ‘represents a swing of the pendulum from a position that had been too favourable, too self congratulatory’, to an opposite extreme that is even more unreal and decidedly jaundiced. Not only, it is said, does the black armband view belittle past achievements, it also encourages a ‘guilt industry’ and impedes rational thinking on current problems. From this perspective, the black armband view of history is a strand of ‘political correctness’-the dominant but erroneous view of how we see ourselves and what we see as worthwhile in our culture. For others, the term is inherently political and a misrepresentation of the work of many serious historians. It is an attempt to appropriate an established symbol of genuine grieving, loss and injustice by those who do not accept, or do not want to accept, that past wrongs must be fully recognised before present problems can be resolved. Both sides accuse each other of attempting to distort history and of taking an extreme view.
By contrast, the ‘Three Cheers’ view of history looks at Australia’s past as a series of achievements, and emphasises events from history that Australians should apparently be proud of. Taken from McKenna (
Citation1997).
27. Kohn (Citation1995, 1036–1063), Linethal and Engelhardt (Citation1996). See also a comparative study between Australia’s ‘History Wars’ and those of Japan; Yonetani (Citation2013, 33–50).
45. See also Judith Wright in Griffiths (Citation2016, 102).
55. See for example, the discussion in Macintyre (Citation2004).
65. Ibid. See book index for references to each historian.
67. For a particularly critical study, see Chapter 4 on Geoffrey Blainey. Griffiths (Citation2016, 74–93).
Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Karskens, Grace. 2010. The Colony: A History of Early Sydney. Sydney: Angus & Robertson. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Clark, Anna. 2014. “Exploring Historical Consciousness across Generations.” Historical Encounters 1 (1): 88–102. Evans, Richard. 1997. In Defence of History. London: Granta Books. Evans, Richard. 1997. In Defence of History. London: Granta Books. Evans, Richard. 1997. In Defence of History. London: Granta Books. Becker, Carl. 1955. “What are Historical Facts?” The Western Political Quarterly 8 (3): 327–340. Carr, E. H. 2008. What is History? London: Penguin Books. Schneider, Axel, and Daniel Woolf eds. 2011. The Oxford History of Historical Writing, Volume 5: 1945 to the Present. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Lyons, Martyn, and Penny Russell, eds. 2005. Australian History: Themes and Debates. Sydney: UNSW Press. Weisner-Hanks, Merry E. 2011. Gender in History: Global Perspectives. Chichester, UK: Wiley-Blackwell. Cook, James W. 2008. A Companion to American Cultural History. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.10.1002/9780470691762 Dening, Greg. 1997. “Empowering Imagination.” The Contemporary Pacific 9 (2): 419–429. Dening, Greg. 2004. Beach Crossings: Voyaging across times, Cultures and Self. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Clendinnen, Inga. 1998. Reading the Holocaust. Melbourne: Text Publishing. Clendinnen, Inga. 2002. “Spearing the Governor.” Australian Historical Studies 33 (118): 157–174.10.1080/10314610208596189 Clendinnen, Inga. 2005. Dancing with Strangers: Europeans and Australians at First Contact. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Sachs, Aaron. 2013. Arcadian America: The Death and Life of an Environmental Tradition. Newhaven: Yale University Press. Lanz, Tobias J. 2015. “Book Review: Arcadian America: The Death and Life of an Environmental Tradition.” Environmental History 20 (2): 314–315. Sachs, Aaron. 2010. “Letters to a Tenured Historian: Imagining History as Creative Nonfiction – Or Maybe Even Poetry.” Rethinking History 14 (1): 5–38.10.1080/13642520903515611 Rosenstone, Robert A. 2010. “Buried in a Footnote.” Rethinking History 14 (1): 55–58.10.1080/13642520903515686 Brown, Katie. 2010. “Three Letters to a Junior Colleague.” Rethinking History 14 (1): 65–69.10.1080/13642520903515728 Price, Jenny. 2010. “A Letter from a Lapsed Colleague.” Rethinking History 14 (1): 39–41.10.1080/13642520903515629 Sachs, Aaron. 2010. “Letters to a Tenured Historian: Imagining History as Creative Nonfiction – Or Maybe Even Poetry.” Rethinking History 14 (1): 5–38.10.1080/13642520903515611 Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Windschuttle, Keith. 2000. The Killing of the Past: How Literary Critics and Social Theorists are Murdering Our Past. San Francisco, CA: Encounter Books. Macintyre, Stuart, and Anna Clark. 2004. The History Wars. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Manne, Robert, ed. 2003. Whitewash: On Keith Windschuttle’s Fabrication of Aboriginal History. Melbourne: Black Inc Books. Macintyre, Stuart. 2003. “The History Wars.” The Sydney Papers, Winter/Spring, 77–83. Clark, Anna. 2010. “The History Wars.” In Southern Worlds: South Africa and Australia Compared, edited by John Peter Nieuwenhuysen and David Dunstan, 120–129. Melbourne: Australian Scholarly Publishing. Windschuttle, Keith. 2005. The Fabrication of Aboriginal History, Part 1. Sydney: Macleay Press. Kohn, Richard H. 1995. “History and the Culture Wars: The Case of the Smithsonian Institution’s Enola Gay Exhibition.” The Journal of American History 82 (3): 1036–1063.10.2307/2945111 Linethal, Edward T., and Tom Engelhardt, eds. 1996. History Wars: The Enola Gay and Other Battles for the American Past. New York: Henry Holt and Company. Yonetani, Julia. 2013. “The ‘History Wars’ in Comparative Perspective: Australia and Japan.” Cultural Studies Review 10 (2): 33–50. 10.5130/csr.v10i2.3470 Foster, Meg. 2014. “Online and Plugged in? Public History and Historians in the Digital Age.” Public History Review 21: 1–20.10.5130/phrj.v21i0.4295 Belgrave, Michael. 2013. “Something Borrowed, Something New: History and the Waitangi Tribunal.” In The Public History Reader, edited by Hilda Kean and Paul Martin, 311–322. London: Routledge. Evans, Richard. 2002. Telling Lies about Hitler: The Holocaust, History and the David Irving Trial. London: Verso. Macintyre, Stuart. 2004. “Introduction.” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 1–16. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Foster, Meg. 2014. “Online and Plugged in? Public History and Historians in the Digital Age.” Public History Review 21: 1–20.10.5130/phrj.v21i0.4295 Manne, Robert, ed. 2003. Whitewash: On Keith Windschuttle’s Fabrication of Aboriginal History. Melbourne: Black Inc Books. Evans, Richard. 1997. In Defence of History. London: Granta Books. Russell, Penny. 2004. “Almost Believing: The Ethics of Historical Imagination.” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 106–117. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. White, Hayden. 1980. “The Value of Narrativity in the Representation of Reality.” Critical Inquiry 7 (1): 5–27.10.1086/448086 Williams, Raymond. 1983. Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society. New York: Oxford University Press. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Reynolds, Henry. 2000. Black Pioneers. Ringwood: Penguin. Reynolds, Henry. 1989. Dispossession: Black Australians and White Invaders. Sydney: Allen & Unwin. Reynolds, Henry. 2006. The Other Side of the Frontier: Aboriginal Resistance to the European Invasion of Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press. Attwood, Bain, and Tom Griffiths, eds. 2009. Frontier, Race, Nation: Henry Reynolds and Australian History. Melbourne: Australian Scholarly Publishing. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Russell, Penny. 2004. “Almost Believing: The Ethics of Historical Imagination.” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 106–117. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Karskens, Grace. 2010. The Colony: A History of Early Sydney. Sydney: Angus & Robertson. Franken, Robert E. 1994. Human Motivation. Pacific Grove, CA: Cole Publishing. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Clendinnen, Inga. 1998. Reading the Holocaust. Melbourne: Text Publishing. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Clendinnen, Inga. 1998. Reading the Holocaust. Melbourne: Text Publishing. Seymour, Mark. 2012. “Emotional Arenas: From Provincial Circus to National Courtroom in Late Nineteenth-century Italy.” Rethinking History 16 (2): 177–197.10.1080/13642529.2012.681190 Gammerl, Benno. 2012. “Emotional Styles – Concepts and Challenges.” Rethinking History 16 (2): 161–175.10.1080/13642529.2012.681189 Pinto, Sarah. 2010. “Emotional Histories and Historical Emotions.” Rethinking History 14 (2): 189–207. Atkinson, Alan. 2004. “Do Good Historians Have Feelings?” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 17–27. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Seymour, Mark. 2012. “Emotional Arenas: From Provincial Circus to National Courtroom in Late Nineteenth-century Italy.” Rethinking History 16 (2): 177–197.10.1080/13642529.2012.681190 Macintyre, Stuart. 2004. “Introduction.” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 1–16. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Atkinson, Alan. 2004. “Do Good Historians Have Feelings?” In The Historian’s Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, edited by Stuart Macintyre, 17–27. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books. Ashton, Paul, and Paula Hamilton. 2010. History at the Crossroads. Sydney: Halstead Press. Griffiths, Tom. 2016. The Art of Time Travel: Historians and Their Craft. Melbourne: Black Inc., Books.