Utilising urban context recognition and machine learning to improve the generalisation of buildings

Abstract

The introduction of automated generalisation procedures in map production systems requires that generalisation systems are capable of processing large amounts of map data in acceptable time and that cartographic quality is similar to traditional map products. With respect to these requirements, we examine two complementary approaches that should improve generalisation systems currently in use by national topographic mapping agencies. Our focus is particularly on self‐evaluating systems, taking as an example those systems that build on the multi‐agent paradigm. The first approach aims to improve the cartographic quality by utilising cartographic expert knowledge relating to spatial context. More specifically, we introduce expert rules for the selection of generalisation operations based on a classification of buildings into five urban structure types, including inner city, urban, suburban, rural, and industrial and commercial areas. The second approach aims to utilise machine learning techniques to extract heuristics that allow us to reduce the search space and hence the time in which a good cartographical solution is reached. Both approaches are tested individually and in combination for the generalisation of buildings from map scale 1:5000 to the target map scale of 1:25 000. Our experiments show improvements in terms of efficiency and effectiveness. We provide evidence that both approaches complement each other and that a combination of expert and machine learnt rules give better results than the individual approaches. Both approaches are sufficiently general to be applicable to other forms of self‐evaluating, constraint‐based systems than multi‐agent systems, and to other feature classes than buildings. Problems have been identified resulting from difficulties to formalise cartographic quality by means of constraints for the control of the generalisation process.

Keywords:

• Map generalisation
• building generalisation
• data enrichment
• machine learning
• expert knowledge
• self‐evaluating systems
• multi‐agent systems

Acknowledgements

The research reported in this paper was partially funded by the Swiss NSF through grant no. 20‐101798, project DEGEN. We are grateful to Julien Gaffuri for helping us to get started with Clarity and Cécile Duchêne for discussions during the experiments. We would specifically like to acknowledge the fruitful exchange of ideas with the IGN Nouvelle Carte de Base team. The authors are also grateful for the comments from anonymous reviewers.