Living with risk in the age of ‘intensive motherhood’: Maternal identity and infant feeding

Abstract

Socio-cultural studies have suggested that, even in societies where it is a commonplace practice, infant feeding with formula milk can compromise women's identity as ‘good mothers.’ This proposition is explored in this paper. We first provide a brief review of literature that has considered the broad socio-cultural context for infant feeding, that of ‘intensive motherhood.’ Attention is drawn to the idea that this context is one in which feeding babies formula milk is constructed as risky, for physical health but also for the mother–child relationship. Drawing on data from a study of mothers living in the UK, the paper then explores how mothers actually experience infant feeding with formula milk and how they live with a context that deems their actions risky. Maternal experience is found to include variously moral collapse, feelings of confidence, expressions of defiance and defensiveness, and opting to go it alone in response to ‘information overload.’ Despite these variations in how mothers live with risk, the conclusion is drawn that the current cultural context does appear to be one overall in which mothers who formula feed often have to struggle hard to maintain a positive sense of themselves as mothers.

Keywords:

• risk
• formula milk
• bonding
• identity
• intensive motherhood

Notes

1.For reasons of space it is not possible to provide more detail about methodology here. Further discussion appears in Lee 2007a, 2007b. The full report of the research, with complete account of methodology, can be accessed at: http://www.kent.ac.uk/sspssr/staff/academic/lee/infant-formula-full.pdf