Are there differences in performance validity test scores between African American and White American neuropsychology clinic patients?

ABSTRACT

Objective

The purpose of the present study was to compare performance on a wide range of PVTs in a neuropsychology clinic sample of African Americans and White Americans to determine if there are differences in mean scores or cut-off failure rates between the two groups, and to identify factors that may account for false positive PVT results in African American patients.

Method

African American and White American non-compensation-seeking neuropsychology clinic patients were compared on a wide range of standalone and embedded PVTs: Dot Counting Test, b Test, Warrington Recognition Memory Test, Rey 15-item plus recognition, Rey Word Recognition Test, Digit Span (ACSS, RDS, 3-digit time, 4-digit time), WAIS-III Picture Completion (Most discrepant index), WAIS-III Digit Symbol/Coding (recognition equation), Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test, Rey Complex figure, WMS-III Logical Memory, Comalli Stroop Test, Trails A, and Wisconsin Card Sorting Test.

Results

When groups were equated for age and education, African Americans obtained mean performances significantly worse than White Americans on only four of 25 PVT scores across the 14 different measures (Stroop Word Reading and Color Naming, Trails A, Digit Span 3-digit time); however, FSIQ was also significantly higher in White American patients. When subjects with borderline IQ (FSIQ = 70 to 79) were excluded (resulting in 74 White Americans and 25 African Americans), groups no longer differed in IQ and only continued to differ on a single PVT cutoff (Trails A). Further, specificity rates in African Americans were comparable to those of White Americans with the exception of the b Test, the Dot Counting Test, and Stroop B.

Conclusions

PVT performance generally does not differ as a function of Black versus White race once the impact of intellectual level is controlled, and most PVT cutoffs appear appropriate for use in African Americans of low average IQ or higher.

KEYWORDS:

• performance validity tests
• PVTs
• African Americans

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Disclaimer

The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent the views of the Veterans Administration Tennessee Valley Healthcare System

Additional information

Funding

The author(s) reported that there is no funding associated with the work featured in this article.