The Case for Testing Memory With Both Stories and Word Lists Prior to DBS Surgery for Parkinson's Disease

Abstract

Patients seeking deep brain stimulation (DBS) surgery for Parkinson's disease (PD) typically undergo neuropsychological assessment to determine candidacy for surgery, with poor memory performance interpreted as a contraindication. Patients with PD may exhibit worse memory for word lists than for stories due to the lack of inherent organization in a list of unrelated words. Unfortunately, word list and story tasks are typically developed from different normative datasets, and the existence of a memory performance discrepancy in PD has been challenged. We compared recall of stories and word lists in 35 non-demented PD candidates for DBS. We administered commonly used neuropsychological measures of word list and story memory (Hopkins Verbal Learning Test, Logical Memory), along with a second word list task that was co-normed with the story task. Age-corrected scores were higher for the story task than for both word list tasks. Compared to story recall, word list recall correlated more consistently with motor severity and composite measures of processing speed, working memory, and executive functioning. These results support the classic view of fronto-subcortical contributions to memory in PD and suggest that executive deficits may influence word list recall more than story recall. We recommend a multi-componential memory battery in the neuropsychological assessment of DBS candidates to characterize both mesial temporal and frontal-executive memory processes. One should not rely solely on a word list task because patients exhibiting poor memory for word lists may perform better with stories and therefore deserve an interdisciplinary discussion for DBS surgery.

Keywords:

• Parkinson's disease
• Verbal memory
• Deep brain stimulation

Acknowledgments/Financial Disclosure/Conflict Of Interest

The present study was made possible by support from the University of Florida (UF) National Parkinson Foundation Center of Excellence, the UF Foundation, and the National Institutes of Health (NINDS: NS50633, NS044997, K23NS060660; NIA: T32-AG020499). No authors have conflicts of interest related to the research reported in this manuscript.