Economic Criteria for Evaluating Demand Side Management Measures in the Context of Electricity Sector Regulation

Abstract

In the present regulations of the Portuguese electricity sector distribution companies, acting as last resort suppliers, they can promote energy efficiency measures also designated in this context by Demand Side Management (DSM) measures. In order to promote the implementation of these measures, the Tariff Code establishes that the measures, costs and half of the respective net benefits will be reflected in the supply tariffs. In this paper different criteria for valuing DSM measures are analysed, including valuing avoided costs from the electricity sector (namely by considering data from marginal costs) and valuing environmental benefits. The economic criteria discussed are applied to five DSM measures. For each criterion and for each DSM measure several aspects are evaluated, namely: 1) the respective costs and benefits, distinguishing between bill reduction benefits and environmental benefits; 2) the benefit/cost ratio; 3) the amount of allowed revenues to be included in the supply tariffs and the impact this causes to consumers; and 4) the cost per ton of avoided CO₂ emission as well as the cost per kWh of saved energy. A sensitivity analysis on the merit order of the different measures is also performed. The results show that the different criteria considered have a significant impact on the costs that electricity consumers pay through tariffs and a relatively minor impact on the merit order of the different measures. Therefore, changing the hypotheses behind the criteria discussed would not have a major impact on project selection, but could be relevant for the design of incentives for each measure. It is shown that despite the attribution of high environmental premiums for the implementation of DSM measures, the costs for ton of CO₂ avoided are much lower than those that would result from the implementation of equivalent supply side measures.

Keywords:

• Demand side management
• energy efficiency
• environmental premium
• economic regulation

Acknowledgement

The authors gratefully acknowledge all other members of ERSE for their contribution on results presented.

Notes

1. ERSE, ‘Revisão dos Regulamentos do Sector Eléctrico – Documento de Discussão’, ERSE, Lisboa, 2001. (Portuguese only). (Online). Available: www.erse.pt

2. ERSE, “Regulamento Tarifário”, ERSE, Lisboa, 2001. (Portuguese only). (Online). Available: www.erse.pt

3. ADENE, Programa SAVE No. 4.1031/Z/98‐267, ‘Gestão da Procura. Campanha de medições por utilização em 400 unidades de alojamento na União Europeia. Avaliação dos potenciais de economia de electricidade’, ADENE, 2002. (Portuguese only).

4. A. Traça de Almeida, A. Cristina Rosa e F. Grilo Gonçalves, ‘Manual de Programas de DSM’, Universidade de Coimbra, 2001. (Portuguese only).

5. EDP Distribuição Energia S.A. ‘Plano de Gestão da Procura’, EDP Distribuição Energia S.A., Outubro de 2002. (Portuguese only).

6. ERSE, ‘Apreciação do Plano de Gestão da Procura da EDP Distribuição’, ERSE, Lisboa, 2003. (Portuguese only).

7. The Carbon Trust, ‘Best Practice Programme’, The Carbon Trust, United Kingdom, 2005.

8. Copper Development Association ‘Good Practice Case Study 162’, Copper Development Association, United Kingdom, 1992.

9. A. Trindade, P. Roberto e V. Barroso, ‘A utilização racional de energia na iluminação pública em três municípios’, Revista Energia, N°4 ano XV (II Série), Lisboa (1999). (Portuguese only).

10. Presidência do Conselho de Ministros, ‘Plano Nacional para as Alterações Climáticas’, Resolução do Conselho de Ministros n.° 119/2004, Diário da República (I Série ‐ B). (Portuguese Only).

11. M. Armstrong, S. Cowan e J. Vickers, ‘Regulatory Reform – Economic Analysis and British Experience’, London, MIT Press, 1994.

12. F. Kreith e R. West, ‘CRC Handbook of Energy Efficiency’, CRC Press, E.U.A., 1997.

13. ERSE, ‘Revisão da Estrutura Tarifária: 1^a Fase’, ERSE, Lisboa, 2000. (Portuguese only).

14. ERSE, ‘Caracterização do Sector Eléctrico’ – Portugal Continental 2001 ERSE, Lisboa, 2002. (Portuguese only).

15. ERSE, ‘Parâmetros e Tarifas e Preços para a Energia Eléctrica e Outros Serviços em 2005’, ERSE, Lisboa, 2004. (Portuguese only). (Online). Available: www.erse.pt.