Pluralism in EIA practice: A Q-method analysis of the economic growth-environment nexus

ABSTRACT

The economic growth-environment nexus explores the relationship between economic growth, as understood in the neoclassical free market or neoliberalism economic theory context, and its implications for the environment. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is considered one of the most successful environmental policy instruments to deal with the consideration of environmental implications of development decisions. Because the economic growth-environment nexus is central to discourses in EIA it is helpful to gain an improved understanding of different perspectives manifesting and influencing EIA practice. This paper aims to identify pluralism in perspectives on the economic growth-environment nexus in EIA practice. This is achieved by applying the Q-method to EIA practice in South Africa and involve the sorting of 36 statements by 16 respondents. The results show pluralism and distinct patterning with four key perspectives emerging namely: the deontological perspective, neoliberal progression, EIA polarisation and new conservationist perspective. We hope this research contributes towards a growing understanding of how different perspectives on the economic growth-environment nexus might influence EIA practice and decision making.

KEYWORDS:

• Pluralism
• economic growth-environment nexus
• environmental impact assessment
• Q-method
• sustainable development

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Ethics approval

Based on the review by the Faculty of Natural and Agricultural Sciences Ethics Committee (FNASREC), the Committee cleared the study as no ethical risk. This implies that the FNASREC grants permission that, provided the general conditions specified are met, the study may be initiated, using the ethics number below. Ethics number: N W U - 0 1 4 2 1 - 2 0 - A 9.