Abstract
Finzsch suggests four hypotheses, which are intrinsically connected and which form the basis for a theory labelled “Settler Imperialism”. First, he proposes a new definition of genocide, which is grounded in a different interpretation of the concept of the event. Secondly, he argues in favour of a sliding continuum of genocide that ranges from everyday practices to organized mass murder. Thirdly he indicates that phenomena which are commonly called genocide rest upon invisible everyday practices that do not appear on the radar of transgressions, forming different plateaus of a rhizomatic expansion, called settler imperialism. Lastly, Finzsch makes a case for the reality of a merciless, albeit low-intensity war against the indigenous populations preceding organized modern wars like the ones led in the 150 years of our epoch, but already using biological methods to drive away, decimate or annihilate indigenous populations. Two historical examples are used for this line of reasoning: the use of pathogens derived from the smallpox against Native Americans in North America during the French and Indian Wars in the eighteenth century and the probable employ of these pathogens in the destruction of the Dharug and Kurringgai in Sydney 1789. Although in the latter case irrefutable evidence for the application of the smallpox virus is missing, circumstantial evidence suggesting such appliance is very high. Colonial wars, like all wars, are aimed at the subjugation of the opponents under the will of the victorious party. In the case of colonial wars the vanquished is generally the indigenous population. As the alien in the 1996 Sci-Fi movie Independence Day wanted humans simply to die, settlers in the Anglosphere wished the Indigenous to simply disappear. It was totally acceptable that this goal was achieved through seemingly natural causes like loss of lands and diminishing ecospheres. Under certain conditions, however, the exterminalist discourse changed its register and the consequence was either low intensity warfare or biological warfare. Only when this turned out to be insufficient, settler imperialists increased the intensity of the exterminalist agenda and resorted to mass killings that surmounted the threshold of visibility.
Notes
1 Jeffery Amherst, Official Papers, quoted in Fenn (Citation2000, p 1575).
5 Lemkin, (Citation1944, p 79). Tony Barta has made a similar statement in an article in 1987.
6 Deleuze Citation(2006). For Deleuze, the event has three conditions: Extension, intension, individuation. Deleuze (Citation1990, p 22).
10 I follow Michel Serres in this. For Serres, the medium of communication—in this case the rhizomatic expansion of settler societies—is not only that through and across which messages pass, but also an environment within which expansion occurs—or fails to. What is communicated is not just the message, but the social collectivity itself. Serres and Schehr (1983, p 50).
12 My article therefore runs counter to positions taken by Maxim Rodinson, Baruch Kimmerling and Ilan Pappé, not only because in my conceptualization of settler imperialism is limited to societies in the anglosphere, but also because I think that state-organized genocides are something different from settler imperialism. I also deny that Israel's policies in dealing with the Palestinians are generally genocidal, although I have to admit that my historical expertise concerning these issues is limited at best. Kimmerling Citation(2003); Pappé Citation(2006); Rodinson Citation(1973).
15 Starkey dismissed this interpretation in 1988. Starkey Citation(1998).
19 Dederer has explained the bifurcation of the militia system in colonial North America as a result of the wars with Native Americans. Dederer (Citation1990)
28 The UN definition of genocide emphasizes the criminal act as an event rather than the endurance and repetition of a social practice (Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights). The original definition by Polish jurist Raphael Lemkin was much more open to the composite nature and long-lasting aspect of genocides. Chalk and Jonassohn (Citation1990, pp 8–9). Churchill was among the first historians to complain about the conceptual rigidity of the genocide definitions, Churchill (Citation1997, p 71). See also Curthoys and Docker Citation(2001). Genocides can be transformed into theatrical productions, which proves their general narratability, Skloot Citation(1990).
29 Curthoys and Docker, op. cit. p 10.
32 Wallerstein claims that even under sixteenth century Spanish rule, the crown could not control the settlers in the colonies, Wallerstein (Citation1976, p 188).
33 Curthoys and Docker, op cit, p 6.
38 “Micro-politics” is a concept that was first defined by Michel Foucault, but extended and systematically applied by Deleuze and Guattari Citation(1987), op cit, pp 208–231. See also Houle Citation(2000). The rhizomatic territorialization of indigenous lands seems to have been typical for every frontier in the anglosphere except for “beachhead frontiers” like Sydney, NSW or Plymouth, MA, Connor (Citation2002, p 26).
42 In Queensland, the Native Police was one of the most effective agents of genocidal acts. Moses Citation(2000) op cit, pp 99–102.
48 Fenn, op cit, pp 1559–1561.
54 According to Native American sources “This smallpox was sold to them shut up in a showy tin box, with the strict injunction not to open the box on their way homeward.” Fenn op cit. After they had arrived at the beaches of Lake Michigan, the Ottawa opened the box and various other cases included in it. They “[…] found nothing but mouldy particles in the last box. […] They wondered very much what it was, and a great many closely inspected [the box and its content] to try to find out what it meant […] pretty soon [there] burst out a terrible sickness among them.” Andrew J. Blackbird quoted in MacLeod (Citation1992, p 50).
55 Fenn, op cit, pp 1552–1556. This recent interpretation is contradicted by older research. The interpretation hinges on the meaning of two words: Does “last spring” relate to the spring of 1763 or 1764? Knollenberg (Citation1954, p 493).
59 General Jeffery Amherst to Deputy Agent for Indian Affairs George Croghan, August 7, 1763, in: NativeWeb, Inc. Citation(2007).
60 Henry Bouquet to Jeffery Amherst, July 13, 1763, NativeWeb, Inc. op cit. See also Parkman (Citation1991, p 648).
61 Henry Bouquet to Jeffery Amherst, June 23, 1763, three weeks before the first discussion of the plan. NativeWeb, Inc., op cit.
62 Jeffery Amherst an Henry Bouquet am 16. Juli 1763. NativeWeb, Inc. op cit.
63 Journal of William Trent, entry date May 24th, 1763, in: Harpster (Citation1938, pp 103–104).
64 Parkman, op cit., p 649.
65 Kociumbas argues in the same direction. Kociumbas (Citation2004, pp 81–82).
68 Judy Campbell's notion that the virus could not have survived a transport of several months is erroneous. Campbell op. cit. p 62. See McGovern and Christopher, op cit; Fenner (Citation1988, pp 115–116, tab. 2.11).
69 “I can, therefore, only propose queries for the ingenuity of others to exercise itself upon: is it [the smallpox, N.F.] a disease indigenous to the country? […] It is true that our surgeons had brought out variolous matter in bottles, but to infer that it was produced from this cause were a supposition so wild as to be unworthy of consideration.”, Flannery (Citation1996, pp 103-104). Ventilators to cool provisions were present onboard. See First Fleet Fellowship Citation(2007).
75 Attwood and Forster (2003), op cit, pp 22–23. Unfortunately Attwood and Forster are unable to present Tim Rowse's oral contribution in an inter-subjectively tangible way.
Fenn
,
E. A.
2000
.
Biological warfare in eighteenth-century North America: beyond Jeffery Amherst
.
The Journal of American History
,
86
(
4
)
:
1552
–
1580
.
Deleuze
,
G.
1990
.
The Logic of Sense
,
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Tucker
,
A.
2004
.
Our Knowledge of the Past: A Philosophy of Historiography
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Lemkin
,
R.
1944
.
Axis Rule in Occupied Europe Laws of Occupation, Analysis of Government, Proposals for Redress
,
Washington, DC
:
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Division of International Law
.
Deleuze
,
G.
2006
.
The Fold: Leibniz and the Baroque
,
London, New York
:
Continuum
.
Deleuze
,
G.
1990
.
The Logic of Sense
,
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Deleuze
,
G.
and
Guattari
,
F.
1987
.
A Thousand Plateaus Capitalism and Schizophrenia
,
Minneapolis, MN
:
University of Minnesota Press
.
Moses
,
A. D.
2000
.
An antipodean genocide? the origins of the genocidal moment in the colonization of Australia
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
2
(
1
)
:
89
–
106
.
Finzsch
,
N.
2006
.
“
Siedlerimperialismus und Genozid in den Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika und Australien
”
. In
Atlantic Understandings: Essays on European and American History in Honor of Hermann Wellenreuther
,
Edited by:
Lehmann
,
H.
and
Schnurmann
,
C.
271
–
285
.
Mu¨nster
:
LIT Verlag
.
Lewy
,
G.
2007
.
Can there be genocide without the intent to commit genocide?
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
9
(
4
)
:
661
–
674
.
Barta
,
T.
2008
.
With intent to deny: on colonial intentions and genocide denial
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
10
(
1
)
:
111
–
119
.
Finzsch
,
N.
2008
.
If it looks like a duck, if it walks like a duck, if it quacks like a duck: comment on “Can there be genocide without the intent to commit genocide?” by Gunter Lewy
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
10
(
1
)
:
119
–
126
.
Stannard
,
D.
2008
.
Déjá vu all over again
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
10
(
1
)
:
127
–
133
.
Kimmerling
,
B.
2003
.
Politicide Ariel Sharon's Wars Against the Palestinians
,
London
:
VERSO
.
Pappé
,
I.
2006
.
The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine
,
Oxford
:
Oneworld
.
Rodinson
,
M.
1973
.
Israel: A Colonial-Settler State?
,
New York
:
Monad Press
.
Crary
,
J.
1990
.
Techniques of the Observer on Vision and Modernity in the Nineteenth Century
,
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Lee
,
W. E.
2001
.
Early American Ways of War: A New Reconnaissance, 1600–1815
.
Historical Journal
,
44
(
1
)
:
269
–
289
.
Starkey
,
A.
1998
.
European and Native American Warfare, 1675–1815
,
Norman, OK
:
University of Oklahoma Press
.
McGinnis
,
A.
1990
.
Counting Coup and Cutting Horses: Intertribal Warfare on the Northern Plains
,
1738
–
1889
.
Evergreen, CO
:
Cordillera Press
.
Anderson
,
F.
1984
.
A People's Army: Massachusetts Soldiers and Society in the Seven Years' War
,
Chapel Hill, NC
:
University of North Carolina Press
.
Selesky
,
H. E.
1990
.
War and Society in Colonial Connecticut
,
New Haven, CT
:
Yale University Press
.
Titus
,
J.
1991
.
The Old Dominion at War: Society, Politics, and Warfare in Late Colonial Virginia
,
Columbia, SC
:
University of South Carolina Press
.
Lenz
,
M.
2007
.
“Arma Sunt Necessaria”: Guns, Gun Culture and the Cultural Origins of the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
,
Dissertation
:
University of Cologne
.
Galtung
,
J.
1990
.
Cultural violence
.
Journal of Peace Research
,
27
(
3
)
:
291
–
305
.
Dederer
,
J. M.
1990
.
War in America to 1775: Before Yankee Doodle
,
New York
:
New York University Press
.
Michaux
,
F. A.
1904
.
Travels to the West of the Alleghany Mountains
,
Cleveland, OH
:
Arthur H. Clark
.
Grinde
,
D. A.
and
Johansen
,
B. E.
1995
.
Ecocide of Native America Environmental Destruction of Indian Lands and Peoples
,
Santa Fe
:
Clear Light
.
Catton
,
W. R
Jr.
1994
.
Foundations of human ecology
.
Sociological Perspectives
,
37
(
1
)
:
75
–
95
.
Bemrose
,
J.
1966
.
Reminiscences of the Second Seminole War
,
Gainesville, FL
:
University of Florida Press
.
Foucault
,
M.
1980
.
The History of Sexuality: An Introduction
,
New York
:
Vintage Books
.
Smart
,
B.
2002
.
Michel Foucault
,
New York
:
Routledge
.
Foucault
,
M.
1997
.
“Il Faut Défendre la Société”: Cours au Collège de France, 1975–1976
,
Paris
:
Gallimard
.
Moses
,
A. D.
2002
.
Conceptual blockages and definitional dilemmas in the ‘racial century’: genocides of indigenous peoples and the Holocaust
.
Patterns of Prejudice
,
36
(
4
)
:
7
–
36
.
Chalk
,
F. R.
and
Jonassohn
,
K.
1990
.
The History and Sociology of Genocide: Analyses and Case Studies
,
New Haven, CT
:
Yale University Press
.
Churchill
,
W.
1997
.
A Little Matter of Genocide Holocaust and Denial in the Americas, 1492 to the Present
,
San Francisco
:
City Lights Books
.
Curthoys
,
A.
and
Docker
,
J.
2001
.
Introduction—genocide: definitions, questions, settler-colonies
.
Aboriginal History
,
25
:
1
–
15
.
Skloot
,
R.
1990
.
Theatrical images of genocide
.
Human Rights Quarterly
,
12
(
2
)
:
185
–
201
.
Wolfe
,
P.
2001
.
Land, labor, and difference: elementary structure of race
.
American Historical Review
,
106
(
3
)
:
866
–
905
.
Wolfe
,
P.
2006
.
Settler colonialism and the elimination of the native
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
8
(
4
)
:
387
–
409
.
Churchill
,
W.
1997
.
A Little Matter of Genocide Holocaust and Denial in the Americas, 1492 to the Present
,
San Francisco
:
City Lights Books
.
Wallerstein
,
I. M.
1976
.
The Modern World-System: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century
,
New York
:
Academic Press
.
Cook
,
S. F.
1973
.
The significance of disease in the extinction of the New England Indians
.
Human Biology
,
45
(
3
)
:
485
–
508
.
Pulsipher
,
J. H.
2001
.
“Our Sages Are Sageles”: A letter on Massachusetts Indian policy after King Philip's War
.
The William and Mary Quarterly
,
58
(
2
)
:
431
–
448
.
Deleuze
,
G.
and
Guattari
,
F.
1987
.
A Thousand Plateaus Capitalism and Schizophrenia
,
Minneapolis, MN
:
University of Minnesota Press
.
Patton
,
P.
1984
.
Conceptual politics and the war machine in “Mille Plateaux”
.
SubStance
,
13
(
3–4
)
:
61
–
80
.
Deleuze
,
G.
and
Guattari
,
F.
1987
.
A Thousand Plateaus Capitalism and Schizophrenia
,
Minneapolis, MN
:
University of Minnesota Press
.
Houle
,
K. F.
2000
.
Micropolitics and property: Deleuze and Foucault on common ground
.
International Studies in Philosophy
,
32
(
1
)
:
113
–
122
.
Connor
,
J.
2002
.
The Australian Frontier Wars, 1788-1838
,
Sydney, NSW
:
UNSW Press
.
Dowd
,
G. E.
1992
.
A Spirited Resistance the North American Indian Struggle for Unity, 1745–1815
,
Baltimore, MD
:
Johns Hopkins University Press
.
Weaver
,
J. C.
1996
.
Beyond the fatal shore: pastoral squatting and the occupation of Australia, 1826 to 1852
.
American Historical Review
,
101
(
4
)
:
981
–
1007
.
Vismann
,
C.
1995
.
“
Terra Nullius: Zur Unterscheidung von Freund und Feind
”
. In
u¨bertragung und Gesetz. Gru¨ndungsmythen, Kriegstheater und Unterwerfungsstrategien von Institutionen
,
Edited by:
Adam
,
A.
and
Stingelin
,
M.
159
–
174
.
Berlin
:
Akademie Verlag
.
Newbury
,
P. W.
1999
.
Aboriginal Heroes of the Resistance: From Pemulwuy to Mabo
,
Surry Hills, NSW
:
Action for World Development
.
Willmot
,
E. P.
1988
.
Pemulwuy, the Rainbow Warrior
,
Sydney
:
Bantam
.
Medcalf
,
R.
1993
.
Rivers of Blood: Massacres of the Northern Rivers Aborigines and Their Resistance to the White Occupation, 1838–1870
,
Lismore
:
The Northern Star
.
Miller
,
J.
1985
.
Koori: A Will to Win the Heroic Resistance. Survival & Triumph of Black Australia
,
London
:
Angus & Robertson
.
Pope
,
A.
1989
.
Resistance and Retaliation Aboriginal-European Relations in Early Colonial South Australia
,
Bridgewater, SA
:
Heritage Action
.
Brownlie
,
R.
2003
.
A Fatherly Eye Indian Agents, Government Power, and Aboriginal Resistance in Ontario, 1918–1939
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Don Mills, ONT
Churchill
,
W.
2002
.
Struggle for the Land: Native North American Resistance to Genocide, Ecocide, and Colonization
,
San Francisco
:
City Lights
.
Fenelon
,
J. V.
1998
.
Culturicide, Resistance, and Survival of the Lakota (“Sioux Nation”)
,
New York
:
Garland Pub
.
Fischer
,
K.
2002
.
Suspect Relations Sex, Race, and Resistance in Colonial North Carolina
,
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Gouy-Gilbert
,
C.
1983
.
Une Résistance Indienne: Les Yaquis du Sonora
,
Lyon
:
Fédérop
.
Grounds
,
R. A.
,
Tinker
,
G. E.
and
Wilkins
,
D. E.
2003
.
Native Voices American Indian Identity and Resistance
,
Lawrence, KS
:
University Press of Kansas
.
Hu-DeHart
,
E.
1984
.
Yaqui Resistance and Survival the Struggle for Land and Autonomy, 1821–1910
,
Madison, WI
:
University of Wisconsin Press
.
Josephy
,
A. M.
1993
.
The Patriot Chiefs: A Chronicle of American Indian Resistance
,
New York
:
Penguin Books
.
Katz
,
J. B.
1975
.
Let Me Be a Free Man: A Documentary History of Indian Resistance
,
Minneapolis, MN
:
Lerner Publications Co
.
Richardson
,
R. N.
1973
.
The Comanche Barrier to South Plains Settlement: A Century and a Half of Savage Resistance to the Advancing White Frontier
,
Millwood, NY
:
Kraus Reprint Co.
.
Senier
,
S.
2001
.
Voices of American Indian Assimilation and Resistance: Helen Hunt Jackson, Sarah Winnemucca, and Victoria Howard
,
Norman, OK
:
University of Oklahoma Press
.
Taylor
,
W. B.
and
Franklin Pease
,
G. Y.
1994
.
Violence, Resistance, and Survival in the Americas: Native Americans and the Legacy of Conquest
,
Washington, DC
:
Smithsonian Institution Press
.
Moses
,
A. D.
2000
.
An antipodean genocide? the origins of the genocidal moment in the colonization of Australia
.
Journal of Genocide Research
,
2
(
1
)
:
89
–
106
.
Levene
,
M.
1999
.
The Chittagong Hill Tracts: a case study in the political economy of “creeping” genocide
.
Third World Review
,
20
(
2
)
:
339
–
369
.
Macaulay
,
T. B. M.
1888
.
The History of England From the Accession of James II
,
Chicago
:
Belford, Clarke & Co.
.
Wheelis
,
M.
1999
.
“
Biological warfare before 1914
”
. In
Biological and Toxin Weapons: Research, Development and Use From the Middle Ages to 1945
,
Edited by:
Geissler
,
E.
and
van Moon
,
J. E.
8
–
34
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Williams
,
J.
1721
.
Several Arguments, Proving, That Inoculating the Small Pox Is Not Contained in the Law of Physick, Either Natural or Divine, and Therefore Unlawful. Together With a Reply to Two Short Pieces, One by the Rev. Dr. Increase Mather, and Another by an Anonymous Author, Intituled, Sentiments on the Small Pox Inoculated. And Also, a Short Answer to a Late Letter in the New-England Courant
,
Boston, MA
:
J. Franklin
.
Miller
,
G.
1956
.
Smallpox inoculation in England and America: a reappraisal
.
William & Mary Quarterly
,
13
(
4
)
:
476
–
492
.
McGovern
,
T. W.
and
Christopher
,
G. W.
2007
.
Biological warfare and its cutaneous manifestations
.
The Electronic Textbook of Dermatology
,
http://telemedicine.org/stamfor1.htm (accessed February 24, 2008)
Campbell
,
J.
2002
.
Invisible Invaders Smallpox and Other Diseases in Aboriginal Australia, 1780–1880
,
Carlton South, VIC
:
Melbourne University Press
.
MacLeod
,
D. P.
1992
.
Microbes and muskets: smallpox and the participation of the Amerindian allies of New France in the Seven Years' War
.
Ethnohistory
,
39
(
4
)
:
42
–
64
.
Knollenberg
,
B.
1954
.
General Amherst and germ warfare
.
The Mississippi Valley Historical Review
,
51
(
4
)
:
489
–
494
.
Middlekauff
,
R.
1982
.
The Glorious Cause: The American Revolution, 1763–1789
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
White
,
R
.
1991
.
The Middle Ground Indians, Empires, and Republics in the Great Lakes Region
,
1650
–
1815
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Parkman
,
F.
1991
.
The Oregon Trail. The Conspiracy of Pontiac
,
New York
:
Viking Press
.
Harpster
,
J. W.
1938
.
Pen Pictures of Early Western Pennsylvania
,
Pittsburgh
:
University of Pittsburgh Press
.
Kociumbas
,
J.
2004
.
“
Genocide and modernity in colonial Australia, 1788–1850
”
. In
Genocide and Settler Society Frontier Violence and Stolen Indigenous Children in Australian History
,
Edited by:
Moses
,
A. D.
77
–
102
.
New York
:
Berghahn Books
.
Fitzmaurice
,
A.
2003
.
Humanism and America an Intellectual History of English Colonisation, 1500–1625
,
Cambridge, UK, New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Konishi
,
S.
2007
.
“
The father governor: the British administration of Aboriginal people at Port Jackson, 1788–1792
”
. In
Public Men: Political Masculinities in Modern Britain
,
Edited by:
McCormack
,
M.
54
–
72
.
New York
:
Palgrave Macmillan
.
Fenner
,
F.
1988
.
Smallpox and Its Eradication
,
Geneva
:
World Health Organization
.
Flannery
,
T. F.
1996
.
1788 Comprising A Narrative of the Expedition to Botany Bay and A Complete Account of the Settlement at Port Jackson
,
Melbourne
:
Text Pub. Co
.
Butlin
,
N. G.
1983
.
Our Original Aggression Aboriginal Populations of Southeastern Australia, 1788–1850
,
Sydney, Boston, MA
:
G. Allen & Unwin
.
Agamben
,
G.
2002
.
Homo Sacer
,
Frankfurt a. M
:
Edition Suhrkamp
.
Foucault
,
M.
2000
.
“
The birth of social medicine
”
. In
Power
,
Edited by:
Foucault
,
M.
134
–
156
.
New York
:
New Press
.
Mosse
,
G. L.
1985
.
Toward the Final Solution: A History of European Racism
,
Madison, WI
:
University of Wisconsin Press
.
Gascoigne
,
J.
2002
.
The Enlightenment and the Origins of European Australia
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Hinton
,
A. L.
2002
.
Annihilating Difference the Anthropology of Genocide
,
Berkeley, CA
:
University of California Press
.
Finzsch
,
N.
2007
.
“It is scarcely possible to conceive that human beings could be so hideous and loathsome”: discourses of genocide in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century America and Australia
”
. In
Colonialism and Genocide
,
Edited by:
Moses
,
A. D.
and
Stone
,
D.
1
–
19
.
Abingdon
:
Routledge
.