Abstract
Can the craft of planning take advantage of a growing body of planning-relevant research? Evidence-based practice proposes a better connection between research and professional work, but raises several concerns about the character of valid evidence, the strength and clarity of planning research, and inequalities in the available resources for integrating research into planning practice. Much of planning practice is a reflective craft where skills of mediation, negotiation, listening, and framing are prominent. As part of the planner's work employing these skills, however, there is a valuable role for research-generated evidence to inform decision making. Evidence-based practice needs careful implementation but it can enrich the field of planning by linking research to practice.
Notes
1. Relevant professions include business (Pfeffer & Sutton, 2006b), nursing (Dale, Citation2005; French, Citation2002), social work (Rubin, Citation2008; Webb, Citation2001), education (Davies, Citation1999; Slavin, Citation2002), interior design (InformeDesign, Citation2008), public health (Brownson et al., Citation2003), and medicine (Coomarasamy & Khan, 2004; Sackett et al., Citation1996).
2. Research is a form of scholarship or “the production and transmission of culturally valued, specialized knowledge” typically with clear goals, methods, broader significance, documentation and dissemination, and peer review (Diamond, Citation2002; Humphreys, Citation1997, p. 1). It is possible to practice in a scholarly way, just as it is possible to undertake the scholarship of teaching, though most practice is not scholarship (Boyer, Citation1990; Rice, Citation2002).
Dale
,
A.E.
2005
.
Evidence-based practice: compatibility with nursing
.
Nursing Standard
,
19
(
40
)
:
48
–
53
.
French
,
P.
2002
.
What is the evidence on evidence-based nursing? An epistemiological concern
.
Journal of Advanced Nursing
,
37
(
3
)
:
250
–
257
.
Rubin
,
A.
2008
.
Practitioner's Guide to Using Research for Evidence-Based Practice
,
Hoboken, NJ
:
Wiley
.
Webb
,
S.A.
2001
.
Some considerations on the validity of evidence-based practice in social work
.
British Journal of Social Work
,
31
(
1
)
:
57
–
79
.
Davies
,
P.
1999
.
What is evidence-based education?
.
British Journal of Educational Studies
,
47
(
20
)
:
108
–
121
.
Slavin
,
R.E.
2002
.
Evidence-based education policies: transforming educational practice and research
.
Educational Researcher
,
31
(
7
)
:
15
–
21
.
Brownson
,
R.C.
,
Baker
,
E.A.
,
Leet
,
T.L.
and
Gillespie
,
K.N.
2003
.
Evidence-Based Public Health
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Sackett
,
D.L.
,
Rosenberg
,
W.M.C.
,
Gray
,
J.A.M.
,
Haynes
,
R.B.
and
Richardson
,
W.S.
1996
.
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't: it's about integrating individual clinical expertise and the best external evidence
.
British Medical Journal
,
312
:
71
–
72
.
Diamond
,
R.
2002
.
“
Defining scholarship for the twenty-first century
”
. In
Scholarship in the Postmodern Era
,
Edited by:
Zahorski
,
K.
San Francisco
:
Jossey Bass
.
Humphreys
,
S.C.
1997
.
“
Introduction: let's hear it for the magpies
”
. In
Cultures of Scholarship
,
Edited by:
Humphreys
,
S.C.
Ann Arbor
:
University of Michigan Press
.
Boyer
,
E.
1990
.
Scholarship Reconsidered
,
Menlo Park, CA
:
Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching
.
Rice
,
R.E.
2002
.
“
Beyond scholarship reconsidered: toward an enlarged vision of the scholarly work of faculty members
”
. In
Scholarship in the Postmodern Era
,
Edited by:
Zahorski
,
K.
San Francisco
:
Jossey Bass
.