Consequences of the limit on foreign players in Russian football

Abstract

This paper examines how a limit on foreign players has influenced national football in Russia. For this purpose, the effects on competition in the league, number of new young players in the national team and commercial value are investigated. Both positive and negative effects are examined. On the one hand, a quota on foreign players raised the competition in the Russian Premier League and captured attention of club owners on the development of youth academies. On the other hand, the negative effects included the reduction in the number of young players in the Russia national team, and the restriction in the invitation of international stars slowed down the growth of match attendance and commercial value. Therefore, because of the current limit, Russia became less competitive. However, if some of the measures suggested in this paper were to be implemented, Russia might improve its development of national football.

Notes

1. Jarigin, ‘Мутко поставил двойку’, http://www.rg.ru/2005/12/13/sbornye-itogi.html.

2. Mujzhnek, ‘Легион против Империи’, http://www.sports.ru/football/131930369.html.

3. RFS.ru., ‘SOGAZ Russian Football Championship Regulation’, ‘Title 5’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/res/docs/regulations/Regl_SOGAZ_chempRos_2012-2013.pdf.

4. RFS.ru., ‘Football Championship of the National League regulation’, ‘Title 8’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/res/docs/regulations/Reglament_SUPRA-Pervenstva_Rossii_po_futbolu_sredi_komand_klubov_FNL.pdf.

5. RFS.ru., 2012. ‘Russian Second Division Regulation’, ‘Title 5’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/res/docs/regulations/regulations_2div_201213.pdf.

6. Jarigin, ‘Мутко поставил двойку’, http://www.rg.ru/2005/12/13/sbornye-itogi.html.

7. Milanovic, ‘Globalization and Goals: Does Soccer Show the Way?’.

8. Feess and Muehlheusser, ‘Transfer Fee Regulations in European Football’.

9. H. Verbon, Migrating Football Players, Transfer Fees and Migration Controls (2004).

10. Dejonghe and Van Opstal, ‘Competitive Balance Between National Leagues in European Football after the Bosman Case’.

11. Flores, Forrest, and Tena, ‘Impact on Competitive Balance from Allowing Foreign Players in a Sports League’.

12. Mitchell, Agle, and Wood, ‘Toward a Theory of Stakeholder Identification and Salience: Defining the Principle of Who and What Really Counts’.

13. Parker and Stone, Developing Management Skills for Leadership, 216.

14. Beech and Chadwick, The Business of Sport Management, 229.

15. Troelsen and Dejonghe, ‘The Need of Competitive Balance in European Professional Soccer’.

16. Collett, ‘Warning Follows Premier League Match with No Englishmen’, http://uk.reuters.com/article/2009/12/31/uk-soccer-england-overseas-fapl-idUKTRE5BU2H420091231.

17. Downward, Dawson, and Dejonghe, Sports Economics, Theory, Evidence and Policy, 261.

18. Mujzhnek, ‘Легион против Империи’, http://www.sports.ru/football/131930369.html.

19. State Duma, ‘On Physical Culture and Sports in the Russian Federation’, 2007, N 329.

20. RFS.ru., ‘Charter of RFU’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/rfs/documents/founding_docs/.

21. RFS.ru., ‘SOGAZ Russian Football Championship regulation’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/res/docs/regulations/Regl_SOGAZ_chempRos_2012-2013.pdf.

22. Borzikin, ‘Зачем России лимит на легионеров?’, http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/article-item/487402.

23. Ibid.

24. Chaushjan, ‘Лимит на легионеров: хотели как лучше …’, http://www.aif.ru/sport/article/62052.

25. Egorov, ‘Валерий Карпин: Чем жертвую? Здоровьем …’, http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/article-item/485234.

26. Alexeev and Domchev, ‘Футбол по российской системе’, http://www.gazeta.ru/sport/rfc/2010/09/a_3419154.shtml.

27. Borzikin, ‘Зачем России лимит на легионеров?’, http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/article-item/487402.

28. Ennis, ‘Blow for Blatter as EU Rejects ‘6 + 5’ Plan to Limit Foreign Players’, http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/news-and-comment/blow-for-blatter-as-eu-rejects-65-plan-to-limit-foreign-players-824091.html.

29. Ibid.

30. Ibid.

31. Ibid.

32. Matveev, ‘Сергей Прядкин: Оставить нынешний лимит на легионеров - личная просьба Платини’, http://www.sovsport.ru/news/text-item/375440.

33. Amies, ‘Platini Faces Stormy Second Term as UEFA Chief as He Pushes for Reform’, http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,14733032,00.html.

34. Downward, Dawson, and Dejonghe, Sports Economics, Theory, Evidence and Policy, 219.

35. Troelsen and Dejonghe, ‘The Need of Competitive Balance in European Professional Soccer’.

36. Aliyev, ‘Фабио Капелло посетит Дагестан’, http://www.rg.ru/2012/08/15/reg-skfo/kapello-anons.html.

37. MCFC.co.uk., ‘Players Section’, http://www.mcfc.co.uk/Players.

38. Dejonghe and Van Opstal, ‘Competitive Balance Between National Leagues in European Football After the Bosman Case’.

39. Flores, Forrest, and Tena, ‘Impact on Competitive Balance from Allowing Foreign Players in a Sports League’.

40. Tikhonov, ‘20 самых вместительных стадионов России’, http://www.sports.ru/football/91621326.html.

41. Memoid.ru., ‘TV Section’, http://www.memoid.ru/node/Perspektivy_platnyh_translyacij_futbola_v_Rossii.

42. Localov and Tarasenko, ‘Кто хочет стать миллионером?’, http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/article-item/469713.

43. Kozlov, ‘Russian Premier League TV Awarded $2.8 M in Damages Over “Illegal” Broadcasts’, http://www.sportsbusinessdaily.com/Global/Issues/2014/01/20/Media/Russia-Verdict.aspx.

44. Dejonghe and Van Opstal, ‘Competitive Balance Between National Leagues in European Football After the Bosman Case’.

45. Teenagers Football League, ‘News Section’, http://www.dfl.org.ru/news/1323/.

46. Bystrov, ‘Бухгалтерия отдельно взятого клуба’, http://www.sports.ru/tribuna/blogs/navosha/148791.html.

47. RFS.ru., ‘SOGAZ Russian Football Championship Regulation’, ‘Title 5’, 2012, http://rfs.ru/res/docs/regulations/Regl_SOGAZ_chempRos_2012-2013.pdf.

48. Colucci, ‘Quota for Foreign Football Players Allowed to Play in a Club. A Comparative Analysis at National Level’, http://www.rdes.it/FOREIGN_PLAYERS36.pdf.