Abstract
A corporate crisis can be defined as a short-term, undesired, unfavourable and critical state in a company, which has derived from both internal and external causes and which directly endangers the further existence and growth of the company. Although the state of crisis in the company can be affected by various interrelated external and internal causes, which vary by company as to intensity and appearance, the essence of the causes surely lies in the management of the company. During the country's period of transition, all types of explained management mistakes could be found in Slovene corporate systems. Despite the fact that the hypothesis that a pattern of management mistakes follows changes in the political and economic environment cannot be completely reliably confirmed, some outlines of such patterns are seen, in spite of everything. If there really is a more or less valid pattern of management mistakes in corporate crises and these mistakes appear differently with regard to changes in the political and economical environment in countries in transition, this could help decision-makers, who are in the process of appointing new crisis or restructuring managers, make better choices, every time, according to the managers' most appropriate competencies.
Notes
‘Sooner or later, every business will be confronted with a crisis of some type. Its ability to manage the crisis successfully can mean the difference between survival and disaster’ (Spillan, Citation2003, p. 161).
Cf. for example, Barnett and Pratt, Citation2000; Barton, Citation1993; Buchalik, Citation2004; Fink, Citation1986; Grünert, Citation2007; Heath, Citation1998; Kraus and Becker-Kolle, Citation2004; Lerbinger, Citation1997; Leupin, Citation1998; Mitroff et al., Citation2006; Moore and Seymour, Citation2005; Neubauer, Citation1999; Roux-Dufort, Citation2003; Slatter, Citation1987; Smith, Citation2006.
Roux-Dufort (Citation2003) indicates the following equation of a crisis: ‘crisis=accumulation of ruined equilibriums+ignorance of management’, pointing out the insufficient ‘vigilance’ of management.
Some sources are, for example, Bellinger (Citation1962), Buth and Hermanns Citation(2004), Kraus and Becker-Kolle (Citation2004), Mitroff et al. (Citation2006), Müller Citation(1986), Pate (Citation1999), Richardson Citation(1994), Slatter (Citation1987), Turner and Pidgeon Citation(1997), Wildemann (Citation2004) and www.infoquelle.de (accessed January 31, 2007).
Or also ‘polymorphous phenomenon’ (Hensen et al., Citation2003). Mellahi and Wilkinson Citation(2004) state that the organisational failure is connectively influenced by environmental factors (technological uncertainty, regulatory changes, economic changes), ecological factors (density, size, age, industry life-cycle), organisational factors (management tenure, homogeneity and successions, past performance) and psychological factors (managerial perceptions).
We debate on the most characteristic and frequent reactions of the management to the emerged situation, while it might not be necessary that, in the case in question, all characteristics are present or in this succession.
Hartley (Citation2005) divides management mistakes in two groups: mistakes of omission (no action was taken) and mistakes of commission (bad decision, wrong actions taken, etc.).
Avoiding adoption of important strategic decisions is, by the way, often typical of a management directly prior to its departure or retirement, when it attempts to avoid possible risks resulting from strategic decisions, which is probably not beneficial for the company.
There is no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ in making business decisions – decision-making is not like mathematics where you can prove that something is ‘right’. ‘… Business decision-making is far more situational – the right decision today is really just the “best decision” based on the current situation, what is known, and what the options are’ (Kow, Citation2004, p. 28).
It can be concluded from the stated excursus that the position of an individual company within an industry must be monitored from the perspective of the circumstances in the industry, which can be identical to the economic conditions in the region or the country; it may also be better or even much worse.
‘One natural way to facilitate moral outcomes is through organizational cultures where certain principles, norms, and values are internalised and fully motivating’ (Smith, Citation2005, p. 163).
Spillan
,
J. E.
2003
.
An explanatory model for evaluating crisis events and managers' concerns in non-profit organisations
.
Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management
,
11
(
4
)
:
160
–
167
.
Barnett
,
C. K.
and
Michael
,
G. P.
2000
.
From threat-rigidity to flexibility: Toward a learning model of autogenic crisis in organizations
.
Journal of Organizational Change Management
,
13
(
1
)
:
74
–
88
.
Barton
,
L.
1993
.
Crisis in organizations
,
Cincinnati
:
South-Western
.
Buchalik
,
R.
2004
.
“
Restrukturierungs-/Sanierungsmöglichkeiten aus der Sicht der finanzierenden Bank
”
. In
Restrukturierung, Sanierung, Insolvenz (Restructuring, healing and bankruptcy)
,
Edited by:
Buth
,
A. K.
and
Hermanns
,
M.
30
–
64
.
München
:
Verlag C.H. Beck
.
(Restructuring and healing possibilities from the financing bank's point of view)
Fink
,
S.
1986
.
Crisis management
,
New York
:
Amacom
.
Grünert
,
T.
2007
.
Mergers and acquisitions in Unternehmungskrisen
,
Wiesbaden
:
Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag
.
Heath
,
R.
1998
.
Crisis management for managers and executives
,
London
:
Financial Times, Pitman
.
Kraus
,
G.
and
Becker-Kolle
,
C.
2004
.
Führen in Krisenzeiten
,
115
–
146
.
Wiesbaden
:
Gabler
.
(Management in times of crisis)
Lerbinger
,
O.
1997
.
The crisis manager
,
Mahwah
:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
Leupin
,
U.
1998
.
Turnaround von Unternehmen
,
Bern
:
Verlag Paul Haupt
.
(Corporate turnaround)
Mitroff
,
I. I.
,
Pauchant
,
T. C.
and
Shrivastava
,
P.
2006
.
“
The structure of man-made organizational crises: Conceptual and empirical issues in the development of a general theory of crisis management
”
. In
Key readings in crisis management
,
Edited by:
Smith
,
D.
and
Elliott
,
D.
47
–
74
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Moore
,
S.
and
Seymour
,
M.
2005
.
Global technology and corporate crisis
,
London
:
Routledge
.
Neubauer
,
M.
1999
.
Krisenmanagement in Projekten
,
Berlin
:
Springer
.
(Crisis management in projects)
Roux-Dufort
,
C.
2003
.
Gérer et décider en situation de crise
,
Paris
:
Dunod
.
(Leading and decision-making in a crisis situation)
Slatter
,
S.
1987
.
Corporate recovery. A guide to turnaround management
,
London
:
Penguin Books
.
Smith
,
D.
2006
.
“
Crisis management – practice in search of a paradigm
”
. In
Key readings in crisis management
,
Edited by:
Smith
,
D.
and
Elliott
,
D.
London
:
Routledge
.
Roux-Dufort
,
C.
2003
.
Gérer et décider en situation de crise
,
Paris
:
Dunod
.
(Leading and decision-making in a crisis situation)
Bellinger
,
B.
1962
.
“
Unternehmungskrisen und ihre Ursachen
”
. In
Handelsbetrieb und Marktordnung
,
Wiesbaden
:
Verlag Dr. Th. Gabler
.
(Corporate crisis and its causes. Trading companies and market order)
Buth
,
A. K.
and
Hermanns
,
M.
2004
.
Restrukturierung, Sanierung, Insolvenz
,
München
:
Verlag C. H. Beck
.
(Restructuring, healing and bankruptcy)
Kraus
,
G.
and
Becker-Kolle
,
C.
2004
.
Führen in Krisenzeiten
,
115
–
146
.
Wiesbaden
:
Gabler
.
(Management in times of crisis)
Mitroff
,
I. I.
,
Pauchant
,
T. C.
and
Shrivastava
,
P.
2006
.
“
The structure of man-made organizational crises: Conceptual and empirical issues in the development of a general theory of crisis management
”
. In
Key readings in crisis management
,
Edited by:
Smith
,
D.
and
Elliott
,
D.
47
–
74
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Müller
,
R.
1986
.
Krisenmanagement in der Unternehmung
,
Frankfurt am Main
:
Peter Lang
.
(Corporate crisis management)
Pate
,
R. C.
1999
.
“
Business regeneration: Early detection – early intervention
”
. In
Workouts & turnarounds II, global restructuring strategies for the next century
,
Edited by:
DiNapoli
,
D.
New York
:
Wiley
.
Richardson
,
B.
1994
.
Crisis management and management strategy – time to ‘loop the loop’?
.
Disaster Prevention and Management
,
3
(
3
)
:
59
–
80
.
Slatter
,
S.
1987
.
Corporate recovery. A guide to turnaround management
,
London
:
Penguin Books
.
Turner
,
B. A.
and
Pidgeon
,
N. F.
1997
.
Man-made disasters
,
London
:
Butterworth-Heinemann
.
Wildemann
,
H.
2004
.
Sanierungsstrategien
,
München
:
TCW Transfer-Centrum
.
(Healing strategies)
Hensen
,
T.
,
Desouza
,
K. C.
and
Kraft
,
G. D.
2003
.
Games, signal detection, and processing in the context of crisis management
.
Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management
,
11
(
2
)
:
67
–
72
.
Mellahi
,
K.
and
Wilkinson
,
A.
2004
.
Organizational failure: A critique of recent research and a proposed integrative framework
.
International Journal of Management Reviews
,
1
(
5/6
)
:
21
–
41
.
Hartley
,
R. F.
2005
.
Management mistakes and success
,
New York
:
Wiley
.
Kow
,
G.
2004
.
Turning around business performance: Part II
.
Journal of Change Management
,
4
(
4
)
:
281
–
296
.
Smith
,
J. D.
2005
.
Moral markets and moral managers revisited
.
Journal of Business Ethics
,
61
(
2
)
:
129
–
141
.