Abstract
This essay reviews published responses to Paul Gilroy's The Black Atlantic (1993). The essay begins by summarizing Gilroy's main arguments and considering the significance of his term “double consciousness,” both as a theme and as a theoretical approach. It goes on to examine reviews, articles, books and journal special issues, spanning from 1994 to 2008, which either engage directly with Gilroy's text or make use of his term “black Atlantic” as a basis for further research. Early reviews of The Black Atlantic balance its shortcomings against its groundbreaking potential, envisaging that the book will generate discussions for years to come across a range of disciplines. Analysis of more recent literary criticism and cultural theory which draws on Gilroy's ideas, taking them in a variety of often conflicting directions, demonstrates the accuracy of this prediction. The essay looks first at critics’ commentaries on the scope of Gilroy's project, whether they aim to extend it so that it encompasses a broader range of social and cultural contexts, or to narrow its focus in a way which illuminates its relevance for a particular country or region. Readings of The Black Atlantic asserting the need to incorporate the Pacific and the Indian diaspora into Gilroy's black Atlantic vision, or to transform his “counterculture of modernity” into a more general notion of anti-colonial resistance, are compared to readings which seek to ground Gilroy's theoretical framework within the social realities of Africa, the Caribbean, or Canada. The essay then explores the work of critics and theorists who have identified problems with Gilroy's style, viewing his black Atlantic model as dangerously abstracted from the material world, and discussing the limitations of his postnational stance. I argue that the apparent inconsistencies within Gilroy's theoretical framework have led to productive debates and significant shifts in methodology within literary and cultural studies.
Notes
1. CitationGilroy, The Black Atlantic, 1. All further references will be marked in parentheses.
Gilroy
,
Paul.
1993
.
The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness
,
London and New York
:
Verso
.
Winant
,
Howard.
“Notes on Paul Gilroy's The Black Atlantic.”
Found Object
4
Autumn
1994
:
5
10
.
Winant
,
Howard.
“Notes on Paul Gilroy's The Black Atlantic.”
Found Object
4
Autumn
1994
:
5
10
.
Reid-Pharr
,
Robert F.
“Engendering the Black Atlantic.”
Found Object
4
1994
:
11
6
.
Reid-Pharr
,
Robert F.
“Engendering the Black Atlantic.”
Found Object
4
1994
:
11
6
.
Reid-Pharr
,
Robert F.
“Engendering the Black Atlantic.”
Found Object
4
1994
:
11
6
.
Lipsitz
,
George.
1995
.
Review of Paul Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Social Identities
,
1
(
1
)
:
193
–
200
.
Goebel
,
Walter
,
Saskia
Schabio
.
“Introduction: Relocating Modernization and Technology.”
In
Beyond the Black Atlantic: Relocating Modernization and Technology
,
1
10
.
London
:
Routledge
2006
Goebel
,
Walter
,
Saskia
Schabio
.
“Introduction: Relocating Modernization and Technology.”
In
Beyond the Black Atlantic: Relocating Modernization and Technology
,
1
10
.
London
:
Routledge
2006
Goebel
,
Walter
,
Saskia
Schabio
.
“Introduction: Relocating Modernization and Technology.”
In
Beyond the Black Atlantic: Relocating Modernization and Technology
,
1
10
.
London
:
Routledge
2006
Williams
,
Brackette F.
1995
.
Review of Paul Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Social Identities
,
1
(
1
)
:
175
–
92
.
Pettinger
,
Alasdair
.
“Introduction.”
In
Always Elsewhere: Travels of the Black Atlantic
,
viii–xix
.
London and New York
:
Cassell
,
1998
.
Pettinger
,
Alasdair
.
“Introduction.”
In
Always Elsewhere: Travels of the Black Atlantic
,
viii–xix
.
London and New York
:
Cassell
,
1998
.
De Souza
,
Pascale
and
Adlai Murdoch
,
H.
2005
.
“Oceanic Dialogues: from the Black Atlantic to the Indo-Pacific.”
.
Special issue, International Journal of Francophone Studies
,
8
(
2
)
:
133
–
46
.
De Souza
,
Pascale
and
Adlai Murdoch
,
H.
2005
.
“Oceanic Dialogues: from the Black Atlantic to the Indo-Pacific.”
.
Special issue, International Journal of Francophone Studies
,
8
(
2
)
:
133
–
46
.
Gruesser
,
John Cullen.
2005
.
Confluences: Postcolonialism, African American Literary Studies, and the Black Atlantic
,
Athens and London
:
The University of Georgia Press
.
Gruesser
,
John Cullen.
2005
.
Confluences: Postcolonialism, African American Literary Studies, and the Black Atlantic
,
Athens and London
:
The University of Georgia Press
.
Gruesser
,
John Cullen.
2005
.
Confluences: Postcolonialism, African American Literary Studies, and the Black Atlantic
,
Athens and London
:
The University of Georgia Press
.
Gruesser
,
John Cullen.
2005
.
Confluences: Postcolonialism, African American Literary Studies, and the Black Atlantic
,
Athens and London
:
The University of Georgia Press
.
Chambers
,
Douglas B.
“The Black Atlantic: Theory, Method, and Practice.”
In
The Atlantic World, 1450–2000
, ed.
Toyin
Falola
Kevin D.
Roberts
,
151
73
.
Bloomington and Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
,
2008
.
Chambers
,
Douglas B.
“The Black Atlantic: Theory, Method, and Practice.”
In
The Atlantic World, 1450–2000
, ed.
Toyin
Falola
Kevin D.
Roberts
,
151
73
.
Bloomington and Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
,
2008
.
Chambers
,
Douglas B.
“The Black Atlantic: Theory, Method, and Practice.”
In
The Atlantic World, 1450–2000
, ed.
Toyin
Falola
Kevin D.
Roberts
,
151
73
.
Bloomington and Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
,
2008
.
Chambers
,
Douglas B.
“The Black Atlantic: Theory, Method, and Practice.”
In
The Atlantic World, 1450–2000
, ed.
Toyin
Falola
Kevin D.
Roberts
,
151
73
.
Bloomington and Indianapolis
:
Indiana University Press
,
2008
.
Chude-Sokei
,
Louise.
1996
.
The Black Atlantic Paradigm: Paul Gilroy and the Fractured Landscape of ‘Race’
.
American Quarterly
,
48
(
4
)
:
740
–
5
.
Olver
,
Thomas
and
Meyer
,
Stephen.
2004
.
Introduction: African Shores and Transatlantic Interlocutions
.
Special issue, Current Writing: Text and Reception in Southern Africa
,
16
(
2
)
:
1
–
17
.
Olver
,
Thomas
and
Meyer
,
Stephen.
2004
.
Introduction: African Shores and Transatlantic Interlocutions
.
Special issue, Current Writing: Text and Reception in Southern Africa
,
16
(
2
)
:
1
–
17
.
Olver
,
Thomas
and
Meyer
,
Stephen.
2004
.
Introduction: African Shores and Transatlantic Interlocutions
.
Special issue, Current Writing: Text and Reception in Southern Africa
,
16
(
2
)
:
1
–
17
.
Olver
,
Thomas
and
Meyer
,
Stephen.
2004
.
Introduction: African Shores and Transatlantic Interlocutions
.
Special issue, Current Writing: Text and Reception in Southern Africa
,
16
(
2
)
:
1
–
17
.
Piot
,
Charles.
2001
.
Atlantic Aporias: Africa and Gilroy's Black Atlantic
.
South Atlantic Quarterly
,
100
(
1
)
:
155
–
70
.
Edwards
,
Norval (Nadi).
“And Some Routes Not Taken: A Caribcentric Reading of The Black Atlantic.”
Found Object 4
1994
:
27
35
.
Edwards
,
Norval (Nadi).
“And Some Routes Not Taken: A Caribcentric Reading of The Black Atlantic.”
Found Object 4
1994
:
27
35
.
Edwards
,
Norval (Nadi).
“And Some Routes Not Taken: A Caribcentric Reading of The Black Atlantic.”
Found Object 4
1994
:
27
35
.
Brydon
,
Diana.
“Detour Canada: Rerouting the Black Atlantic, Reconfiguring the Postcolonial.”
In
Reconfigurations: Canadian Literature and Postcolonial Identities
Mark
Maufort
Franca
Bellarsi
109–122. Brussels: Peter Lang, 2002
.
Brydon
,
Diana.
“Detour Canada: Rerouting the Black Atlantic, Reconfiguring the Postcolonial.”
In
Reconfigurations: Canadian Literature and Postcolonial Identities
Mark
Maufort
Franca
Bellarsi
109–122. Brussels: Peter Lang, 2002
.
Clarke
,
George Elliott.
1996
.
Must All Blackness Be American?: Locating Canada in Borden's ‘Tightrope Time,’ or Nationalizing Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Canadian Ethnic Studies
,
28
(
3
)
:
56
–
71
.
Clarke
,
George Elliott.
1996
.
Must All Blackness Be American?: Locating Canada in Borden's ‘Tightrope Time,’ or Nationalizing Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Canadian Ethnic Studies
,
28
(
3
)
:
56
–
71
.
Clarke
,
George Elliott.
1996
.
Must All Blackness Be American?: Locating Canada in Borden's ‘Tightrope Time,’ or Nationalizing Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Canadian Ethnic Studies
,
28
(
3
)
:
56
–
71
.
Clarke
,
George Elliott.
1996
.
Must All Blackness Be American?: Locating Canada in Borden's ‘Tightrope Time,’ or Nationalizing Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Canadian Ethnic Studies
,
28
(
3
)
:
56
–
71
.
Brydon
,
Diana.
“Detour Canada: Rerouting the Black Atlantic, Reconfiguring the Postcolonial.”
In
Reconfigurations: Canadian Literature and Postcolonial Identities
Mark
Maufort
Franca
Bellarsi
109–122. Brussels: Peter Lang, 2002
.
Clarke
,
George Elliott.
1996
.
Must All Blackness Be American?: Locating Canada in Borden's ‘Tightrope Time,’ or Nationalizing Gilroy's The Black Atlantic
.
Canadian Ethnic Studies
,
28
(
3
)
:
56
–
71
.
Masilela
,
Ntongela.
1996
.
The ‘Black Atlantic’ and African Modernity in South Africa
.
Research in African Literatures
,
27
(
4
)
:
88
–
96
.
Barnes
,
Natasha.
1996
.
Black Atlantic – Black America
.
Research in African Literatures
,
27
(
4
)
:
106
–
7
.
Barnes
,
Natasha.
1996
.
Black Atlantic – Black America
.
Research in African Literatures
,
27
(
4
)
:
106
–
7
.
Chrisman
,
Laura.
2003
.
Postcolonial Contraventions: Cultural Readings of Race, Imperialism and Transnationalism
,
Manchester and New York
:
Manchester University Press
.
Barnes
,
Natasha.
1996
.
Black Atlantic – Black America
.
Research in African Literatures
,
27
(
4
)
:
106
–
7
.
Barnes
,
Natasha.
1996
.
Black Atlantic – Black America
.
Research in African Literatures
,
27
(
4
)
:
106
–
7
.
Gunning
,
Dave.
2004
.
Anti-Racism, the Nation-State and Contemporary Black British Literature
.
The Journal of Commonwealth Literature
,
39
(
2
)
:
29
–
43
.
Gunning
,
Dave.
2004
.
Anti-Racism, the Nation-State and Contemporary Black British Literature
.
The Journal of Commonwealth Literature
,
39
(
2
)
:
29
–
43
.
Gunning
,
Dave.
2004
.
Anti-Racism, the Nation-State and Contemporary Black British Literature
.
The Journal of Commonwealth Literature
,
39
(
2
)
:
29
–
43
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Giles
,
Paul.
2001
.
Transatlantic Insurrections: British Culture and the Formation of American Literature, 1730–1860
,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
:
University of Pennsylvania Press
.
Giles
,
Paul.
2001
.
Transatlantic Insurrections: British Culture and the Formation of American Literature, 1730–1860
,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
:
University of Pennsylvania Press
.
Puri
,
Shalini.
2004
.
The Caribbean Postcolonial: Social Equality, Post-Nationalism, and Cultural Hybridity
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Rothberg
,
Michael.
“Small Acts, Global Acts: Paul Gilroy's Transnationalism.”
Found Object
4
Autumn
1994
:
17
26
.
Lazarus
,
Neil.
1999
.
Nationalism and Cultural Practice in the Postcolonial World
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Dayan
,
Joan.
“Paul Gilroy's Slaves, Ships, and Routes: The Middle Passage as Metaphor.”
In
Sisyphus and Eldorado: Magical and Other Realisms in Caribbean Literature
.
Timothy J.
Reiss
,
187
99
.
2nd edn
.
Africa World Press
:
Trenton, NJ and Asmara, Eritrea
,
2002
.
Dayan
,
Joan.
“Paul Gilroy's Slaves, Ships, and Routes: The Middle Passage as Metaphor.”
In
Sisyphus and Eldorado: Magical and Other Realisms in Caribbean Literature
.
Timothy J.
Reiss
,
187
99
.
2nd edn
.
Africa World Press
:
Trenton, NJ and Asmara, Eritrea
,
2002
.
Chrisman
,
Laura.
2003
.
Postcolonial Contraventions: Cultural Readings of Race, Imperialism and Transnationalism
,
Manchester and New York
:
Manchester University Press
.
Dayan
,
Joan.
“Paul Gilroy's Slaves, Ships, and Routes: The Middle Passage as Metaphor.”
In
Sisyphus and Eldorado: Magical and Other Realisms in Caribbean Literature
.
Timothy J.
Reiss
,
187
99
.
2nd edn
.
Africa World Press
:
Trenton, NJ and Asmara, Eritrea
,
2002
.
Donnell
,
Alison.
2006
.
Twentieth-Century Caribbean Literature
,
Oxford
:
Routledge
.
Donnell
,
Alison.
2006
.
Twentieth-Century Caribbean Literature
,
Oxford
:
Routledge
.
Donnell
,
Alison.
2006
.
Twentieth-Century Caribbean Literature
,
Oxford
:
Routledge
.
Bauman
,
Zygmunt.
2000
.
Liquid Modernity
,
Cambridge
:
Polity Press
.