Tackling material dependency in sustainability transition: rationales and insights from the agriculture sector

ABSTRACT

Human material dependency is hardly questioned as such. However, there are different understandings of humans’ connection with their biophysical milieu. In this paper, we discuss four basic accounts, which differ according to whether dependency and agency are assumed to be strong or weak. Though these accounts, which we label as Cartesian, Kantian, Spinozian and Adornian, are ideal-typical, we argue they express a cognitive path dependency that can be detected in the diverse ways the transition to sustainability is pursued. To show the heuristic value of the typology we focus on agriculture, as a field of major relevance in this regard. The first three rationales, respectively underpinning industrial agriculture, ecosystem services and earth restoration programmes, see material dependency as a problem to which the reply is mastering the world, though such mastery is understood differently. The fourth one, which underpins peasant agroecology, sees dependency as a constitutive – that is, unavoidable and formative – limitation, pointing to a caring, friendly attitude. We argue this outlook is crucial to a sustainability transition, and give a clue to the governance approach that may help support it.

KEYWORDS:

• Ecosystem services
• earth restoration
• peasant agroecology
• vitalism
• Adorno and non-identity

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Luigi Pellizzoni

Luigi Pellizzoni is professor of Sociology of the environment and territory at the Department of Political Sciences, University of Pisa and co-ordinator of the research group Politics Ontologies Ecologies (www.poeweb.eu). His research interests intersect three fields: risk, uncertainty, environmental change and sustainability; anticipations and impacts of scientific advancement and technological innovation; conflict, participation and the transformation of governance.

Laura Centemeri

Laura Centemeri is Senior Researcher in Environmental Sociology at the French CNRS. Her areas of interest and research projects include: sociology of (e)valuation and environmental conflicts, environmental movements and agro-ecological movements (e.g. permaculture), sociology of repair and environmental disasters.