Workplace Protection Factors for an N95 Filtering Facepiece Respirator

Abstract

This study evaluated the workplace performance of an N95 filtering facepiece, air-purifying respirator in a steel foundry. Air samples were collected inside and outside respirators worn by workers who were properly trained and qualitatively fit tested. For most workers, three or four pairs of air samples were collected on each of 2 days. The 49 valid sample sets were analyzed for iron, silicon, and zirconium. Only iron was present in sufficient concentrations to perform workplace protection factor (WPF) calculations. Individual WPF measurements ranged from 5 to 753. The geometric mean of the distribution was 119 with a lower 5th percentile value of 19. Time-weighted average WPFs (WPF _TWA ) were also calculated for each day for each worker as an estimate of the protection an individual might receive with daily respirator use. The WPF _TWA values ranged from 15 for the worker with the single WPF value of 5, to a high of 684. The distribution of WPF _TWA had a geometric mean of 120 and a lower 5th percentile of 22. Both data treatments indicate this respirator's performance was consistent with the assigned protection factor of 10 typically used for half facepiece respirators. The respirator provided adequate protection as used in this study. All contaminant concentrations inside the respirator were well below the relevant occupational exposure limits. Data collected also illustrate the dynamic nature of faceseal leakage in the workplace.

Keywords:

• filtering facepiece
• respirator performance
• WPF
• workplace protection factor

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors would like to thank the company management, the workers who volunteered to participate in the study, and the observation team for their assistance. Erik Johnson and Jeffrey Payne are also recognized for their valuable assistance with the particle sizing and SEM analyses.

Notes

^A One valid sample

^B No valid samples