Change of Gamut Size for Producing Preferred Color Appearance from 20 to 15000 lux

ABSTRACT

Numerous efforts have been made to investigate how light source color rendition affects color preference. Though the effect of light level on color appearance (known as the Hunt effect) was found in 1952, most studies investigating color preference under light sources only employed a single illuminance level and the illuminance levels were typically between 200 and 1000 lux. This article reports two psychophysical experiments that were designed to investigate how light source color rendition affected color preference across a wide range of illuminance levels, from 20 to 15,000 lux. The observers compared the color appearance of an artwork under nine nearly metameric light stimuli with a correlated color temperature (CCT) of 3000 K at different illuminance levels. These light stimuli were carefully designed to have different abilities to enhance the chroma of red and green colors, so that they had different gamut areas R_g (between 100 and 124 in Experiment 1 and between 99 and 117 in Experiment 2). It was found that the illuminance level significantly affected the observers’ judgments, with a light stimulus with a greater R_g being preferred at a lower light level. The light stimuli with an R_g beyond 100 were preferred at the light levels from 20 to 5000 lux, whereas those with an R_g around 100 were preferred at very high light levels (i.e., 10,000 and 15,000 lux). This suggested that the preference to the stimuli with an R_g beyond 100, as found in many past studies, was likely due to the relatively lower illuminance levels in comparison to the daylight illuminance levels. In addition, the calculations of the color attributes of the artwork under the preferred stimuli suggested that CIECAM02 may overestimate the effect of light level on color appearance, especially when the light level was very high, which merits further investigations.

KEYWORDS:

• Color quality
• color rendition
• color preference
• light level
• LED lighting

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Additional information

Funding

This work was funded by The Public Policy Research Funding Scheme from Policy Innovation and Co-ordination Office of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government 2017.A6.091.18A.