Situational familiarity and its relation to decision quality in ice-hockey

Abstract

Field-based observation, including helmet-mounted cameras, was employed to study pattern-matching aspects of decision making in ice-hockey. We were interested in the role of situational familiarity in decision making and decision quality. Expert and non-expert players were videotaped during competition. In retrospective interviews, prompted by the game videos, players were asked about the role that familiarity (both event and rule-based), played in their decision-process. Decision quality and decision outcome were assessed retrospectively by two expert coaches. Experts described decision-making situations as ‘familiar’ twice as often as non-experts. Although rule-based decisions were more common, only for decisions based on recognition of the event, were familiar decisions rated as better quality. This pattern-matching aspect of the decision-making process and its relationship to decision quality has implications for theories of decision making in dynamic sports.

Keywords:

• expert performance
• pattern recognition
• decision making
• sport

Acknowledgements

The final author would like to acknowledge financial assistance from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.