Social influence and children's event recall and suggestibility

Abstract

The present study sheds light on interactions between cognitive and social factors affecting children's memory performance and suggestibility in event recall tasks. We examined 251 children, aged 8, 9 and 10 years, and applied a well-known paradigm from social psychology, that is, the social influence of misleading questions was experimentally manipulated through the presence and answering behaviour of an adult confederate. Children's answers about the content of a previously watched film to misleading questions, their accurate statements in their subsequent free recall, as well as performance in a recognition test were assessed. The design also included two control conditions, one in which children answered misleading questions without an adult confederate, and a second one in which no misleading interview was administered but only free recall and recognition. The results document large recall and suggestibility differences between the conditions. Participants of the strong social influence condition answered more conformably to misleading questions and showed a larger effect of memory contagion in recognition. Moreover, there were strong age-related increases in the ability to rely on one's own recollection rather than parroting the confederate's answers. Strong social influence also differentially affected the occurrence of false statements in free recall and errors in the recognition test depending on the children's age.

Notes

This study is associated to the research project “Children's Event Memory and Suggestibility” of the first author and Wolfgang Schneider, which is financially supported by the German Research Foundation (FOR 261/2 – 3). We would like to thank Christian Walter-Klose, Monique Guillot, Karin Scheuermann and Nelly Moga for their help with conducting the interviews as well as the participating and co-operating schools, teachers and students.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Claudia M Roebers

This study is associated to the research project “Children's Event Memory and Suggestibility” of the first author and Wolfgang Schneider, which is financially supported by the German Research Foundation (FOR 261/2 – 3). We would like to thank Christian Walter-Klose, Monique Guillot, Karin Scheuermann and Nelly Moga for their help with conducting the interviews as well as the participating and co-operating schools, teachers and students.