Abstract
Financial ratios have recently reached unprecedented levels and despite price falls remain at ahistoric levels. This is at odds with the theoretical present value model. Whilst, several researchers have attempted to reconcile theory and data using fractional integration and nonlinear techniques, an alternate view is that such ratios do not revert to a single point but exhibit a time-variation in their level. This article, tests for and supports, the belief that financial ratios exhibit structural breaks, or level shifts, through time. As such, the present value model does not hold exactly, but needs to accommodate such shifts. This may also explain apparent contradictory findings in long-horizon return predictability regressions performed over different sample periods.
Notes
1 For examples of fractional integration behaviour see, Caporale and Gil-Alana (Citation2004; Cuñado et al. (Citation2005) and Koustas and Serletis (Citation2005), while for examples, of nonlinear dynamics behaviour see, Bohl and Siklos (Citation2004), Psaradakis et al. (Citation2004) and Kanas (Citation2005). Furthermore, it has recently been shown (Byers and Peel,Citation2003), that both fractional linear and nonlinear dynamics can arise from the same process.
Caporale
,
GM
and
Gil-Alana
,
LA
.
2004
.
Fractional cointegration and tests of present value models
.
Review of Financial Economics
,
13
:
245
–
58
.
Cuñado
,
J
,
Gil-Alana
,
LA
and
Perez de Gracia
,
F
.
2005
.
A test for rational bubbles in the NASDAQ stock index: A fractionally integrated approach
.
Journal of Banking and Finance
,
29
:
2633
–
54
.
Koustas
,
Z
and
Serletis
,
A
.
2005
.
Rational bubbles or persistent deviations from market fundamentals
.
Journal of Banking and Finance
,
29
:
2523
–
39
.
Bohl
,
MT
and
Siklos
,
PL
.
2004
.
The present value model of US stock prices redux: A new testing strategy and some vidence
.
Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance
,
44
:
208
–
23
.
Psaradakis
,
Z
,
Sola
,
M
and
Spagnolo
,
F
.
2004
.
On Markov error-correction models, with an application to stock prices and dividends
.
Journal of Applied Econometrics
,
19
:
69
–
88
.
Kanas
,
A
.
2005
.
Non-linearity in the stock price-dividend relation
.
Journal of International Money and Finance
,
24
:
583
–
606
.
Byers
,
JD
and
Peel
,
DA
.
2003
.
Another example of a non-linear time series with misleading linear properties
.
Applied Economics Letters
,
10
:
47
–
51
.
Bai
,
J
and
Perron
,
P
.
1998
.
Estimating and testing linear models with multiple structural changes
.
Econometrica
,
66
:
47
–
68
.
Bai
,
J
and
Perron
,
P
.
2003a
.
Computation and analysis of multiple structural change models
.
Journal of Applied Econometrics
,
18
:
1
–
22
.
Bai
,
J
and
Perron
,
P
.
2003b
.
Critical values in multiple structural change tests
.
Econometrics Journal
,
6
:
72
–
8
.