Word chunk frequencies affect the processing of pronominal object-relative clauses

Abstract

We present experimental support for the view that fine-grained statistical information may play a crucial role in the processing of centre-embedded linguistic structure. Using both offline and online methods, we show that the processing of pronominal object-relative clauses is influenced by the frequency of co-occurrence of the word combinations (chunks) forming the clause. We use materials that are controlled for capacity-based factors that have been previously shown to influence comprehension of relative clauses. The results suggest that, other factors being equal, the frequency of the word chunk forming the clause affects processing difficulty. Analyses of the data indicate that the results cannot be explained by differential access to individual lexical items. Following recent constructivist approaches, we argue that frequency of co-occurrence influences the chunking mechanism by which multiword sequences may become fused into processing units that are easier to access.

We are grateful to Michael Spivey and Thomas Farmer for helpful discussions on this work. We also wish to thank Tessa Warren and an anonymous reviewer for providing insightful comments and suggestions regarding an earlier version of this manuscript.