Reciprocal Journalism

Abstract

Reciprocity, a defining feature of social life, has long been considered a key component in the formation and perpetuation of vibrant communities. In recent years, scholars have applied the concept to understanding the social dynamics of online communities and social media. Yet, the function of and potential for reciprocity in (digital) journalism has yet to be examined. Drawing on a structural theory of reciprocity, this essay introduces the idea of reciprocal journalism: a way of imagining how journalists might develop more mutually beneficial relationships with audiences across three forms of exchange—direct, indirect, and sustained types of reciprocity. The perspective of reciprocal journalism highlights the shortcomings of most contemporary approaches to audience engagement and participatory journalism. It situates journalists as community-builders who, particularly in online spaces, might more readily catalyze patterns of reciprocal exchange—directly with readers, indirectly among community members, and repeatedly over time—that, in turn, may contribute to the development of greater trust, connectedness, and social capital. For scholars, reciprocal journalism provides a new analytical framework for evaluating the journalist–audience relationship, suggesting a set of diagnostic questions for studying the exchange of benefits as journalists and audiences increasingly engage one another in networked environments. We introduce this concept in the context of community journalism but also discuss its relevance for journalism broadly.

KEYWORDS:

• audience engagement
• community journalism
• news audiences
• online communities
• participatory journalism
• reciprocal journalism
• reciprocity
• social media

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors wish to thank guest editor Sue Robinson for her helpful guidance on this essay.

Notes

1. One exception is the work of Barger and Barney (2004), who suggest that journalists and citizens have an ethical, reciprocal obligation to distribute and act upon information for the democratic good.

2. See https://www.facebook.com/houstonherald.