Northwest Passages: Framing by Local, National and Public Media in Canada's Arctic

ABSTRACT

During the summer of 2016, the largest cruise ship ever to transit the Northwest Passage traveled through the Canadian Arctic, carrying more than 1,600 passengers and crew. That event resulted in a tremendous influx of tourists, considering the population the entire territory of Nunavut is only 36,000.

This study examines how local media played a critical role in representing local community values in coverage of that remarkable cruise. The complete English Canadian textual coverage of the voyage by three media segments was compiled: local media, national media, and a national public broadcaster. A framing analysis revealed significant differences in how each of the three media segments frames the news. Local media placed significantly more emphasis on political, bureaucratic, and environmental frames than did national media, yet used human interest frames at about the same frequency. Furthermore, local media's selection of frames was more diverse than was evident in coverage from national media or the public broadcaster.

In addition, the study reveals that the public broadcaster frames stories independently of local and national media, a finding which serves to emphasize the distinct value of each media segment in forming complete coverage of this story.

KEYWORDS:

• Arctic
• community journalism
• community media
• framing
• journalism
• local news
• national news
• public broadcaster

Correction Statement

This article has been republished with minor changes. These changes do not impact the academic content of the article.

Acknowledgements

Alycia Mutual was associated with this research project in its initial phase. I’m greatly appreciative of her contributions to the project, including early collaboration in project conceptualization, and compilation of the news articles.

Disclosure Statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes

1 This study did not include stories published in Inuktitut syllabics or French.

2 Unfortunately, no Crystal Serenity coverage from APTN could be found.

3 An α level of 0.05 was used for all statistical tests in this paper.