Professional characteristics of the Jewish guild in the Muslim world: Thessaloniki dockers at the end of the Ottoman era

Abstract

This article focuses upon the Jewish dockers of Ottoman Thessaloniki. At the beginning of the twentieth century, the loading and unloading of merchandise between ships and docks in the port of Thessaloniki was dominated by Jewish manpower. This dominance should be considered, first of all, in relation to the pre-industrial regulations of the Ottoman labour market. Work on the Thessaloniki docks was operated by veteran guilds of Jewish labourers (registered according to ethnic or family affinity) who managed to distribute all the specific spheres of work among themselves (the gedik principle). They demonstrated a high standard of professionalism (the hisba value) and created a well-organized welfare system. These outdated regulations still maintained their validity in spite of the legal abolition of the guild system (1860), and the emergence of the industrial labour market. The second reason for Jewish prosperity derived from the political turmoil of that period. Against the background of the Macedonian Question and the Western semi-colonization of Macedonia, the Jewish dockers should be seen as part of an ethnic group which clearly defined itself as supporting the preservation of the Ottoman regime in the Southern Balkans. As such, the Ottoman regime counted them as a loyal and useful element in maintaining its interests in the docks, and in exchange came to their aid when modernization of the infrastructures might have thrown many of them out of work in the port.

Keywords:

• Ottoman-Thessaloniki
• Muslim guilds
• Jewish dockers
• Greek dockers
• gedik
• hisba
• Macedonian Question
• Western colonialism
• industrial labour market

Notes

  1. Sorkin, ‘The Port Jew’, 87–90.

  2. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 72–75.

  3. Klier, ‘A Port, not a Shtetl’, 176.

  4. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 72.

  5. Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul Blunt on the Trade of Salonica for the Year 1873’, Vol. LXVI (1874), The Academic Library at London School of Economics (LSE); Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul-General Blunt on the Trade and Commerce of Macedonia and the Port of Salonica for the Years 1879, 1880, 1881’, Vol. LXXII (1883), LSE.

  6. Brodo, ‘The Porters’, 242–3; Uziel, The White Tower, 9–21.

  7. Davies et al., Dock Workers .

  8. Chalcraft, ‘The End of Guilds’, 338.

  9. Yildirim, ‘Ottoman Guilds’, 2–3.

 10. Murphey, art. ‘Sinf’; Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 73.

 11. Faroqhi, ‘Understanding Ottoman Guilds’, 3.

 12. Ghazaleh, ‘Organising Labour’, 235. For further reading: Cohen, The Guilds; Quataert, Social Disintegration ; Faroqhi, Towns and Townsmen , idem, ‘Merchant Networks’, 92–169.

 13. Baer, ‘Monopolies and Restrictive Practices’; idem, ‘The Administrative’.

 14. Faroqhi, ‘Understanding Ottoman Guilds’, 9–10.

 15. Quataert, Ottoman Manufacturing ; idem, ‘The Port Worker Guilds’; idem, ‘A Provisional Report’.

 16. Faroqhi, ‘Textile Production’, 67–71, 90–92, Quataert, Ottoman Manufacturing, 98.

 17. Hadar, ‘Jewish Tobacco Workers’, 129–30.

 18. Van Voss and Van der Linden, ‘Dockers’ Configurations', 764–6.

 19. Baer, ‘Monopolies and Restrictive Practices’; idem, ‘The Administrative’.

 20. Baer, ‘Monopolies and Restrictive Practices’, 155.

 21. Brodo, ‘The Porters’, 243.

 22. Baer, ‘Monopolies and Restrictive Practices’, 155–6; Bruce, ‘Ethnicity’, 666.

 23. Yildirim, ‘Ottoman Guilds,’ 14.

 24. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 76.

 25. Eunjeong, Guild Dynamics, 148–51.

 26. Quataert, ‘The Port Workers Guilds’, 100.

 27. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 76.

 28. Baer, ‘Monopolies and Restrictive Practices’, 162–5.

 29. Faroqhi, ‘Ottoman Craftsmen’, 87–8.

 30. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 83.

 31. Faroqhi, ‘Ottoman Craftsmen’, 87.

 32. Pamuk, ‘Institutional Change’, 230, 236–9.

 33. Wallerstein and Kasaba, ‘Incorporation’, 338–9.

 34. Baer, Egyptian Guilds, 91.

 35. The Van district is located in Eastern Turkey between the Lake of Van and the Iranian border.

 36. White, Three Years , 325.

 37. Baer, ‘The Administrative’, 28–35.

 38. Baer, ‘The Administrative’ 33–36; Quataert, Ottoman Manufacturing , 8.

 39. Unluhisarcikli, ‘Vocational Training’, 118.

 40. Faroqhi et al., An Economic and Social History of the Ottoman Empire. Vol. 2., 761–2.

 41. Quataert, ‘The Workers’, 60–1.

 42. Sivi means liquid in Turkish. This may be a general reference to a market in which certain merchandise was estimated according to liquid measures (such as oil), but this type of merchandise was not sold in shops in the Sivi area.

 43. Ginio, ‘Migrants and Workers’, 138–9.

 44. Gerber, Economy and Society , 114.

 45. Ginio, ‘Migrants and Workers’, 113–24.

 46. Gerber, Economy and Society, 36–7.

 47. Molho, Oι Eβραíoι [The Jews].

 48. Hadar, ‘Jewish Tobacco Workers’, 127.

 49. Meron, ‘The Demographic Development’, 32.

 50. Quataert, ‘The Port Workers Guild’, 96–100.

 51. Rozen, ‘Fishermen's Guilds’, 74.

 52. Sugar, Southeastern Europe, 80; Inalcik, ‘Capital Formation’, 106–7, 138–40.

 53. Uziel, ‘The White Tower’, 40.

 54. Taplin, The Dockers Union , 2.

 55. Johnson, ‘Criminality’, 720–1; Green, ‘The Work Process’, 570–1; De Vries, ‘The Construction’, 687, 692.

 56. Green, ‘The Work Process’, 570.

 57. Green, ‘The Work Process’ 575–7.

 58. Gounaris, Steam over Macedonia; Hastaoglou, Eντάξη τoυ A′ και B′ Πρoβλήτα [The Integration of Piers A and B], 1–53

 59. Taplin, ‘The History’, 443–4.

 60. Lederer, Port Terminal Operation 5–8.

 61. Lederer, Port Terminal Operation 43.

 62. Svend, ‘Danish Dock Workers’, 570–3.

 63. Nehama, Iστoρíα [The History], 1393.

 64. Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul-General Blunt on the Trade and Commerce of Macedonia and the Port of Salonica for the Years 1879, 1880, 1881’, Vol. LXXII (1883), LSE.

 65. Consular Report, ‘Report on Trade and Commerce of the Consular District of Salonica for the Years 1891–92 by Consul-General Blunt, Moυσϵío Mακϵδoνικoέ Aγώνα, Θϵσσαλoνíκη’ [Museum of Macedonian Struggle in Thessaloniki], British Foreign Office section.

 66. Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul-General Blunt on the Trade and Commerce of Macedonia and the Port of Salonica for the Years 1879, 1880, 1881’, Vol. LXXII (1883), LSE; Taplin, ‘The History’, 444.

 67. Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul Blunt on the Trade of Salonica for the Year 1873’, Vol. LXVI (1874), LSE.

 68. Parliamentary Papers, Accounts and Papers, ‘Report by Consul Blunt on the Trade of Salonica for the Year 1873’, Vol. LXVI (1874), LSE

 69. Meron, ‘Jewish Entrepreneurship’, 275–7.

 70. Bourla, ‘The Jews’, 212–3.

 71. Meron, ‘The Jewish Economy’, 37.

 72. Blaisdell, European Financial Control, 128–9; Pamuk, The Ottoman Empire, 3–10.

 73. Quataert, ‘Πρώτoι Kαπνoí’ [The first smoke], 192; idem, ‘A Provisional Report’, 462.

 74. Idem, ‘Some General Factors’, 159.

 75. Hastaoglou, Eντάξη τoυ A′ και B′ Πρoβλήτα [The Integration of Piers A and B], 35–42.

 76. ‘Toπικά Zητήματα [local issues] Eϕημϵρíς των Bαλκανíων’ [The Newspaper of the Balkans], 23 November 1923, 1

 77. Quataert, ‘The Ottoman Boycott’, 135–7.

 78. Gounaris, Steam over Macedonia, 171.

 79. Bulgaria declared independence at the beginnings of October and Greece renewed its struggle for further influence over Crete.

 80. Quataert, ‘The Ottoman Boycott’, 135–7; Gounaris, Steam over Macedonia, 171

 81. Hacisalihoğlu, ‘The Young Turk Revolution’, 165–82; Rozen, The Last Ottoman Century , 151–2; Ilicak, ‘Eβραïκóς Σoσιαλισμóς’ [Jewish Socialism], 50.

 82. Meron, ‘The Jewish Economy’, 25.

 83. Meron, ‘The Jewish Economy’ 37.

 84. Arditi, ‘The Words of Samuel’, 51–2.

 85. Levy, ‘The Jews’, 14–9; Quataert, The Ottoman Empire , 5–6.

 86. For obvious reasons, we decided not to give full details about this docker, but only his personal name and the first letter of his surname.

 87. ‘Πρωτóτυπoς Kλoπή ϵις τo Tϵλωνϵíoν’ [Original Theft in the Custom House], To Φως [The Light], 8 April 1915.

 88. Johnson, ‘Criminality’.

 89. Johnson, ‘Criminality’ 725.

 90. Johnson, ‘Criminality’ 720–1.

 91. Johnson, ‘Criminality’ 724–6.

 92. Baer, ‘The Administrative’, 44–5.

 93. Rofe, ‘Charity Fund’, 623–5.

 94. Rofe, ‘Charity Fund’ 625.

 95. Brodo, ‘The Porters’, 243.

 96. Baer, ‘The Administrative’, 44.

 97. ‘To Λιμάνι της Θϵς(νíκης’ [The Port of Thessaloniki], Tαχυδρóμoς τoυ Boρϵíoυ Eλλάδoς [The Postman of North Greece], 29 May 1929, 3.

 98. ‘Mϵγάλαι ′Eρϵυναι της Mακϵδoνíας, τo Λιμάνι ′Eγϵινα Kóλασις Πϵíνας και Δυστυχíας’ [The Big Researches of Macedonia. The Port has become a Hell of Hunger and Misery], Mακϵδoνíα [Macedonia], 5 September 1933, 1.

 99. ‘Mϵγάλαι ′Eρϵυναι της Mακϵδoνíας, τo Λιμάνι ′Eγϵινα Kóλασις Πϵíνας και Δυστυχíας’ [The Big Researches of Macedonia. The Port has become a Hell of Hunger and Misery], Mακϵδoνíα [Macedonia], 5 September 1933 4 September 1933, 1; ‘Mια Mατιά στo Eργατικó Kíνημα. Mϵ Toυς Eργάτϵς και τα Σωματϵíα των’ [A Glance at the Labor Movement. With the Laborers and their Unions], Eϕημϵρíς των Bαλκανíων [The Newspaper of the Balkans], 5 November 1934, 1.

100. ‘Mια Mατιά στo Eργατικó Kíνημα. Mϵ Toυς Eργάτϵς και τα Σωματϵíα των’ [A Glance at the Labor Movement. With the Laborers and their Unions], Eϕημϵρíς των Bαλκανíων [The Newspaper of the Balkans], 16 November 1934, 1.

101. ‘To Λιμάνι της Θϵς(νíκης’ [The Port of Thessaloniki], Tαχυδρóμoς τoυ Boρϵíoυ Eλλάδoς [The Postman of North Greece], 29 May 1929, 3.