Impact on plant communities by white-tailed deer in Mississippi, USA

Abstract

Background: The abundance of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) in the eastern United States has escalated during the twentieth century, potentially impacting plant communities.

Methods: We measured understorey plant cover and biomass five years after excluding deer from mature forests of three ecological regions in Mississippi, USA. We extended the significance of P values to 0.10 to detect developing impacts.

Results: Deer impacts were limited and varied by ecological region. We recorded 151 species in cover transects. Consistent exclosure treatment effects were detected in two regions where there was greater cover of two deer forages and less cover of three non-forages. Species richness was greater in exclosures in one region, but otherwise species richness and diversity indices did not differ. We recorded 127 species in biomass quadrats. Exclosure treatment effects on biomass were inconsistent. Out of five species with significant differences, three had more biomass in controls, including two deer forages. Except for greater total biomass in controls of one region, there were no differences by growth form or total vegetation for canopy coverage or biomass. Ordination of community canopy cover demonstrated similarity of paired exclosure and controls.

Conclusions: Exclosure treatment effects on canopy cover and species richness in two regions indicated limited negative impacts from deer foraging. A time frame of more than five years may be required for exclusion to allow recovery of vegetation, even with relatively open canopies and a long growing season.

Keywords:

• browsing
• exclosure
• herbivory
• regime shift
• southeastern United States

Acknowledgements

Major funding for this project was provided by the Mississippi Department of Wildlife, Fisheries, and Parks with Federal Aid under Wildlife Restoration Project W-48, Study 64. The USDA Forest Service, Weyerhaeuser Company and Anderson-Tulley Company provided additional funding. USDA Forest Service staff provided assistance for exclosure maintenance and we thank S. Edwards, J. Fogarty, P. Jones and A. Pearse for their aid. We thank three anonymous reviewers for their suggestions. This is Mississippi State University Forest and Wildlife Research Center publication WF374.

Supplemental data

Supplemental data for this article can be accessed here.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Phillip Hanberry

Phillip Hanberry is a GIS analyst at Missouri Resource Assessment Partnership.

Brice B. Hanberry

Brice Hanberry is a forest researcher at the University of Missouri.

Stephen Demarais

Stephen Demarais is a large mammal ecologist and the Dale Arner Distinguished Professor at Mississippi State University.

Bruce D. Leopold

Bruce D. Leopold is a carnivore ecologist and the Sharp Distinguished Professor at Mississippi State University.

Jackie Fleeman

Jackie Fleeman is a regional supervisor of wildlife management areas for the Mississippi Department of Wildlife, Fisheries, and Parks.