Anterior cingulate cortex and intuitive bias detection during number conservation

Abstract

Children’s number conservation is often biased by misleading intuitions but the precise nature of these conservation errors is not clear. A key question is whether children detect that their erroneous conservation judgment is unwarranted. The present study reanalyzed available fMRI data to test the implication of the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) in this detection process. We extracted mean BOLD (Blood Oxygen Level Dependent) signal values in an independently defined ACC region of interest (ROI) during presentation of classic and control number conservation problems. In classic trials, an intuitively cued visuospatial response conflicted with the correct conservation response, whereas this conflict was not present in the control trials. Results showed that ACC activation increased when solving the classic conservation problems. Critically, this increase did not differ between participants who solved the classic problems correctly (i.e., so-called conservers) and incorrectly (i.e., so-called non-conservers). Additional control analyses of inferior and lateral prefrontal ROIs showed that the group of conservers did show stronger activation in the right inferior frontal gyrus and right lateral middle frontal gyrus. In line with recent behavioral findings, these data lend credence to the hypothesis that even non-conserving children detect the biased nature of their judgment. The key difference between conservers and non-conservers seems to lie in a differential recruitment of inferior and lateral prefrontal regions associated with inhibitory control.

Keywords:

• Bias detection
• Number
• Cingulate

We would like to thank our colleagues at LaPsyDE for their help in running this study, especially Arlette Pineau, Céline Lanoë, Sandrine Rossi, and Nicolas Poirel.

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Additional information

Funding

Preparation of this manuscript was supported by the French National Research Agency [grant number ANR-12-JSH2-0007-01].