ABSTRACT
This research explored the social responsibility (SR) attitudes of engineering students with respect to their self-reported religious beliefs and the religious affiliation of their institution. The study measured SR attitudes using 50 items on a 7-point Likert metric. Over 1900 responses were received in spring 2014 from undergraduate engineering students attending 5 Christian-affiliated and 12 secular universities. On average, students attending Christian-affiliated institutions had more positive SR attitudes than students attending secular institutions. However, an individual's religious beliefs were more important than the institution in predicting SR attitudes. Students who stated that they were very active in an organized religion had more positive attitudes toward SR than students who self-characterized as spiritual, who were in turn more positive than students less active in their religious preference, indifferent, or atheist. College courses were reported to have impacted views of SR by 42–74% of the students attending various institutions; among these students, 32% of the students attending Christian-affiliated institutions indicated that religion-related courses had an impact. The results indicate a need to further explore how religious beliefs impact SR beliefs, toward the goal of more effectively encouraging all engineering students – religious or not – to recognize the importance of socially responsible engineering.
Acknowledgments
Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
Notes
1Zandvoort “Editors' Overview”, 2013, p. 1414.
2ABET, Criteria for Accrediting Engineering Programs; 2013; ASCE, Civil Engineering Body of Knowledge, 2008; Herkert, Social, Ethical, and Policy Implications of Engineering, 1999; NAE, Educating the Engineer of 2020, 2005.
3Munoz and Mitcham, “Chapter 3 – Humanitarian Engineering,” 2012; Roeser, “Emotional Engineers,” 2012.
4Bierhoff and Rohmann, “Altruistic Personality,” 2004; Riley, Engineering and Social Justice, 2008; Segal, “Social Empathy,” 2011; Steele et al., “The Role of Altruistic Behavior,” 2008.
5Bielefeldt and Canney, “Impacts of Service-Learning,” 2014; Canney and Bielefeldt, “Differences in Engineering Students’ Views,” 2015; Canney and Bielefeldt, “Gender Differences in the Social Responsibility Attitudes of Engineering Students,” 2015.
6Perkins, “Student Religiosity and Social Justice Concerns,” 1992; Todd, “Religious Participation and Social Justice,” 2010.
7Angelidis and Ibrahim, “An Exploratory Study of the Impact of Degree of Religiousness,” 2004; Brammer et al., “Religion and Attitudes to Corporate Social Responsibility,” 2007; Ramasamy et al., “Consumer Support for Corporate Social Responsibility,” 2010.
8Conroy and Emerson, “Business Ethics and Religion,” 2004; Parboteeah et al., “Ethics and Religion,” 2008; Solihu and Ambali, “Dissolving the Engineering Moral Dilemmas,” 2011.
9Mencken and Fitz, “Image of God and Community Volunteering,” 2013; Ozorak, “Love of God and Neighbor,” 2003; Paston et al., “Volunteering and the Dimensions of Religiosity,” 2014.
10Bradley, “The Interconnection Between Religious Fundamentalism,” 2009; Duriez, “Are Religious People Nicer People?” 2004; Francis et al., “Religious Diversity, Empathy, and God Images,” 2012; Huber and MacDonald, “An Investigation of the Relations,” 2012; Khan et al., “Muslim Attitudes Toward Religion,” 2005; Markstrom et al., “Caring and Helping in Adolescence,” 2010.
11Davidson and Garcia, “Welcoming the Stranger,” 2014, p. 3.
12Angelidis and Ibrahim, “An Exploratory Study of the Impact of Degree of Religiousness,” 2004.
13Partoteeah et al., “Ethics and Religion,” 2008.
14Chen and Tang, “The Bright and Dark Sides of Religiosity,” 2013.
15Hunsberger, “Religion and Prejudice,” 1995; Kossowska and Sekerdej, “Searching for Certainty,” 2015.
16Canney and Bielefeldt, “Examining the Correlation between Religion and Social Responsibility,” 2013.
17Kosmin and Keysar, “Religious, Spiritual and Secular,” 2013.
18Rockenbach et al., Engaging Worldview, 2014.
19Berry et al., “Measuring Religiosity/Spirituality in Diverse Religious Groups,” 2011; Huber, “Religious Belief, Religious Participation, and Social Policy Attitudes,” 2005; McAndrew and Voas, “Measuring Religiosity Using Surveys,” 2011.
20Chen and Tang, “The Bright and Dark Sides of Religiosity,” 2013; Nasel and Haynes, “Spiritual and Religious Dimensions Scale,” 2005; Tiliopoulos et al., “The Means and Ends of Religiosity,” 2007.
21Lindholm et al., “The Spiritual Questing,” 2006.
22Lindholm et al., “The Spiritual Questing,” 2006, p. 509.
23Meijknecht and Van Drongelen, “How is the Spirituality of Engineering Taught or Conveyed?” 2004.
24Hess, “Global Portrayals of Engineering Ethics Education,” 2013.
25Engineers Dedicated to a Better Tomorrow, The Online Guide to Engineering Schools, 2012.
26Rawlinson, Religious Reality, 2010.
27Catholic Church, Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2000.
28Brammer et al., “Religion and Attitudes to Corporate Social Responsibility,” 2007; Lin, Religion & Corporate Social Responsibility, 2013.
29Schaffer, “Service-Learning in Christian Higher Education,” 2004.
30Comegys, “The Impact of Religiously Affiliated Universities and Courses in Ethics,” 2010; Gonyea and Kuh, “Independent Colleges and Student Engagement,” 2006.
31Canney and Bielefeldt, “A Framework for the Development of Social Responsibility in Engineers,” 2015.
32Schwartz, “Normative Influences on Altruism,” 1977; Schwartz and Howard, “Helping and Cooperation,” 1982; Shiarella et al., “Development and Construct Validity of Scores,” 2000.
33Graham and Haidt, “Beyond Beliefs,” 2010; Habito and Inaba, The Practice of Altruism, 2006; Saroglou, “Religion, Spirituality, and Altruism,” 2013.
34Ramsey, “A Curricular Framework,” 1989; Ramsey, “The Science Education Reform Movement,” 1993.
35Delve et al., “Promoting Values Development through Community Service,” 1990.
36Carnegie, Carnegie Classifications Data File, 2014.
37Association of Jesuit College & Universities, Jesuit Higher Education, 2014.
38Zandvoort et al., “Editors’ Overview,” 2013, p. 1416.
39Canney and Bielefeldt, “Validity and Reliability Evidence for the Engineering Professional Responsibility Assessment Tool,” in press.
40Canney and Bielefeldt, “A Framework for the Development of Social Responsibility in Engineers,” 2015.
41Canney and Bielefeldt, “Validity and Reliability Evidence for the Engineering Professional Responsibility Assessment Tool,” in press.
42Lugo, The Decline of Institutional Religion, 2013.
43Nasel and Haynes, “Spiritual and Religious Dimensions Scale,” 2005; Tiliopoulos et al., “The Means and Ends of Religiosity,” 2007.
44Sax et al., “Assessing Response Rates and Nonresponse Bias,” 2006.
45Creative Research Systems, Sample Size Calculator, 2012.
46Bielefeldt and Canney, “Humanitarian Aspirations of Engineering Students,” 2015.
47Dalecki et al., “Sample Non-Response Bias and Aggregate Benefits in Contingent Valuation,” 1993; Sax et al., “Assessing Response Rates and Nonresponse Bias,” 2006.
48Creswell, Educational Research, 2005.
49Kallenberg, “Engineering as a Christian Vocation,” 2011.
50VanAntwerp et al., “Examining Calling as a Motivator in Career Decisions,” 2011.
51Ammerman, “Spiritual but Not Religious?” 2013; Zinnbauer et al., “Religion and Spirituality,” 1997.
52Eagan et al., The American Freshman, 2013.
53Canney and Bielefeldt, “Differences in Engineering Students’ Views,” 2015; Canney and Bielefeldt, “Gender Differences in the Social Responsibility Attitudes of Engineering Students,” 2015.
54Canney and Bielefeldt, “Examining the Correlation between Religion and Social Responsibility,” 2013; Canney, Assessing Engineering Students’ Understanding of Personal and Professional Social Responsibility, 2013.
55Ro et al., “Between-college Effects,” 2013.
56Rawlinson, Religious Reality, 2010; Catholic Church, Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2000.
57Eagan et al., The American Freshman, 2013.
58Brammer et al., “Religion and Attitudes to Corporate Social Responsibility,” 2007; Lin, Religion & Corporate Social Responsibility, 2013.
59Lugo, The Decline of Institutional Religion, 2013.