Abstract
This community note provides a summarised version of a peer review of a thesis written by Alfonso Acuna in 2007 as part of his Master's study at the University of Amsterdam. The peer review took the form of an online roundtable discussion between Valerie Brown, Nancy White, Patrick Lambe and Alfonso Acuna. Alfonso Acuna's paper was published in the May 2010 issue of this journal.
Guard: Do you intend to resist?
Portos: Oh don't be so stupid, of course we intend to resist! Just give us a minute! [To his comrades:] Five of them, three of us. Hardly seems fair.
Aramis: Maybe we should give them a chance to surrender?
D'Artagnan: Excuse me, there's four of us.
Aramis: It isn't your fight. You're not a Musketeer.
D'Artagnan: I may not wear the tunic, but I believe I have the heart of a Musketeer.
Aramis: You got a name, boy?
D'Artagnan: D'Artagnan.
Portos: Athos, Portos, Aramis. Everyone acquainted? [The four whirl around and unsheath their swords.] NOW, we are ready to resist you!
(adapted from The Three Musketeers film, 1973)