![Sample our Politics & International Relations journals, sign in here to start your FREE access for 14 days]({"type":"image" , "src" : "/sda/5947/TOC-Subject-Sample-2021-Politics-International-Relations.jpg"})
Abstract
This paper highlights the importance of local context, the timing of development, and the trade-off between growth and equity in shaping strategies of development. We compare the ‘Guangdong Model’ and ‘Chongqing Model’ of development, two alternative strategies of development in contemporary China. The former emphasized market-oriented reforms, international linkages, and a relatively open environment for civil society; the latter emphasized state-led initiatives to produce economic growth, reduce economic inequality, and reprise traditional practices of the Chinese Communist Party. This paper contrasts the ideological aspects of the two models, along with the political strategies of the leaders most associated with them and the results of their policies. Although China remains a one-party political regime, the Guangdong and Chongqing models are also the most recent manifestation of different localities pursuing different economic models. Rather than providing alternative models for China’s future development, they reveal trade-offs between economic and social goals and how best to achieve them. Their experiences also have implications for other developing countries trying to balance competing developmental goals.
Notes
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
Notes on contributors
Chunhua Chen is an Assistant Professor, Department of English and International Studies, Beijing Foreign Studies University, 2 W 3rd Ring Rd N, Haidian Qu, China ([email protected]).
Bruce Dickson is a Professor of Political Science and International Affairs, George Washington University, 1957 E Street, NW, Washington, DC 20052 ([email protected]).
Notes
1 Joshua Cooper Ramo, The Beijing Consensus.
2 Trinidad, “Goodbye Washington Consensus”; Stiglitz, “Is There a Post-Washington Consensus”; Lin, “The Washington Consensus Revisited.”
3 Xi, “President Xi Jinping.”
4 BBC, “China Economic Growth Slowest in 25 years.”
5 Jacques, When China Rules the World; Bell, The China Model.
6 Dirlik, “The Idea.”
7 Tang, “China: A not Very Successful Developmental State”; Zhang, “No China Model yet.”
8 Wang was Party Secretary of Guangdong province from December 1, 2007 to December 18, 2012; Bo was Party Secretary of Chongqing City from November 30, 2007 to March 15, 2012. See “Resume of Comrade Wang Yang, “cpcnews.cn, March 2013, http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64192/106076/6604586.html and “Resume of Comrade Bo Xilai,” Xinhuanet.com, October 22, 2007. Accessed June 3, 2013. http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2007-10/22/content_6924941.htm. Accessed June 3, 2013.
9 Qu, “Guangdong Moshi yu Chongqing Moshi bijiao.”
10 Chen, “Bo Xilai: Chongqing zhejinian.”
11 Xiao, “Yanbianzhong de Guangdong Moshi.”
12 Xinhua News Agency, “Zhonggong Chongqing shiwei.”
13 Wang Yang: Yi jingji.
14 Gu and Suo, “Zhonggong Guangdong shengwei.”
15 Chen, “Bo Xilai: the Guiding Principle.”
16 The Nanfang Media Group’s fight for press freedom in China culminated in January 2013, when its employees mounted a rare protest over alleged government censoring of the new year editorial of Southern Weekly, which is a subsidiary of the Group. http://cn.wsj.com/gb/20130109/bch171120.asp. After that episode, the paper’s coverage and editorial line became less distinctive. Many saw this as a taming of the Group’s editorial independence. But according to a journalist who formerly worked at the paper, it is not that Southern Weekly became more mainstream, but that other papers became more like Southern Weekly. Private conversation with one of the authors, March 2014.
17 Chin, “Zuowan Xin Jing Bao jiujing fashengle shenme.”
18 Xiao, “The Evolving Guangdong Model.”
19 Chan, “Chongqing and Guangdong.”
20 Xiao, “The Evolving Guangdong Model.”
21 See Zhu and Lin, “Guangdong Conducted the First Public Hearing.”
22 State Council of China, “Rules on Open Government Information.”
23 People’s Government of Guangzhou, “Guangzhoushi guizhang zhiding gongzhong canyu banfa.”
24 He, “Guangzhou wangshang gongkai.”
25 Xiao, “The Evolving Guangdong Model.”
26 Liu, “Wang Yang shuaixian chuifan wuhui wangmin.”
27 “Xu Shaohua zai diwuci wangyou.”
28 Liu, “Wang Yang shuaixian chuifan wuhui wangmin.”
29 Wu, “Wang Yang: Fangman jiaobu buke.”
30 Lan and Zhang, “Wang Yang zhichi gonghui zhixuan.”
31 Gobel and Ong, “Social Unrest in China.”
32 Cai, “Power Structure and Regime Resilience.”
33 Richburg, “Guangdong Protests Could Alter.”
34 Hong, “Guangdong Zhengfu Kuanjin.”
35 Chan, “Chongqing and Guangdong.”
36 Lin, “Bo Xilai Dahei Shou’an Qiyejia Li Qiang.”
37 Cartier and Tomba, “Symbolic Cities and the ‘Cake Debate.’”
38 Stockmann, Media Commercialization.
39 Zhang, “Chongqing Weishi Tingbo Shangye Guanggao.”
40 Ji, “Hongse Weishi Jingjizhang.”
41 Ling, “Deputy Bo Xilai: Chongqing Satellite.”
42 Deng and Li, “Despite Wine Commercial.”
43 Xia, “Chongqing Qingchu Gaosulu.”
44 “Lianhe Zaobao: Chongqing Shangye.
45 Polanyi, The Great Transformation.
46 Chan, “Chongqing and Guangdong.”
47 Wang Yang Said.
48 Chan, “Chongqing and Guangdong.”
49 Gobel and Ong, Social Unrest in China.
50 Tam, “Hundreds Riot over Suspicious Death.”
51 BBC, “Riots ‘Effectively Contained.’”
52 Wang, “Jiakuai Zhuanxing Shengji.”
53 Guangdong Deputies Reviewed Government Work Report. The minimum wage in Guangdong has been increased again in May 2013 to 1550 yuan.
54 Yang, “Jizhe diaocha: Guangzhou.”
55 General Office of Guangdong Provincial Government, “Guangdongsheng Renminzhengfu Bangongting Guanyu.”
56 For example, applicants in Zhongshan City can access relevant information at the Zhongshan Portal of Migrant Population: http://www.zslg.gov.cn/.
57 Yang, “Jizhe diaocha: Guangzhou jifen.”
58 Li, “Guangzhou Jifen Ruhu Zhengce Yanxu Yinian.”
59 State Council of China, “Official Reply of the State Council.”
60 Hu, “Hu Jintao’s Speech on Building.”
61 Xinhua, “China Gini Coefficient at .474 in 2012.” Unofficial estimates put the level as high as .61: “China’s Gini Index at .61, University Report Says.”
62 Qiu, “Guangdong Moshi yu Chongqing Moshi.”
63 Zhan, “‘Chongqing Moshi’ Haozai Na,” 77.
64 Central Government of People’s Republic of China, “National Guideline on Land Utilization.”
65 Qiu, “Guangdong Moshi yu Chongqing Moshi.”
66 Huang, “Chongqing Nongdi Jiaoyi Jingyan.”
67 Qiu, “Guangdong Moshi yu Chongqing Moshi.”
68 Chongqing People’s Municipal Government, “Suggestions of the Chongqing People’s Municipal Government.”
69 Li and Gu, “Chongqingmeng yu Zhongguo Moshi.”
70 Ye, “Chongqing Moshi de Zhangben.”
71 Gerschenkron, “Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective.”
72 China Data Online, http://www.chinadataonline.org.
73 Cai, “Dui Chen Yun ‘Niaolong Jingji.’”
74 Wang Yang: Zhusanjiao yao Shixian Tenglonghuanniao.
75 Statistics is taken from General Administration of Customs of the People’s Republic of China, www.customs.gov.cn
76 Jiang, “Guangdong Wanyu Jiguan Dangyuan.”
77 Xinhua, “‘Shuangzhuanyi’ Zhanlue Dazao.”
78 People.cn, “Guangdongsheng Xinyilun Fupin Kaifa.”
79 Zhang and Chen, “Zhuanxing Guoduqi.”
80 Qu, “Comparing the Guangdong Model,” http://Caijing.com.cn.
81 Xinhua, “Siwanyi Touzi Chongqing Yifen 86 Yi.”
82 National People’s Congress of China, “Yusuanfa Xiuzhengan.”
83 Han and Cui, “Difang Zhengfu Bulie Chizi.”
84 Cartier and Tomba, “Symbolic Cities and the ‘Cake Debate.’”
85 Huang was initially vice mayor of Chongqing (2001–2009) and then became mayor in 2010.
86 Gerschenkron, “Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective.”
87 Hu, Yue, and Fu, “Wang Yang yu Bo Xilai.”
88 Zhu, “Shaoshuai Wang Yang.”
89 Suo and Chen, “Wang Yang Zuobaogao Zhizi.”
90 Bo Xilai Would Do Anything to Please Jiang Zemin.
91 Tong and He, “‘Chongqing Moshi’ yu Zhongguo.”
92 Chen, “Chongqing Senlin Bo Xilai.”
93 Wei, “1966 Nian Hongdong Quanguo.”
94 BBC, “Bo Xilai Scandal.”
95 “Chongqing Zhuanye Xiaojing Jinzhu Xiaoyuan” [Chongqing Police Stationed on Campus], Sohu.com, May 4, 2010. Accessed September 13, 2013. http://news.sohu.com/20100504/n271898642.shtml.
96 “Guowuyuan Guanyu Kaizhan Xinxing Nongcun Shehui Yanglao Baoxian Shidian de Zhidao Yijian” [Guiding Opinions of the State Council on the Trial New-pattern Rural Social Endowment Insurance], www.gov.cn, September 4, 2009. Accessed March 30, 2014. http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2009-09/04/content_1409216.htm.
97 “Chonqging na 36 yi ‘zifei gaige’” [Chongqing Set Aside 3.6 Billion for Reform], cqnews.net, June 29, 2010. Accessed March 30, 2014. http://cq.cqnews.net/sz/zwyw/201006/t20100629_4423431.htm.
98 “Minsheng Shitiao Zhuyao Neirong” [Ten Projects for Improving People’s Livelihood], Cqcb.com, September 13, 2010. Accessed June 13, 2013. http://cqcbepaper.cqnews.net/cqcb/html/2010-09/13/content_1236644.htm.
99 Zhu Xiao, “Bo Xilai: Chongqing Sanjin Santong Sanxiang Zhidu Chengxiao Mingxian” [Bo Xilai: Chongqing’s “Going Back to the Masses” and “Three Institutions” are Effective], Cqnews.net, June 10, 2010. Accessed July 9, 2013. http://cq.cqnews.net/sz/zwyw/201006/t20100610_4386462.htm.