Ambiguities in the taxonomic assignment and species delineation of botryllid ascidians from the Israeli Mediterranean and other coastlines

Abstract

Based on mtCOI sequences comparisons, recent studies reassigned the ‘dwarf Botrylloides leachii’ from the Levant as Botrylloides nigrum. Here we conducted a survey of the literature and of deposited mtCOI sequences of botryllid ascidians, elucidating ambiguities in their taxonomy. We found that the species, dwarf morph of Botrylloides leachii, Botrylloides nigrum, Botryllus aster and Botryllus arenaceus are grouped together on a single molecular taxon. Then, results of three additional markers (18S, 28S, H3) contradicted literature suggestions, revealing minute distances between Botrylloides leachii and the ‘dwarf Botrylloides leachii’. Moreover, only Botrylloides leachii and the ‘dwarf Botrylloides leachii’ develop giant ampullae as an allorecognition response. Our results raise the possibility that inadequate identification, together with faults in molecular assignment, including queries regarding the efficacy of the mtCOI as the exclusive barcoding tool in botryllid ascidians, is the major culprits responsible for the emerged inconsistencies between the mtCOI sequences and traditional taxonomy. Thus, we assign the Levantine dwarf form as Botrylloides aff. leachii.

Keywords:

• Allorecognition
• Botryllid ascidians
• mtDNA
• nuclear DNA
• species barcoding
• taxonomy

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Yana Yudkovsky for technical help, to Guy Paz for help in figures and tables preparation and to R. Brunetti from the Venice Museum of Natural History for sending us samples of Botrylloides leachii.

Disclosure statement

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests related to them.